feed twitter twitter facebook

A Rich Life

The Old Ideas on Saving & Investing Don't Work -- Here's What Does

  • "Valuation-Informed Indexing Is the Same Song We Sing. Glad You Belong to the Same Choir We Do."





    Carolyn McClanahan, Director of Financial Planning
    for Life Planning Partners, Inc.

  • "Retirees Now Frequently Base Their Retirement Decisions on the Portfolio Success Rates Found in Research Such as the Trinity Study.... This Is Not the Information They Need for Making Their Withdrawal Rate Decisions."




    Wade Pfau, Academic Researcher

  • "The P/E10 Tool Could Drastically Change
    How the Entire Investment Industry
    Operates and Measures Risk."





    Larry, A PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "The Your Money or Your Life Book
    for a New Generation."





    Beatrix Fernandex, Book Reviewer
    for Dollar Stretcher Site

  • "A Newer School of Thought Believes That the Safe Withdrawal Rate Depends on How Stocks Are Priced at the Time You Begin Making Withdrawals."





    Scott Burns, Dallas Morning News Finance Columnist

  • "A Fascinating Retirement Calculator."







    Michael Kitces, Maryland Financial Planner

  • "The Evidence is Pretty Incontrovertible. Valuation-Informed Indexing...Is Everywhere Superior to Buy-and-Hold Over Ten-Year Periods."




    Norbert Schenkler,
    Co-Owner of Financial WebRing Forum

  • "Every Detail Shows Rob's Respect
    for His Information and His Reader."






    Audrey Owen, Owner of Writer's Helper Site

  • "You’ve Accomplished Something Radical
    With Your Idea of Passion Saving."





    Mark Michael Lewis,
    Money, Mission & Meaning Talk Show Host

  • "Big Moves Out of Stocks Should Not Be Done at All. But Strategic Asset Allocation Can Be Done At Very Rare Times, Maybe Six Times in an Investor’s Lifetime, Three Times When the Market Is Stupidly High and Three Times When Stupidly Low."



    John Bogle, Founder of Vanguard Funds

  • "Valuation-Informed Investing and Passive Investing
    Share More of a Common Ancestry
    Than It Might Appear at First."





    Jacob Irwin, Owner of Passive Investing Blog Carnival

  • "It Is Great to See a Finance Journalist Who Understands That Valuations Matter. Efficient Market Zealotry Is Rampant in the Journalism Community. I Just Love Your Valuation-Based Return Calculator."




    Rich Toscano, Pacific Capital Associates

  • "There Is Always An Unlimited Supply of Complainers Against Any Good Idea."






    Mr. Money Mustache Blogger

  • "Rob: This Has Been One of the Most Insightful and Helpful Comments I Think Anyone Has Ever Posted. Thank You for This Lesson and for Sharing Your Knowledge on This Subject!"




    My Money Design Blogger

  • "There Is An Extensive Literature About the Predictability of Long-Term Stock Returns. There Is an Extensive Literature About Short-Term Market Timing. My Question Is About Long-Term Market Timing. The Literature Seems Slim."



    Wade Pfau, Retirement Income Professor
    at The American College

  • "Your Ideas Are Sound."







    Rob Arnott, Financial Analysts Journal Editor

  • "For Years, the Investment Industry Has
    Tried to Scare Clients Into Staying Fully Invested
    in the Stock Market at All Times, No Matter
    How High Stocks Go. It's Hooey.
    They're Leaving Out More Than Half the Story."



    Brett Arends, The Wall Street Journal

  • "There Are Time-Periods Where Stocks Are a Terrible Addition to That Portfolio. Yet Inexplicably, We As Planners STILL tend to Suggest That It Is 'Risky' to Not Own Stocks When in Reality the Only Risk Is to Our Business."




    Michael Kitces, Maryland Financial Planner

  • "Valuation-Informed Indexing Provides More Wealth for 102 of 110 of the Rolling 30-Year Time-Periods While Buy-and-Hold Did Better in Eight of the Periods."






    Wade Pfau, Academic Researcher

  • "There Is a Growing Behavioral Economics Movement, But It So Far Has Had Limited Impact. Economists Are Not Fond of the Softness and Imprecision of Psychology. These Notions Are Considered Vaguely Unprofessional and Flaky."



    Robert Shiller, Yale University Economic Professor

  • "I Would Occasionally Get a Response Post
    Saying I Was 'the Best Since Rob Bennett
    Challenged Us to Think.'"




    A Popular Bogleheads Forum Poster Named "Retired at 48" Who Was Banned for Challenging Buy-and-Hold

  • "New Research by Rob Bennett Shows That
    Even a 4% Withdrawal Rate Could Cause Failure
    If You Start Retirement When
    Stock Market Valuations Are High.”




    Bernard Kelly, Consultant

  • "FuhGedDaBouDit!"




    William Bernstein, Author of
    The Four Pillars of Investing
    (When Asked Whether We Can Use the Old School Safe Withdrawal Rate Studies to Plan Our Retirements)

  • "This [The Stock-Return Predictor]
    Is a Very Handy Little Tool."






    Felix Salmon, Market Movers Blog

  • "A Much Simpler Way to Bring
    the Valuation Issue to Focus."
    (Referring to The Stock-Return Predictor)





    Karteek Narayanaswarmy, Blogger

  • "It's Informative, It's Based on Solid Data and It Provides Useful Results." (Referring to The Stock-Return Predictor)






    Political Calculations Blog

  • "Meet Three Couples Who Left the Corporate World to Do the Kinds of Work That Satisfied Them."






    Liz Pulliam Weston, MSN Money Columnist

  • "I Like Rob's Fresh Views and Tips
    on the Subject of Saving Money."






    The Digerati Life Blog

  • "A Very Solid Approach to Investing."







    Michael Harr, Founder of Walden Advisors

  • "Rob Bennett Has Been on a Tear With One Outstanding RobCast After Another."





    John Walter Russell, Owner of
    Early-Retirement-Planning-Insights.com Site

  • "It’s Time for a Different Way to Look at Investing, and Rob Is Onto Something Here."






    Kevin Mercadante, Owner of Out of Your Rut Blog

  • "My Afternoon Train Reading."
    (Referring to Rob's Article titled
    Why Buy-and-Hold Investing Can Never Work)





    Barry Ritholtz, Owner of The Big Picture Blog

  • "What Is It With Guys Named Rob?
    Longtime Index Agitator Rob Arnott Has Now
    Been Joined on These Pages by a
    Vanguard Diehard Agitator Named Rob Bennett."




    Jim Wiandt, IndexUniverse.com Publisher

  • "He Offers a Fresh New Perspective
    that Will Motivate You to Get on Track
    With a Solid Savings Plan."





    Lynn Terry, Click Newz Blog

  • "While Browsing at www.PassionSaving.com the Other Day, I Discovered an Article Featuring Ten Unconventional Money-Saving Tips. Each of These Offers a New Way to See Money."




    J.D. Roth, Owner of Get Rich Slowly Site

  • "Rob Has Ideas About Investing That Many Bloggers Find 'Interesting.' His Posts Are Often Controversial and Always Thought Provoking."





    Miranda Marquit, Planting Money Seeds Blog

  • "Is There a Way to Turn Saving Into Something Fun? If There Was, I Bet a Lot More of Us Would Do a Lot More Saving. I Found a Website Where This Basic Premise Is Explored in Great Depth."




    The Great WeiszGuy Blog

  • "I Have Much More Confidence in My Ability to Understand What Is Happening....I Thank You for Your Public Service, and, In Another Dimension, for the Personal Courage It Took to Make It Happen."




    Elizabeth, A PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "I Was Hooked on the Idea of [Passive] Index Indexing, But Something Inside Made Me Wonder "Too Good to Be True?" and "What's the Downside?" I Happened on to Your Site and Valuation-Informed Indexing Seems to Make Sense."



    Coleen, PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "Reads Like a Casual Conversation
    with a Likable Guy Who Wants Nothing More
    Than to Help Others Experience the Same Joy
    and Happiness He Has Found."




    Kara, Reader of Rob's Book

  • "Your 'Secrets' Are Exactly Like Magic Tricks: Once Revealed, They Look So Simple, Yet You Need Somebody to Show You How It Works."





    Kramerizio, Secrets of Retiring Early Reader

  • "Rob's Da Man! Never in the History of the Diehards Forum Has One Poster, Always Making Civil and Well Thought-Out Posts, Managed to Irritate So Many Without Anyone Being Able to Articulate a Good Reason As to Why."




