An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that I sent to Michael on November 11.
Michael:
I was greatly cheered by your e-mail. I have been waiting to hear those wonderful words “A lot of planners are [...]
“I [See] PassionSaving.com as the Meeting Place for People Losing Confidence in [Passive Investing]“
Published in November 13th, 2008
1 Comment
“A Lot of Planners are Starting to Question
Their Passive Investing Beliefs”
Published in November 11th, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that Michael sent to me on November 10.
Rob,
I will be having dinner with Bill [the reference is to Bill Bengen, an Old School SWR researcher] tonight, in advance [...]
“It Is This Shock That Has Caused Bengen’s Conversion to Short-Term Market Timing”
Published in November 6th, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that I sent to Michael on November 6.
Michael:
I hope things have been going well with you since we last talked.
You noted in one of your e-mails from August [...]
“It Doesn’t Mean the New School is Absolutely Right and the Old School Should Be Summarily Dismissed”
Published in November 4th, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that Michael sent to me on October 23, followed by one that I sent to him on October 24.
Rob,
Just a quick email… yes, I agree pretty strongly with [...]
“If We Were Starting with a Clean Slate…No One…Would Recommend…the Old School Studies”
Published in October 30th, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that I sent to Michael on October 19.
Michael:
Again, thanks for the frank and helpful response.
We are ALL walking like lemmings to a cliff! That’s my take.
We have been [...]
“The Old School Studies Have an Extrapolation Problem of Their Own”
Published in October 29th, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that I sent to Michael on October 22.
Michael:
Thanks for your frank and helpful e-mail. I shared the e-mail with John. He sent me the words below, which I [...]
“Under [a P/E10 Value of] 30, I Find It [the Old School SWR Methodology] Still to be Quite Analytically Valid”
Published in October 28th, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that Michael sent me on October 18.
Rob,
Thank you so much for your response here. My apologies that my response will be relatively brief, but unfortunately I am [...]
“I Am Unable to Make Sense of Your Lack of Alarm Over the Effects…on Real Live Investors”
Published in October 23rd, 2008
An earlier blog entry described the background of my recent correspondence with Michael Kitces on safe withdrawal rates (SWRs). Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that I sent to Michael on October 19.
Michael:
Thanks for touching base. I am always glad to hear from you. As you note in your e-mail, I have [...]
Today's Passion
Recent Posts
-
- “Money Management Isn’t Just About Knowing the Math — It’s About Knowing Yourself”
- Podcast #31 — Today’s Understanding of How Investing Works Is Primitive
- Podcast #30 — Fear and Greed and Hope and Love
- “I [See] PassionSaving.com as the Meeting Place for People Losing Confidence in [Passive Investing]“
- Podcast #29 — Is There An Economic Depression In Your Future?
- “A Lot of Planners are Starting to Question
Their Passive Investing Beliefs” - Podcast #28 — Common Sense is the “Problem”
- Podcast #27 — The Efficient Market Theory Is a Big Bunch of Hooey
Our Calculators
Favorite Podcasts
Blogroll
- Aaron’s Blob
- Budgets Are Sexy
- Clever Dude
- Frugal Dad
- Get Rich Slowly
- Karthik’s Random Ramblings
- Market Movers
- Mrs. Micah
- No Limits Ladies
- Owning My Own Life
- Punny Money
- Quest for Four Pillars
- Shark Investor
- Texas Money Talk
- The Digerati Life
- The Kirk Report
- The Money Muse
- Tough Money Love
Categories
-
- Bear Markets
- Budgets
- Buzz Updates
- Career Change
- Community
- Discussion Boards
- Experts
- Goons
- Indexing
- Investing Basics
- Investing Strategy
- Investor Psychology
- M-Class Millionaires
- Money Management
- P/E10
- Passion Saving
- Passive Investing
- Podcasts
- Rational Investing
- Return Predictor
- Risk Evaluator
- Rob Bennett
- Saving Strategies
- Stock Valuations
- SWRs
- The New Luxuries
- TIPS/IBonds/CDs
- Uncategorized
- Value Indexing
- Wage Slavery
Favorite Blog Entries
-
- "For People Who Like to Take a 30,000 Foot View of Investing, This Is a Very Handy Little Tool"
- "The Future Cannot Be Predicted Based on Historical Empirical Observations"
- "The Predictor Would Be Better Termed a Reporter"
- "There Is Always a Reasonably Diversified Subset of the Market with Below Average PEs"
- The Rob Bennett Challenge to Passive Investing Enthusiasts
- "I Have Much More Confidence in My Ability to Understand What Is Happening"
- The Bogleheads Wiki Statement on Safe Withdrawal Rates
- I Hope You Suffer
- The Community Toilet Is Overflowing
- Fear Strikes Out
- The Confession Box
- Our Employers Should Encourage Us to Move On
- The Naked Budget
- Putting a Human Face on the "Save the Retirements!" Story
- Internet Porn and Other Wrong Numbers
- The Exceedingly Strange Standards of Investing Research
- "Securities Markets Appear to Be At Least Partially Predictable Afterall"
- "The Truth Has a Way of Emerging Eventually"
- Why I Quote Song Lyrics in My Posts
- Financial WebRing Forum Entertains (Somewhat) Honest Discussion of Valuation-Informed Indexing
- "This Is What Investing Should Be -- Calculated, Deliberate, Confident, Informed and Simple"
- Joke
- Why Is Scott Burns Afraid of Me?