    Mephistopheles, Bogleheads Forum Poster

  • "I’ve Been Surprised at How Controversial This Idea Is, but If Most People Are Buying and Holding, They Are Emotionally Invested in This Strategy."





    Jennifer Barry, Live Richly Blogger

  • "The Findings for [Long-Term] Market Timing Are So Robust That It Hardly Matters How We Do It."






    Wade Pfau, Asociate Professor of Economics

  • "The Elegant Simplicity of His Ideas Throughout Warms the Heart and Startles the Brain."






    Tom Gardner, Co-Founder of the Motley Fool Site

  • "Mr. Bennett Evidences an Unusual Skill....
    You'll Have to Buy a Copy....Extraordinary....
    A Massive Heap of Crap."




    John Greaney,
    Owner of the Retire Early Home Page Site

  • "By Reading All the Information on Your Website I Was Able to Develop a Part of Me I Didn't Know I Would Be Able to Become."





    Javier, PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "Innovative Financial Thinking."







    No Limits, Ladies Blog

  • "Knowledgeable."







    Hope to Prosper Blog

  • "Holy Toledo! This Is Great Stuff!"






    Bill Schultheis, Author of
    The New Coffeehouse Portfolio

  • ""He Offers Down-to-Earth But
    Nevertheless Eye-Opening Insights About
    the Why and the How of Early Retirement."





    Secrets of Retiring Early Reader

  • "Challenges Unfounded Assumptions."







    Bill Sholar, Founder of the Early Retirement Forum

  • "Seminal."






    John Greaney, Owner of Retire Early Home Page Site
    (Pre-May 13, 2002 Version)

  • "It’s Always Good to Read Something New That Challenges Your Way of Thinking."






    Invest It Wisely Blog

  • "Rob, Thanks for All of Your Articulate, Well-Written and Well-Reasoned Commentary."






    Elle, a Poster at the Joe Taxpayer Blog

  • "Although Rob and I Don’t See Eye to Eye
    on Every Detail, His Site Is a
    Valuable Resource for Research."





    Ken Faulkenberry, Portfolio Manager

  • "Thanks, Rob. I Love Seeing So Many
    Personal Finance Bloggers Who Offer Such
    High Quality Content on Their Own Sites Come Here
    to Weigh In [on Your Ideas]."




    Married With Debt Blogger

  • "A Ton of Tremendously Useful Content."







    Network Abundance Radio

  • "Your Enthusiasm Is Infectious."







    Ruth, a PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "I Woke Up at 4:00 am and Stared at the Wall for 20 Minutes....Thank You for Doing What You Do."






    Tasha, A PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "It Might Just Give You
    a New Way of Looking at Saving."






    Kevin Surbaugh, Owner of Debt Free 4Ever Blog

  • "'Staying Too Long in a Job Where You Don’t Feel Relevant Takes a Toll,' Said Rob Bennett, Who Worked for Years in a Well-Paying Corporate Communications Job Where He Didn’t Have Enough to Do."




    The New York Times

  • "You Have Started One of the Most Interesting
    and Stimulating Discussions This Board has Seen
    in a Long Time."





    Poster at Motley Fool Site

  • "A Respected Author and Commentator, Mr. Bennett has Dedicated Himself to Educating Average Investors to Avoid the Most Common Errors."





    Liberty Watch Site

  • "I've Gone from Shattered Dreams of Early Retirement to Glimpses of Hope to Reassurance from Quantitative Research."





    Patricia, A PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "Some of the Most Helpful and Insightful Market Discussions on the Web Take Place on These Pages."





    A Poster at the Safe WithDrawal Rate Research Group
    (Founded by Rob)

  • "Rob is the Only Person I Know (If Only via Message Board) Who has Completely Opted Out of Participation in the Stock Bubble. And You Know What? He Has Benefited Immensely from Doing So."




    Poster at Motley Fool

  • "Makes the Subject of Saving Edgy and Fresh."







    Maxine, A Reader of Rob's Book

  • "Rob Bennett, the Author of a Book Called Passion Saving, Thinks the Saving Problem Is Partly One of Packaging. So He Prefers to Couch it in the Language of Freedom."





    The Wall Street Journal

  • "This Tip Comes from Rob Bennett
    of the Finance Site PassionSaving.com."






    Lifehacker.com

  • "I LOVE This Article and
    Am Proud to be Publishing It!"




    Chuck Yanikoski, Executive Director of
    The Association of Integrative Financial
    and Life Planning

  • "Rob Bennett: Some People Disagree With Him, and He Rubs a Lot of People the Wrong Way. But He Has Interesting Ideas About Valuation-Informed Indexing, and He Delves Into a Lot of What Makes a Successful Investing Strategy."



    Miranda Marquit, Planting Money Seeds Blog

  • "Rob….Wow…..Your Response Sent Shivers
    Up the Ol’ Pilgrim Spine."






    Neal Frankie, Owner of the Wealth Pilgrim Blog

  • "I Have Counseled My Clients to Allocate a Percentage to Equities Based Upon Market Valuations....I Feel Like I've Found a Kindred Spirit. Fascinating Web Site."





    Tom Behlmer, Financial Planner

  • “A Simple Age-Based Asset Allocation Formula Is Not Appropriate, and Any Sensible Asset-Allocation Formula Should Combine Both Age/Investment Horizon and Market Valuation Levels.”




    RationalInvestor.biz

  • "Had a Guest Post This Week from Rob Bennett, Where He Discusses the Benefits of Value-Informed Indexing, Which I Find Very Intriguing."





    Sustainable Personal Finance Blog

  • "I Can Appreciate Rob's Comments.... Buy-and-Hold?
    For the Most Part, a Long Obsolete Theory."






    Neal Deutsch, Certified Financial Planner

  • "Utterly Brilliant!"







    Secrets of Retiring Early Reader

  • "Your Website Is So Enjoyable That It Is Keeping Me From My Research As I Am So Excited That I Have Found Such a Valuable Resource."





    Stuart, a PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "What We're Talking About Here Really
    ...Is Empowerment."






    Motley Fool Poster

  • "The Return Predictor Is Based upon the Principle that Over the Long Term, Stock Market Prices Will Reflect the Ten-Years Earnings Growth of the Underlying Companies. Prices Return to a Common Growth Pattern."




    Links.com Review of The Stock-Return Predictor

  • "Rob’s Arguments in Favor of Value Investing Actually Make a Lot of Sense In a Way That Should Make Any Rational Buy-and-Holder Uncomfortable."





    Pop Economics Blog

  • "What I Don't Understand Is How Rob Can Correspond in Such a Sweet and Polite Way
    -- Yet He Irritates Me to No End!"





    Financial WebRing Forum Poster

  • "You Go About It in a Manner that is Catastrophically Unproductive by Adding Missionary Zeal that Inflates Your Importance and Demeans Others. The Whole Idea That There is a New School of Safe Withdrawal Rates Reeks of Personal Aggrandizement."



    Scott Burns, Dallas Morning News

  • "Inflammatory."







    Morningstar.com Site Administrator

  • “What Warren Buffett Did Was Essentially Quite Close to What Rob Bennett Has Written. Buffett Has in Fact Been Cleverly Incorporating Long-Term Market Timing Based on Valuation of the Market in His Allocation of Money to Stocks.”



    Investor Notes Blog

  • "This Report Offers A Fresh Perspective That Is Rarely Found In Other Financial Literature."






    Secrets of Retiring Early Reader

  • "Rob Bennett Says That Market Timing Based on Aggregate P/E Ratios Can Be a Far More Effective Strategy. This Claim Is Consistent With Shiller's Analysis and I Can See How It Might Be So."




    Rajiv Sethi, Economics Professor at Columbia Univeristy

  • "Retiring Early Was A Concept I Did Not Entertain. I Was Going to Retire at 65 After Putting in 40 Years. Now I Am Glad To Say That All That Has Changed."





    Secrets of Retiring Early Reader

  • "In a Couple of Days, I Had
    Devoured the Entire Book."






    Reader of Rob's Book

  • "FIRECalc May Not Be the Last Word
    on Safe Withdrawal Rates."






    Jonathan Clements, Wall Street Journal

  • "It Seems to Me That Some on This Board Feel Threatened by the Arrival of Rob and His Ideas. They Feel a Threat to Their Perceived Elite Status."





    Motley Fool Poster

  • "You've Got to Say One Thing for Rob. He Has NEVER Lowered Himself to Ad Hominen Attacks -- Subliminal or Otherwise -- on Any Other Person on This Board. Not Once. Ever. At Least Give Him Credit for That."




    Motley Fool Poster

  • "I Have Never Seen Rob Show Incivility. No Matter What. Truly Amazing. Either He Is Really the Output of an Artificial Intelligence Program, or the Man's on the Way to Becoming a Saint!"




    Early Retirement Forum Poster

  • "You're the Politest Guy on the Internet.
    Such a Soft Touch!"






    Jonathan Lewis

  • "Props for Keeping Your Cool in the Married with Debt Article. Best of Luck Combating Buy-and-Hold."






    Money Mamba Blogger

  • "I Caught Up [at the Financial Bloggers Conference] With a Fairly Controversial Financial Blogger
    Named Rob Bennett, Who Struck Me As the
    Nicest Guy Around. There -- I Said It!"




    Digerati Life Blogger

  • "In Rob Bennett's Case, He Was Banned for No Known Listed Forum Policy. Except His Viewpoint Was Different From Other Bogleheads and [He Was Perceived As] a Threat."




    Investor Junkie Blog

  • "Mr. Bennett, You Are Spot on About Integrating Some Type of Valuation Filter to One's Stock Allocation. Astute Investors Have Incorporated Some Type of 'Valuation Timing' Into Their Investment Decisions Since the Beginning of Time."



    Poster at the Psy Fi Blog

  • "His Insights Into What Is Really Going On In The Stock Market Are Quite Compelling."






    Future Storm Blog

  • "It Was an Epiphany...Valuation-Informed Indexing Beats Buy-and-Hold Over Most Long-Term Holding Periods at Much Lower Volatility."





    Sam, a PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "I Am Intrigued By Your Ideas."







    Adam Butler, Portfolio Manager

  • "I Read the Book and I Loved It.
    The Philosophy Resonated with Me.
    I Am a Believer in Your Concept."





    Dr. Peter Weiss, Author of More Health, Less Care

  • "If Your Investment Ideas Can Do for Investing
    What Weston Price’s Ideas Did for Food,
    You’ve Got Our Attention."





    End Times Hoax Blog

  • "I Have Looked at His Website and Reviewed His Research and Find It Both Compelling and Completely Logical and Common-Sense-Based."





    Poster at Free Money Finance Blog

  • "If Investors Paid More Attention to Valuations, We Would Have Fewer Boom-and-Bust Cycles. The Investing Institutions Are Definitely Going to Avoid It Because It Affects Their Income."




    Hope to Prosper Blog

  • "The Calculators on Your Site Are Great Resources. It Amazes Me How So Many People Can Say 'Valuations Matter' Yet, in the Next Breath, They'll Say That We Should Ignore Valuations."




    John Marlowe, Logistics Analyst at Hess Corporation

  • "Must Read As Per My Viewpoint
    For All Value Seekers."






    Ajit Vakil, Value Investing Congress

  • "His Approach Is Both Mathematically Rigorous
    and Easy to Understand."






    Online Investing AI Blog

  • "There Is Nothing More Doubtful of Success Than a New System. The Initiator Has the Enmity of All Who Profit By Preservation of the Old Institution and Merely Lukewarm Defenders in Those Who Gain By the New One."




    Machiavelli

  • "Difficult Subjects Can Be Explained to the Most Slow-Witted Man If He Has Not Formed Any Idea of Them. But the Simplest Thing Cannot Be Made Clear to the Most Intelligent Man If He Believes He Knows Already What Is Laid Before Him."



    Tolstoy

  • "I Am Not Afraid. I Was Born to Do This."







    Joan of Arc

  • "I Certainly Have Seen the Academic Profession Squelching Unfashionable ideas and Have Often Been on the Wrong Side of It. Kuhn Shows How Most Pathbreaking Scientific Ideas Are Rejected at First, Usually for Decades.”




    Carol Osler, Brandeis International Business School

  • "First They Ignore You, Then They Ridicule You, Then They Fight You, Then You Win."






    Ghandi

  • "We Cannot Assume the Existence of Predictability Just Because There Are No Studies That Fully Reject It."






    Valeriy Zakamulin, Economics Professor

  • "I Am Also Extremely Grateful to Rob Bennett for Motivating This Topic and Contributing His Experience and Encouragement."





    Wade Pfau, Academic Researcher

  • "Rob Bennett Was an Early Pioneer in 3rd Generation Modeling by Advocating (Through Various Online Forums) that Withdrawal Rates Must Be Adjusted for Market Valuations Consistent with Research by Campbell and Shiller."



    Todd Tresidder, Financial Mentor Blog

  • "I Am Fascinated by the Growing Body of Research that Revolves Around the P/E10 Ratio by Robert Shiller, Doug Short, Wade Pfau, Michael Kitces, John Hussman, Crestmont Research, Jim Otar, Mike Philbrick, Adam Butler & Rob Bennett."



    Kay Conheady in Advisor Perspectives

  • "Rob Is an Enigma in the Personal Finance World. He Has Interesting Theories on Investing Based on Market Valuations. But He Weaves a Tale Which Makes the Stories of Alexander Litvinenko & Gareth Williams Seem Tame by Comparison."



    Don't Quit Your Day Job Blog

  • "In Recent Years, the 4 Percent Rule
    Has Been Thrown Into Doubt."






    The Wall Street Journal

  • "A Safe Withdrawal Rate Is Very Dependent
    on the Valuation of the Stockmarket
    at the Retirement Date."





    Economist Magazine

  • "I Have Read Everything I Can About Valuation-Informed Indexing. Buy-and-Hold Is Extremely Problematic. I Respect the Passion, Hard Work and Research That You Have Put Into This Very Important Issue. Your Work Has Huge Value."



    Carl Richards, Owner of Clearwater Asset Management

  • "The World of Personal Finance Blogging Needs More Rob Bennetts. He’s Passionate. He’s Intelligent. He’s Writing Things That Go Against the Grain."





    Financial Uproar Blog

  • "Beyond Awesome."







    Larry, a PassionSaving.com Site Visitor

  • "The Wealth Management Industry Seems Intent on Containing This Discussion for Fear Clients Might Discover that the Emperor Has No Clothes."





    Adam Butler, Portfolio Manager

  • "Recommended Reading."







    Jesse's Cafe Americain Blog

  • “All Who Are Still Holding Equities at Present Levels Because Their Financial Adviser Insists that Timing Market Cycles Is Impossible to Do -- Read This!"





    Juggling Dynamite Blog

  • "The Fact that Aggressive and Short-Term Market Timing Was Unproductive Did Not Mean That There Were Never Times When It Would Be Wealth-Maximizing to Get Out of the Market."



    Scott Burris,Director of the Center for
    Health Law, Policy and Practice

  • "The Amount of Return You Can Expect From a Diversified Equity Portfolio Is Inversely Correlated to the Market Valuation at the Start of the Holding Period. It Is One of the Most Robust Statistical Relationships in Modern Finance."




    Todd Tresidder, Financial Mentor Blog

  • "Why Would Your Job Be Jeopardized
    By Such a Sensible Claim?"





    Marcelle Chauvet, Econmics Professor
    at University of California

  • "Received Worrisome E-Mail from Rob Bennett. Warns of Risk with Buy-and-Hold Investing
    -- I Have No Clue."





    Vivek Wadhaw, Business Week Columnist

  • "As Attorney, Tax Expert and Financial Writer Rob Bennett Told Us, the Problem Is That, By the Time Shiller Published His Research, Many Big Names Had Already Endorsed Buy-and-Hold."




    ZeroHedge.com

  • "This Seems to Me to Be a Fundamental Challenge to Some of the Most Basic Tenets of the Boglehead Paradigm."






    Bogleheads Forum Poster

  • "You Want to be Very, Very Wary of Anything Connected with Rob Bennett, the Most Infamous Troll in the History of Investing Forums on the Internet."





    Alex Fract, Owner of Bogleheads Forum

  • “I’ve Had My Fill of Those Long-Winded Posts that Include Distortions, Unsubstantiated Claims, Misquotes and Comments Taken Out of Context.”




    Mel Lindauer, Co-Author of
    The Bogleheads Guide to Investing

  • "Haven't You Noticed Yet That NO ONE Discusses Your Ideas, NO ONE Mentions Your Name, NO ONE Goes To Your Web Site."





    One of the Greaney Goons

  • "I've Had Similar Experiences. I Know of Two Young Professors Who Wanted to Do Research on Fundamental Index and Reported to Me That Their Colleagues Advised Them That This Line of Research Could Derail Their Career Prospects."



    Rob Arnott, Financial Analysts Journal Editor

  • "As with Drug Studies Funded by Drug Companies, It Would Be Churlish to Suppose that the Chicago School of Business Was in the Bag. But It Would Also Be Idealistic to Assume That There Was No Funding Bias at All."