- Scott Burns Distances Himself from the New School SWR Approach
- Scott Burns: "The Whole Idea that There Is a New School of SWRs Reeks of Personal Aggrandizement"
- NYT Discovers P/E10
- Forbes Fires Back at the Goons
- The Terrible Truth About Cute Fuzzy Bunny
- Jack Bogle Started Out as a Little Boy
- You're Smarter Than the Experts
- New York Times Reports on Growing Disgust with the Littler Stinkers
- Non-Money Things You Can Learn By Keeping a Budget
- Jonathan Should Take a Tip from Dustin
- Ball of Confusion
- The Investing Establishment
- Uptight (Everything's Not Allright!)
- Bogle Meets Rocky
- Where the Monkees Went Wrong
PassionSaving.com
-
- Home
- Buzz
- RobCasts
- Return Predictor
- Risk Evaluator
- Scenario Surfer
- Start Me Up
- Upsizing
- Retire Different!
- The Turned-On Budget
- Stock Drunk
- Value Indexing
- Banned at Motley Fool!
- Investing for Humans
- Community Rules!
- The Self-Directed Life
- The Million-Dollar Idea
- M-Class Millionaires
- Save Without Sacrifice
- Practical Dreamers
- For Dolphins Only
- Talking Numbers
- Heroes and Villains
- Planet Internet
- The Book I Read
- The Book I Wrote
- Don't Sue Me!
- Contact Rob
| M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| « Oct | ||||||
| 1 | 2 | |||||
| 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |
| 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 |
| 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 |
| 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 |
Archives I
Archives II
Translators
Favorite Articles
-
- Community Comments on Predicting Stock Returns
- The Experts Speak on the Risks of Holding Overvalued Stocks in Retirement
- Community Comments on Using Stock Data to Diminish Retirement Risk
- Using the Risk Evaluator to Develop Retirement Planning Strategies
- 20 Money Management Insights You'll Likely See Only Here
- 20 Dangerous Money Myths -- They Think We're Stupid!
- Why Passion Saving Works
- Rob Bennett's Favorite Saving Advice Sayings
- The Doctor Pepper of Money Sites
- The Taboo on Talking About Money Hurts Us
- Saving for Retirement Is a Dumb Idea
- How to Start Saving Money
- The Dark Side of Compounding Returns
- Unconventional Mid-Life Career Change Tips
- Fears of Those Who Retire Early
- The Late-Start Retirement Plan
- Eight Ways to Budget for Eight Budgeting Personalities
- Seven Types of Spending
- Ten Reasons for Paying Off the Mortgage
- How Did Commonsense Investing Become Controversial?
- The Case for Selling in a Stock-Market Downturn
- Stock Panic Up Close and Personal
- The Future of Behavioral Finance
- My Beef with Bull Markets
- Why Is Today's Investing Advice So Poor?
- If the Random Walk Is Real, the Efficient Market Isn't
- Passive Investing Is Dangerous
- Market Timing -- What Works and What Doesn't
- Investing Research and the Tricky Tricks Used to Trick You
- The Case Against Valuation-Informed Indexing
- Investing Discussion Boards Ban Honest Posting on Valuations!
- 20 Investing Insights from the First 54 Months
- Community Comments on The Great Safe Withdrawal Rate Debate
- Bogle and Buffett Go Together Like Chocolate and Peanut Butter
- Investing Experts Are Politicians
- 8 Paths to Financial Independence
- Give Up Television and Grow Rich
- I'm So Bored with Financial Pornography
- The Meaning of Work -- A Love Song
- Financial Infidelity and Financial Intimacy
- Smart Vacations Recharge Your Batteries
- Rob Bennett's Weaknesses as a Money Advisor
- Boy Disease, and How Suze Orman Helps
- Rob Bennett -- What Kinda Guy?
Favorites/John's Site
-
- They Got It Wrong
- Progress Reports on New School Research
- TIPS Table
- Always Insist on a Baseline
- The 4% Shocker
- Why P/E10?
- Building Blocks
- Using Stock-Return Predictions
- You Can't Count on 7%
- More Than a Number
- Rule of Thumb?
- New Standards for Financial Reporting
- Retirement Planning Insights
- Income Stream Insights
- Letters to the Editor
- Valuation-Informed Indexing
- David Dreman's Blockbuster
- Our Strong Theoretical Foundations
- The Logical Sequence
- Using All of the Data
- Paradoxes and Confusion
- The Stability of Estimates Based on Earnings Yield
- The Story Behind the Numbers
- Mean Reversion Theory
- Mean Reversions Occurs Faster When You Adjust for Valuations
- Stupid Assertions
- S&P500 Dividend Yields
- Why Dividends Are Better
- Why People Ignore Valuations
- The Wrong Lessons
- Denial Is Expensive
- Today's Skill
- Systems Engineering
- Historical Perspective of Benjamin Graham
- Applying P/E10 Outside of the S&P500
- S&P500 Returns
- S&P500 Return Sequences
- First Year Within a Decade with Returns Above 7%, 6%, 5%, and 4%
- Our Roots