    Bogleheads Poster

  • "This Sort of Intimidation Is Not Acceptable. The Cigarette and Pharmaceutical Industries Found Research Supporting Their Products By Funding It. But That Was Big Money Supporting Outcomes, Not Dissuading Others."




    Lyn Graham, 25-Year CPA

  • "Financial Economists Gave Little Warning to the Public About the Fragility of Their Models. There Is No Ethical Code for Professional Economic Scientists. There Should Be One."



    Paper Titled The Financial Crisis and
    the Systemic Failure of Academic Economics

  • "The Situation [Referring to the Intimidation Tactics Used to Silence Academic Researcher Wade Pfau's Reporting of the Dangers of Buy-and-Hold Investing Strategies] Seems Well Below Any Professional and Academic Acceptable Standards."



    Albert Sanchez Graells, Law Lecturer

  • Many Academics Can Become Quite Strident When Their Views Are Challenged. Academia Is Often Subject to Self-Serving Bias That Obliterates Ethical Bounds."





    Ted Sichelman, Law Professor

  • "I Don't Like Too Much the Conspiracy Idea. I Am Not Pressured By Anyone in My Research."






    Roberto Reno, Economics Professor

  • "This Is What Investing Should Be -- Calculated, Deliberate, Confident, Informed and Simple."






    Aaron Friday, Owner of Aaron's Blob Blog

  • "It Is Obvious that Rob, in Attempting to Identify New Safe Withdrawal Rate Strategies...Is Goring Your Ox. If Rob Improves on [the] Safe Withdrawal Rate Methodology, the Implication Is Clear: You Are All, Metaphorically, Out of Business."



    Bogleheads Poster

  • "I Applaud His Effort to Inject Another Piece of Objectivity Into a Very Complex, Highly Subjective Topic -- Making Money in the Market."





    Bogleheads Poster

  • "Naturally, I Am Finding That Valuation-Informed Indexing Can Allow You to Reach a Wealth Target With a Lower Saving Rate and to Use a Higher Withdrawal Rate in Retirement Than You Could With a Fixed Allocation."



    Wade Pfau, Professor of Retirement Income
    at The American College

  • "A Careful Examination of Past Returns Can Establish Some Probabilities About the Prospective Parameters of Return, Offering Intelligent Investors a Basis for Rational Expectations About Future Returns."




    Jack Bogle, Founder of Vanguard Funds

  • "The Ability to Estimate the Long-Term Future Returns of the Major Asset Classes Is Perhaps the Most Important Investment Skill That An Indivisual Can Possess."




    William Bernstein, Author of The Four Pillars of Investing

  • "The Stock Market Resembles Roulette. In Both Cases, the Accuracy of Sensible Forecasts Rises Over Time."






    Andrew Smithers, Co-Author of Valuing Wall Street

  • "Returns Are for the Most Part a Matter of Simple Arithmetic...Much of Our Industry Seems Fearful of Basic Arithmetic of This Sort."





    Rob Arnott, Financial Analysts Journal Editor

  • "How Can It Be That One-Year Returns Are So Apparantly Random and Yet Ten-Year Returns Are Mostly Forecastable? In Looking at One-Year Returns, One Sees a Lot of Noise. But Over Longer Time Intervals the Noise Effectively Averages Out and Is Less Important."




    Yale Economics Professor Robert Shiller

  • "The Notion That Rich Valuations Will Not Be Followed By Sub-Par Long-Term Returns Is a Speculative Idea That Runs Counter to All Historical Evidence. It Is an Iron Law of Finance That Valuations Drive Long-Term Returns."




    John Hussman

  • "It's January and the Temperature Is Below Freezing. If You Asked Me Whether It Will be Warmer or Cooler Next Tuesday, I Would Be Unable to Say. However, If You Asked Me What Temperature to Expect on April 9, I Could Predict "Warmer Than Today" and Almost Surely Be Right."



    Michael Alexanfer, Author of Stock Cycles

  • "If the Response Is "Who Knew?", It Won't Be Much Comfort for Retirees in the Employment Line at Wal-Mart. This is Especially True Since a Rational Understanding of History and the Drivers of Longer-Term Stock Returns Can Help Retirees To Avoid That Surprise."




    Ed Easterling, Author of Unexpected Returns

  • "New of the Demise of the Random Walk Has Only Very Slowly Spread, In Part Because Its Overthrow Came as a Shock. If the Random Walk Hypothesis Were Correct, the Most Likely Return Would Be the Historic Average Return. The Evidence, However, Is Strongly Against This."



    Andrew Smithers, Co-Author of Valuing Wall Street

  • "I Don't Think We Can Debate the Merits of This Type of Forecasting [Referring to the Numbers Generated by The Stock-Return Predictor] Unless We Believe 'This Time It's Different.'"



    Poster at Bogleheads Forum
    (Before the Ban on Honest Posting Was Adopted There)

  • "I've Seen Absolutely Nothing From You That I Can Use in a Tangible Fashion to Formulate an Investment Plan. Your Ideas Are So Mushy That It's a Complete Waste of Time to Even Consider Them."




    Bogleheads Forum Poster

  • "Do You Really Think Your Tool
    [The Stock-Return Predictor]
    Is 'Wiser' Than the Market?
    If It Was That Easy,
    Everybody Would Be Doing It."



    Bogleheads Forum Poster

  • "The Expected Return of Stocks [As Reported By The Stock-Return Predictor] Needs To Be At Least the Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS) Rate for Stock Investing To Make Sense."




    Bogleheads Forum Poster

  • "I Have Used Valuations to Adjust My Asset Allocation For Many Years With Very Favorable Results."





    Poster at Bogleheads Forum
    (Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting)

  • "I Don't Care If You Do or Don't Believe That the Market Will Behave Similarly in the Future As It Has in the Past. Either Way, This [The Stock-Return Predictor] Is an Excellent Way to Understand What the Market Has Done In the Past."


    Poster at Bogleheads Forum
    [Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting]

  • "My Role Is To Give People Who Don't Like What the Historical Stock-Return Data Says About the Effect of Valuations on Long-Term Returns Somebody To Yell At On Internet Discussion Boards."



    Rob Bennett at Bogleheads Forum
    (Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting)

  • "It Really Is a Shame and Indefensible That So Many Feel the Need to Jump Into It With No Interest of Posting on the Topic But Just to Disrupt. Are You That Insecure? Some on the Forum Have an Interest in This Topic. If You Don't, Stay Out!"



    Poster at Bogleheads Forum
    [Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting]

  • "Irrational Behavior Does Follow Patterns. But How Many Experts in Behavioral Finance Believe That Such Knowledge Can Be Used to Predict Markets? Basically, None. Your Model Cannot Attain the Level of Predictive Value You Claim."



    Poster at Bogleheads Forum
    [Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting]

  • "The Safe Withdrawal Rate Studies Are Based on History. This [The Retirement Risk Evaluator] Shows, Based on the Same History, What the Probabilities Are for the Future at Various Starting Points. If the First Has Value, Then Surely This Does Too."



    Poster at Bogleheads Forum

  • "There Are Hundreds of People Who Contributed to This. This Calculator [The Stock-Return Predictor] Demonstrates in a Compelling Way the Power of This New Internet Discussion-Board Communications Medium."




    Rob Bennett at the Bogleheads Forum
    (Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting)

  • "A P/E10 of'26' Is Bad. Now Look at the 30-Year Return Predicted by the Calculator -- 5.4 Percent Real. That's Not Bad. There Are All Sorts of Strategic Implications That Follow From Understanding That Stocks Provide Different Sorts of Returns Over Different Sorts of Time-Periods."




    Rob Bennett

  • "I Would Never Invest in Anything Without Having Any Idea What the Expected Return Is. For Instance, I Would Not Walk Into a Bank And Say "I'll Take One Certificate of Deposit, Please" WIthout Asking What Rate They Are Offering."



    Poster at Bogleheads Forum
    [Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting]

  • "I've Seen Things Said on Investing Boards That I Have Never Heard Said in Discussions of Any Non-Investing Topic. The Question of Whether Valuations Affect Long-Term Returns Is a Topic That Causes People More Emotional Angst Than Does Abortion or Impeachment Proceedings or the War in Iraq."



    Rob Bennett at the Bogleheads Forum

  • "It's Not Possible For Those Who Have Come to Believe That Stocks Are Always Best to Accept that Valuations Matter. The Two Beliefs Are Mutually Exclusive. If Valuations Matter, There Is Obviously Some Valuation Level At Which Stocks Are Not Best. The Two Paradigms Cannot Be Reconciled."


    Rob Bennett

  • "The Great Safe Withdrawal Rate Is Over. Rob Bennett Has Won.The Technical Evidence Supporting This Assertion Is Rock Solid."




    John Walter Russell,
    Owner of the Early Retirement Planning Insights Site
    [This Statement Was Put Forward on August 3, 2003.]

  • "I Am Afraid that the Emperor SWR [for "Safe Withdrawal Rate"] Has No Clothes."





    A Poster at the Early Retirement Forum
    [This Statement Was Put Forward on October 8, 2003.]

  • "I Cite You and John Walter Russell in My Paper as the Earliest and Strongest Advocates of This Approach [New School Safe Withdrawal Rate Research]."




    Wade Pfau, Professor of Retirement Income
    at The American College

  • "Dear Rob -- I Just Became Aware of Your Past Research in September. Since Then, I've Read Archives From Many Discussion Boards and Websites, and I Always Find Your Writing to Be Very Interesting and Intriguing."



    Wade Pfau, Professor of Retirement Income
    at The American College

  • "I Think Rob Bennett Did Provide An Important Contribution in Terms of Describing a Way for P/E10 to Guide Asset Allocation for Long-Term Conservative Investors. I Also Think He Was Right on the Issue of Safe Withdrawal Rates."


    Wade Pfau, Professor of Retirement Income
    at The American College

  • "What Studies Show This [That Long-Term Timing Doesn't Work]? In Particular, Are There Some Academic Studies That I Haven't Found Yet? That's All I Want to Know."




    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau at the Bogleheads Forum After His Own Search of the Literature Turned Up Not a Single Such Study

  • "Because the Precise Timing of This Mean Reversion Is Not Known in Advance, Expecting the Result to Happen in the Short-Term Will Not Be Possible. But Long-Term Investors Who Can Be Patient Can Wait for This Mean Reversion and Will Eventually Come Out Ahead."




    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau

  • "Your Work Is at Odds with the Ethos of the Board -- Here the Theme is John Bogle's Philosophy, Which Eschews Market Timing. This Board Came Into Existence to ESCAPE One Individual, the Very Individual With Whom You Have Openly Aligned Yourself."




    A Lindaurhead (to Researcher Wade Pfau)

  • "The Problem With Long-Term Market Timing Is That It Takes Too Long to Find Out If You Are Right or Wrong."






    A Poster at the Bogleheads Forum

  • "Why Is It Such an Odious Violation of the Tenets of Bogleheadism to Explore Whether Someone Who Has Enough Patience Might Be Able to Benefit from the Transitory Nature of Speculative Returns (the Idea That the P/E Ratio Eventually Ends Up Where It Started)?"




    A Poster at the Bogleheads Forum

  • "Let Me Explain Why I Posted About This Here. Valuation-Informed Indexing Has Had Critics for Years. But Until Norbert Did It In 2008, Nobody Seemed to Have Provided a Serious Investigation of It. I Couldn't Understand Why. That Bothered Me."



    Researcher Wade Pfau at the Bogleheads Forum
    (Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting)

  • "If You Really Don't Like Market Timing in Any and All Forms, You May Not See Any Point in an Empirical Investigation. You View Me as One of a Long Line of Hucksters Trying to Sell You Some Snake Oil. I Don't Want to Be Such a Person."



    Researcher Wade Pfau at the Bogleheads Forum
    (Prior to the Ban on Honest Posting)

  • "Having a Completely Ineleastic Demand for Equities Is a Bit Bonkers. No One Acts That Way with Life's Other Important Commodities. Campbell Advocates a Linear Valuations-Based Strategy so That You Wouldn't Be Making Big Changes. This Would Be Like Rebalancing But More Flexible."



    A Poster at the Bogleheads Forum

  • "The Whole Idea of Valuation-Informed Indexing Belongs to You. Do You Mind if I call the Paper 'Valuation-Informed Indexing'? I Would Give You Credit. I Have Been Toying With the Idea of Sending the Paper to the Journal of Finance, Which Is the Most Prestigious Journal in Academic Finance."


    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau, in an E-Mail to Rob

  • "I Definitely Need to Cite You as the Founder of Valuation-Informed Indexing, As I Have Not Found Anyone Else Who Can Lay Claim to That. Shiller Pointed Out the Predictive Power of P/E10 But Never Discussed How to Incorporate It Into Asset Allocation, As Far As I Know."




    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau

  • "I Tested a Wide Variety of Assumptions About Asset Allocation, Valuation-Based Decision Rules, Whether the Period Is 10, 20, 30 or 40 Years, and Lump-Sum vs. Dollar-Cost Averaging To Show That the Results Are Quite Robust to Changes In Any of These Assumptions."




    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau

  • "Yes, Virginia, Valuation-Informed Indexing Works!"




    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau
    (Wade Holds a Ph.D. in Economics from Princeton.)
    (The Buy-and-Hold Mafia Threatened to Get Wade Fired From His Job When He Reported His Findings.)

  • "I Wrote Up the Programs to Test Your Valuation-Informed Indexing Strategies Against Buy-and-Hold and I Am Quite Excited. You Say in the RobCast That VII Should Beat Buy-and-Hold About 90 Percent of the Time. I Am Getting Results That Support This."




    Academic Researcher Wade Pfau

  • "Never Underestimate the Power of a Dominant Academic Idea to Choke Off Competing Ideas, and Never Underestimate the Unwillingness of Academics to Change Their Views in the Face of Evidence. They Have Decades of Their Research and Academic Standing to Defend."




    Jeremy Grantham

  • "There's So Much That's False and Nutty
    in Modern Investing Practice."






    Warren Buffett

  • "Following Conventional Wisdom Has Led a Generation of Investors Down the Road to Ruin."






    Steve Hanke

  • "It Is Sad That the Idea That Price Doesn't Matter...Should Ever Have Been Seriously Considered".






    Andrew Smithers, Co-Author of Valuing Wall Street

  • "The Conventional Wisdom of Modern Investing Is Largely Myth and Urban Legend."





    Rob Arnott, Former Editor of
    Fianncial Analysts Journal

  • "Economics Is a Dog's Breakfast of Theoretical Ideas and Alleged Causal Relationships That Are At All Times Unproven and In Dispute."





    Terence Corcoran, Editor of National Post

  • "Since They Did Not Diagnose the Disease, There Is Little Popular Confidence That They Know the Cure. What If Economics Is, Actually, At the Same Level as Medicine Was When Doctors Still Believed in the Application of Leeches?"




    Gideon Rachman, Financial Times

  • "One of the Most Remarkable Errors
    in the History of Economics."



    Yale Economics Professor Robert Shiller
    (Referring to the Logical Leap from the Finding That Short-Term Price Changes Are Unpredictable to the Conclusion That the Market Sets Prices Properly)

  • "Everything Has Fallen Apart."






    Peter Bernstein, Author of Against the Gods
    (Referring to Old Views About How Markets Work)

  • "We Wonder Why Funds and Banks, Full of the Best and Brightest, Have Made Such a Mess of Things. Part of the Reason Is That We Have Taught Economic Nonsense to Two Generations of Students."




    John Mauldin, Thoughts From the Frontline

  • "Perhaps Most Scandalously, the Theory [Behind Buy-and-Hold] Remained Received Wisdom Long After Empirical and Theoretical Arguments Had Demolished It Within the Academic Community."




    John Authers, Financial Times

  • "I Love the Humans Dearly (the Title of the Book I Am Writing Is Investing for Humans: How to Get What Works on Paper to Work in Real Life) But They Can Be a Trial at Times. Hey! Helping the Humans Learn What It Takes to Invest Effectively Is Not All That Different From Being Married!



    Rob Bennett

  • "We Are Going to See Hearts Melt Following the Next Crash. I Will Be Working Side-By-Side With All of My Many Buy-and-Hold Friends to Rebuild Our Broken Economy."





    Rob Bennett

  • "Wow, I Did Not Realize You Had Achieved This Much Success and Had Many Devoted Believers/Followers. That’s Great, Then Ignore the Opposition. It Is Great to Have Opposition: That Means You Are Doing Something Right."




    Robert Savickas, Associate Finance Professor
    at George Washington University

  • "I Do NOT Believe I Know It All. I Believe That Shiller Discovered Something Very Important and It Appalls Me That More People Are Not Exploring the Implications of His Findings. My Aim Is To Launch a National Debate."




    Rob Bennett

  • "I Can See How Many Readers Would Be Put Off by the Somewhat Sensational/Scandalist Tone and Would Not Persevere to Read, Thinking You Are Losing Your Mind."




    Robert Savickas, Associate Finance Professor
    at George Washington University

  • "I LOVE Everything About Buy-and-Hold Other Than the Failure to Encourage Investors to Take Price Into Consideration When Setting Their Stock Allocations. That's a Mistake That Was Made Because Shiller’s Research Was Not Available at the Time The Strategy Was Being Developed."



    Rob Bennett

  • "Valuation-Informed Indexing Sounds Like a Real Thing. If It Is and I Can Thoroughly Understand It, Then It Will End Up In My Classrooms and in My Students' Minds (Of Course, With References to You and Wade)."




    Robert Savickas, Associate Finance Professor
    at George Washington University

  • "I Can Confirm Wade Pfau's Experience. Whenever I Send My Papers to the Financial Analysts Journal or Similar Traditional Journals, I Get Rejected."





    Joachim Klement, CIO at Wellershoff & Partners

  • "As a Fan of Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, I Know That Progress Can Be Frustratingly Slow and What Is Typically Needed Is Either a Crisis or the Ascent of a New Generation of Scientists Who Did Not Build Their Careers on the Old Models and Theories."




    Joachim Klement, CIO at Wellershoff & Partners

  • "We Trace the Deeper Roots [of the Financial Crisis] to the Economics' Profession's Insistence on Constructing Models That, By Design, Disregard the Key Elements Driving Outcomes in Real World Markets."




    Knowledge@Wharton

  • "Rob Gets Himself So Worked Up Over What Someone Else Is Doing With Their Own Money and Not Bothering Rob in the Least. As Long As They Aren't Knocking on Your Basement Door, What Do You Care? They Are Happy and Content. Leave Well Enough Alone and Focus on Your Own Account."


    Dab, One of the Greaney Goons

  • "I've Been on Forum Since the BBS Days and I Think Rob is Special. He Could Be an Internet Meme If He Put Some Effort Into It. Someday, He Will Realize That the Only Thing He's Good At Is Being an Epic Loser. He Just Needs to Embrace That Idea and Run With It. Watch Out, LOLCats, Here Comes Pathetic Guy!"


    Wabmaster, One of the Greaney Goons

  • "Your Lies Are Not Even in the Realm of the Possible, Much Less Actually Credible, Much Less Actually True."






    Drip Guy, One of the Greaney Goons

  • "I'm Your Friend. I Am Not a Boil on Your Ass."






    Rob Bennett, In a Response Comment
    to One of the Greaney Goons

  • "You Guys [the Greaney Goons] Are the Same Jokers Who Have Done This Before, Sparring with Rob Over Nonsensical Issues On This Site and Others, Leveling Personal Attacks, and You Don't Even Use Real Names! Rob Is Entitled to His Opinion, But the Fact That You Challenge Every Jot and Tittle of What He Says Makes It Clear You Have An Unholy Agenda. Please Take It Elsehwere."

    Kevin Mercadante,
    Owner of the Out of Your Rut Site

  • "Rob, Take This As Friendly Advice. You're a Smart and Articulate Guy and You Could Be Making Valuable Contributions to This Discussion. I've Dealt with the Mentally Ill Before and I've Found That They Sometimes Can Be Reasonable If Gently Redirected."



    Goon Poster

  • "Always Remember Others May Hate You, But Those Who Hate You Don't Win Unless You Hate Them, and Then You Destroy Yourself."





    Richard Nixon

  • "I’m a Numbers Guy. And I Believe I Understand Rob’s Thesis, that Future Returns, Over the Next Decade, Have a Tight Inverse Correlation to the PE10 for the Starting Point. Remember, Correlation Doesn’t Need to be 100%, Only That There’s a Bell Curve of Potential Outcomes that Shift Meaningfully Based on the Input."


    Owner of Joe Taxpayer Blog

  • "What a Difference a Threat to Get the Father of Two Small Children Fired From His Job Has on an Investing Discussion, Eh? Long Live Buy-and-Hold! It’s Science! With a Marketing Twist!"




    Rob, Referring to the Wade Pfau Matter

  • "I Respect Rob and His Analysis. He's Bright, Energetic and Passionate. [The Goon Stuff] Is Really Nonsense. I Enjoy a Thought-Provoking Conversation With People I Respect."





    Owner of Joe Taxpayer Blog

  • "The Fact that Shiller is a Proponent of the Approach Takes it from a Fringe View to Mainstream, in my Opinion."






    Owner of Joe Taxpayer Blog

  • "I Have had Academic Researchers Tell Me That They Dream of the Day When They Will be Able to do Honest Research Once Again. I Have had Investment Advisors Tell me That They Dream of the Day When They Will be Able to Give Honest Investing Advice Again."



    Rob Bennett

  • "Let’s Call a Spade a Spade, Shall We? Wade Pfau Stole Your Research and Put His Name on it, Throwing You Just a Tiny Crumb of Acknowledgement to Ward Off a Lawsuit. He’s Profiting Handsomely By His Theft, Leading a Charmed Life, Widely Published, Widely Respected. While Rob Bennett Continues to Toil in Total Obscurity. It’s So Incredibly Unfair, I Think If It Happened to Me, It Could Actually Drive Me Insane."

    One of the Greaney Goons

Navigation Menu 
  • About Us
    • Rob’s Bio
    • Rob’s Bio
    • Contact Rob
    • Rob’s Book
    • Don’t Sue Me!
  • Blog
  • Passion Saving
    • 20 Dangerous Money Myths — They Think We’re Stupid!
    • 10 Unconventional Money Saving Tips
    • Why Your Money or Your Life Rocked the World
    • This Book Saves Marriages — The Complete Tightwad Gazette
    • How to Start Saving Money
  • Valuation-Informed Indexing
    • Why Buy-and-Hold Investing Can Never WorkThe Buy-and-Holders are not evil people. They are smart and good people. They made a mistake. They were so excited about their early findings that they experienced cognitive dissonance when the mistake was revealed. They painted themselves into a corner and now don’t know how to get out. This article explains how the mistake was made and how we came to find ourselves in the trap we are in today.
    • About Valuation-Informed IndexingBackground, Basics and Links to Materials Giving More In-Depth Information
    • The Stock-Return PredictorStocks are NOT always worth buying. That’s a Wall Street lie! This calculator performs a regression analysis on the 140 years of historical stock-return data to reveal the most likely annualized 10-year return for stocks starting from any valuation level. It essentially tells you the price tag for stocks so that you can know whether they are worth buying or not.
    • The Retirement Risk EvaluatorRob pointed out the errors in the Old School safe withdrawal rate studies in May 2002. That post kicked off the biggest controversy in the history of the internet. Today, The Wall Street Journal, Smart Money and The Economist all acknowledge that Rob had it right all along. But they still don’t provide calculators that give the right numbers! The safe withdrawal rate is not a constant number but VARIES with changes in the valuation level that applies on the day the retirement begins. This calculator provides all the details you need for effective planning.
    • The Investor’s Scenario SurferI have run this calculator hundreds of time. it is in my assessment the most powerful tool for learning how stock investing works available today. You have the option of choosing a new stock allocation in each year of a realistic 30-year sequence of returns. You can compare your results with what you would have achieved with a Buy-and-Hold strategy. You will find that Valuation-Informed Indexing strategies yield larger portfolios in 90 percent of your tests of the concept. What matters is what happens in the long term! This tool tells you what strategies give the best results in the long term.
    • The Investment Strategy TesterIf you are worried about losses you have suffered in recent years, you can use this tool to learn what you need to do to get back on the track to early financial freedom. The Strategy Tester lets you design a strategy you want to check out. Then it runs the hundreds of Scenario Surfer tests to see how the strategy compares with other possibilities you identify. The color-coded graphic gives you a good idea of what the odds are of good and bad outcomes for up to four investing strategies at a time.
    • The Returns Sequence Reality CheckerWe all root for price gains in the stock market. Should we? This calculator says “no!” Today’s price increase lowers tomorrow’s price increase. This has been so for the entire history of the market. So the question is whether you should want to pay more for stocks now or later. You are far better off paying more later because that means you get to acquire more gain-producing goodness earlier in life and thus you will enjoy more compounding return magic. This one will blow your mind. It’s a very simple concept but a highly counter-intutive one and one that will someday soon change how we all think about stock investing.
    • Nine Valuation-Informed-Indexing Portfolio Allocation StrategiesThis is the most popular of the 200 hour-long RobCasts that I provide at the site. It explores the nuts-and-bolts aspects of Valuation-Informed Indexing — How often do you change your allocation and by how much?
  • The Buy-and-Hold Crisis
    • Academic Researcher Silenced by Threats to Get Him Fired From His Job After Showing Dangers of Buy-and-Hold Investing StrategiesMy aim is to get this story reported on the front page of the New York Times. On the day that happens, all the nastiness will stop. We will all be working together to bring the economic crisis to an end and to enter the greatest period of economic growth in our history.
    • Academic Researcher Silenced By Threats to Get Him Fired From His Job After Showing Dangers of Buy-and-Hold Investing Strategies — Teaser VersionThis is a briefer version of the same article, the article that I believe is the most important one that I have written in my 30-year journalism career. I believe that the story told at this web site is the most important economic and political story of any of our lifetimes and this article sums up the key points in one little package of dynamite. If Buy-and-Hold were a legitimate strategy, every Buy-and-Holder would be ashamed to learn that even one academic researcher was threatened. We cannot move forward so long as the intimidation tactics of the Buy-and-Holders dominate all discussions of what works in stock investing. I use this short version of the article in my e-mail campaigns aimed at getting researcher and stock advisors and bloggers and journalists and policymakers involved in our effort to open the internet up to honest posting on ALL investing topics. Please help get others involved if you can. We are all in this together!
    • Corruption in the Investing Advice Field — The Wade Pfau StoryThis article provides links to all of my reports on my 16 months of correspondence with Academic Researcher Wade Pfau, the collaboration that produced the research we co-authored that shows millions of middle-class investors how to reduce the risk of stock investing by 70 percent (Ssshh! The Wall Street Con Men don’t want this one getting out!) If you retain doubts re whether Valuation-Informed Indexing is a real thing, looking over the materials available at this page and then reading a few of the reports that strike you as particularly important will dispel them. I believe that Wade will someday win a Nobel prize for the work he did here. The reports show his own skepticism and his transformed into excited BELIEVER in the Valuation-Informed Indexing concept.
    • The Bennett/Pfau Research Showing Middle-Class Investors How to Reduce the Risk of Stock Investing by 70 PercentYou do not have to take on a large amount of risk to obtain good returns. Why should you? When you buy an index fund, you are buying a tin share in the productivity of the U.S. economy. The U.S. economy has been sufficiently productive to support an average annual stock return of 6.5 percent real for 140 years now. So that’s what you can expect if you invest in a sensible way. But you are not being sensible if you follow a Buy-and-Hold strategy. You MUST consider price when buying stocks just as much as you must consider price when buying anything else. This is the most important investing research published in 30 years. It frees all of us from dependence on Wall Street “experts.”
    • Buy-and-Hold Caused the Economic CrisisThe first step to curing an illness is coming up with a correct diagnosis. What we have been hearing thus far about what caused the economic crisis is Democrats yelling at Republicans and Republicans yelling at Democrats. This political attack-game gibberish will not cut it. We borrowed huge amounts of money from our future selves to finance the insane bull of the late 1990s. Now we are our future selves! Now we are paying the price! It hurts to know we caused this. Buy you know what? We never have to suffer through something like this again once we acknowledge the realities.
    • The True Cause of the Current Financial Crisis — Questions and AnswersYale Economics Professor Robert Shiller predicted the economic crisis in his book “Irrational Exuberance,” published in March 2000. How did he know? Shiller knows how stock investing works. He knows that the Pretend Money created during times of overvaluation ALWAYS disappears over the course of 10 years or so. When that money disappears from our portfolios, we cannot afford to spend as much. So tens of thousands of businesses fail and millions lose their jobs. We avoid economic crises by avoiding out-of-control bull markets. We avoid out-of-control bull markets by letting investors know the truth — When stocks are selling at insanely inflated prices, they offer a very poor long-term value proposition. The lies that Wall Street tells about stocks are destroying out free-market economic system.
    • Investing Discussion Boards Ban Honest Posting on ValuationsLots of people hate me. There was a time when I was receiving fresh death threats in my e-mail inbox on an almost daily basis. But lots of people love me too. Thousands of my fellow community members have told me that I am the first person who ever described how stock investing works in a way that truly hangs together. This article offers 101 comments of my fellow community members asking the Buy-and-Holders to knock off the funny business and permit civil and reasoned discussion of the last 30 years of peer-reviewed academic research. This article reveals the emotionalism of the Buy-and-Holders and it is the fact that Buy-and-Hold causes such emotionalism that tells me that it can never work in the long run.
    • Wall Street Journal Calls Buy-and-Hold a “Myth,” Endorses Valuation-Informed IndexingLot of smart people know that Buy-and-Hold is a big pile of smelly garbage. They are afraid to speak out today because they know what will happen to them if they do. But they try to position themselves for the post-next-crash period, when “Buy-and-Hold” will be an obscene phrase. Bret Arends tells us that the Wall Street Con Men “are leaving out half the story.” Precisely so. The purpose of this web site is to let you in on the half of the story that the Wall Street Con Men have been keeping from you for 32 years now.

“I Like Rob’s Fresh Views and Tips on the Subject of Saving”

June 30, 2009 By Rob

The Digerati Life blog recently ran a blog entry examining the unconventional money saving tips explored in my recent interview with ABC News Now. It’s called Money Saving Advice from an Expert Money Saver.

Juicy Excerpt: I like Rob’s fresh views and tips on the subject of saving money…. The “magic” here is that by using this rule, you’ll figure out what it takes to fund something for life. Once you’ve saved up for something in this manner, it can be quite liberating to realize that you’ll never have to worry about affording that particular budget (spending) category ever again.

Lots of good comments.

Juicy Excerpt: Maybe I’m still too young to be able to budget the cost of each thing for my entire life:) – it’s simpler to work towards one little savings goal at a time.

Related Posts

  • My Interview with ABC News re “Ten Unconventional Money Saving Tips”My Interview with ABC News re “Ten Unconventional Money Saving Tips”
  • “<i>Passion Saving</i> Seems to Advise<br> That You Can Never Have Enough”“Passion Saving Seems to Advise
    That You Can Never Have Enough”
  • A Five-Part Series on <i>Passion Saving</i>:<br> “It Is a Great Book”A Five-Part Series on Passion Saving:
    “It Is a Great Book”
  • Thinking Like an EmployeeThinking Like an Employee
  • “If You Can Change Your Mindset<br> to See Saving as Buying You a Little Bit of Freedom…”“If You Can Change Your Mindset
    to See Saving as Buying You a Little Bit of Freedom…”
  • Greaney on <i>Passion Saving</i>:<br>“You’ll Have to Buy a Copy…Extraordinary!”Greaney on Passion Saving:
    “You’ll Have to Buy a Copy…Extraordinary!”

Filed Under: Rob Bennett Tagged With: Passion Saving, unconventional money saving tips

Comments

  1. John Walter Russell says

    June 30, 2009 at 11:13 am

    Rob,

    This is very good news. Keep up the good work.

    Have fun.

    John Walter Russell

  2. Rob says

    June 30, 2009 at 11:29 am

    The Digerati Life is a high quality blog. I’ve been checking in on it for a long time. I was of course thrilled when she elected to write up my interview and the ten tips. That came as a total happy surprise.

    Rob

  3. John Walter Russell says

    June 30, 2009 at 12:08 pm

    Rob,

    As a side comment related to Today’s Passion: notice the new definition of risk.

    You always have to be careful when talking about probability and statistics.

    I prefer a definition which specifies a dollar amount at a specific year, not an annualized percentage increase over an indefinite time frame.

    If you look at the likelihood of reaching $1.0 million starting from some specified amount (or using dollar cost averaging), good things eventually do happen.

    If you demand an 8% or 9% annualized return, you can continue to have difficulties.

    Have fun.

    John Walter Russell

Browse Rob Bennett

  • Ken Evoy, Owner of SiteSell, Inc.: "Rob, Awesome Post. I Suggest All Read It, Some Sharp, Creative Thinking. Trying to "Be There" Before the Gold Rush to a New Niche Is an Interesting Bet! You'll Be THE Name If It Happens. Heck, You Might Even Help MAKE It Happen!" 4 Comments

    ISet forth below is the text of a post that I put to the SiteSell (a web hosting company) forum, followed by the response of SiteSell Owner Ken Evoy: I believe that the path forward is to move away from the idea that there is one right way to build a successful site and to position SBI as a company that helps one-person shops build successful sites in a variety of ways.My site never fit the SBI model. I write about personal finance. That's a huge topic with a huge amount of competition,…

  • "Let’s Say That the Next 20 Years Are the Same As the Past 20 Years in That No One Believes Your Story, No Crash Happens, You Are Still Broke, Etc. Will You Then Admit You Wasted All Your Time?" 36 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Let’s say that the next 20 years are the same as the past 20 years in that no one believes your story, no crash happens, you are still broke, etc.  Will you then admit you wasted all your time? That alone would not do it. It would cause me to experience doubts. I would explore those doubts and see what people I respected were saying about the matter. If there…

  • "I Certainly Am Not Going to Demand Prison Sentences If Most Others Do Not See a Need for Them." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: The person named Laugh is correct. I half agree with both you and with Laugh, Reality. I posted Laugh’s comment as a blog entry because I think he is making an important point. Shiller’s book was a best-seller. It is available in most public libraries. He was awarded a Nobel prize for his “revolutionary” (his word) research. Shiller’s findings have been covered-up in an…

  • "I Am Not an Investing Expert. I Am a Journalist. A Journalist Who Discovered a Huge Story, the Story of How the Investment Advice Field Has Become 100 Percent Corrupt Over the Past 39 Years." 14 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: So all these people, such as Wade and Bill Bernstein are lying…..according to Rob Bennett, top investing expert. I am not an investing expert. I am a journalist. A journalist who discovered a huge story, the story of how the investment advice field has become 100 percent corrupt over the past 39 years. Everyone in this field lies. Some not by commission but…

  • "While I Have a Good Bit of Confidence That Most of What I Have Put Forward Has Great Value, I Would Obviously Feel Even More Confident in That Assessment If Every Site Had Been Open to Honest Posting for the Entire 17 Years and If We Had Had People Like Shiller and Bogle Commenting on My Work All Along and Pointing Out Any Weaknesses in My Work Product." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I rank him as the most important investing analyst of all time. So he obviously has done a huge amount of good, for which we all should be grateful. But he certainly has not done all the good that he could do“ Since you have put all the pieces together, unlike anyone else, wouldn’t you be the most important investing analyst of all time ? It would be…

  • "When I Was a Boy and My Parents Brought Me to Church, I Was Required to Genuflect Before I Got Into the Pew. I Did It But My Heart Was Not Really in It. When I Visited a Library and Was Surrounded by All Those Books Asking All Those Questions and Providing All That learning, That Was When I Felt an Internal Impulse to Genuflect. The Library Was My Church." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ Say that there is a 1 in 100 chance that I was right in what I said in my famous post from the morning of May 13, 2002 — that the retirement study posted at John Greaney’s web site lacks an adjustment for the valuation level that applies on the day the retirement begins. Personally, I believe that the odds are more like 99.9999 percent. But let’s say for…

  • All the Time. The Majority of People Who Hear My Case Do NOT LIke the Way I Present It."" target="_blank">"People Make the Point Made by Rob Arnott About My "Stridency" All the Time. The Majority of People Who Hear My Case Do NOT LIke the Way I Present It." 0 Comments

    One of the Goons recently characterized Rob Arnott's observation (directed at me) that "your stridency is unhelpful to your cause," as "the understatment of the year." He asked: "From how many sources have you heard some variation of this advice and have chosen to ignore it?" My response, initially set forth in the comments section of a blog entry from last week, is set forth below (my aim in posting the words as a separate blog entry is to highlight them so that they reach the attention of…

  • "You Measure Success By How Many Dollar Bills Are Coming In. I Measure Success By How Much Value I Am Contributing to the World. It Is By Adding Value That We Create the Wealth That Permits Us to Be Paid Large Sums." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “Einstein’s definition of insanity was doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.” Says the guy who’s been blogging on the same topic for 15 years. Precisely so. But you overlook the fact that Bogle has been saying the same thing for 45 years. That’s three times as long! And I have been learning amazing things in just…

  • "What You Want Is for All the Sites in the World To Be Open To Your Posts So That You Can Increase Your Popularity. Your Ambition Is To Be One of the Leading, If Not the Top, Investment Experts in the World. With This Fame, You Thought You Would Become Rich By Becoming a Sought After Speaker and Perhaps Selling Books and Other Materials." 12 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Just tell people what you really want. What you want is for all the sites in the world to be open to your posts so that you can increase your popularity. Your ambition is to be one of the leading, if not the top, investment experts in the world. With this fame, you thought you would become rich by becoming a sought after speaker and perhaps selling books and other…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "I Think Your Ex-Wife and Priest Would Disagree With That Statement." 16 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I always want to remain open to hearing thoughts coming from people on the other side of the table, Anonymous.” I think your ex-wife and priest would disagree with that statement. There's some truth in that comment but it does not express the complete truth. I once asked my priest whether he felt that I had committed a sin in making the choices that I…

  • "Maybe I Am Wasting My Time and Maybe I Am Leading the People of the United States to the Biggest Advance in Our Understanding of How Stock Investing Works Ever Achieved in Our History." 16 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: There are no goons. Just people that don’t agree with you. If and when there is a drop in the market, it will not be blamed on buy and hold. Every day, there are predictions of drops that are tied to some particular reason. Here is another…

  • "A Lot of People Want to Be Spoon-Fed. I See This All the Time. So I See the Benefit of a Product That Involves Spoon-Feeding. My Personal Belief, Though, Is That There Is Also a Need for Reinforcement of the Ideas Being Followed to Keep People on Track Long Enough for These Ideas to Pay Off." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of an e-mail that I sent to Ken Evoy, owner of the SiteSell.com web hosting company, on April 16, 2014: Ken: Thanks for your response. I certainly am interested. I will continue to follow the threads at the forum. As details become more clear, please just let me know if you have an interest in me being involved. If you have questions re what I am good at and re the amount of time that I can devote to this or anything else along those lines, I am of…

  • "It Could Be That God Feels That the World Needs the Drama of This Story to be Witnessed by People for Them to Finally Give Up Their Belief in Buy-and-Hold. It Could Be That God Wants Me to Get That $500 Million Payment and He Understood That There Was No Other Way to Get That Sum in My Pocket Without Having This Massive Cover-Up Play Out Before Us All. It Could Be That He Wants the Internet Discussion Board to Achieve Its Potential as the Communications Medium of the Future and That He Feels That Getting This Story Out Before People Will Lead to the Adoption of Legislation That Will Make That Happen." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: So you believe that you have never made a mistake. And you also believe you are sane? Here is something to think about. If you have never made a mistake why are you in the situation you are in? Blame everyone else, you aren’t responsible because you are perfect? Still think that sounds sane? The words you write here make it sound like I am in some sort of bad situation. Huh? I am…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "In Social Situations, They Are Going To Be Polite and Not Say Anything To Hurt Your Feelings. When They Learn of Your Divorce as Part of Your Conversation Regarding Investing/Finance, Just Look at Their Facial Reaction. They Now Know You Are a Train Wreck." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I’ve been in social situations where I meet someone new and I tell them my story, the board bannings and the divorce and my inability to build my internet writing business and so on. I have never seen a negative reaction, People generally don’t know what to make of it. They have never heard of something like this.” In social situations, they are going to…

  • Greaney on Passion Saving:
    "You'll Have to Buy a Copy...Extraordinary!"
    0 Comments

    My old friend John Greaney, owner of the RetireEarlyHomePage.com web site, has finally (I only had to remind you about 10 times, you bad boy!) gotten around to writing a review of my book Passion Saving: The Path to Plentiful Free Time and Soul-Satisfying Work. I hope you won't consider it bragging if I mention that Greaney kicks off his review by observing that "Mr. Bennett evidences an unusual skill." That's a kind thing to say. But we go back a long ways, fella. So what's with this "Mr.…

  • "I Greatly Enjoyed the Time That I Spent at the Bogleheads Forum and Learned a Lot From the Experience and Made Lots of Good Friends. But I Was Not Willing to Say Either That the Buy-and-Hold Retirement Studies Contain Valuation Adjustments or That Such Adjustments Are Not Needed to Get the Numbers Right. So I Am No Longer Permitted to Post There....We All Learn More When We Permit Our Beliefs to be Challenged in Civil and Reasoned Discussions." 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a conversation that recently took place at the FinCon Community on Facebook: Miranda Marquit: Also, I'm looking for a legit Boglehead. Any of you been (or still are) a Boglehead? Would like to know what it's like to be on the "inside" as well as if there are some issues with being too fervent about it. Doug Nordman: I've been a member of the Bogleheads forum since 2007, if that helps. I was also at the Vanguard Diehards forum with Morningstar when the…

  • "If You Took a Poll of the American People and Described the Situation and Asked 'Has Rob Bennett Worked This Hard Enough?' I Am 100 Percent Confident That 90 Percent of the Population Would Say That I Have Worked It Too Hard and Too Long, Not Too Light and for Not a Long Enough Time. I Know That Because of What Friends and Family Members Tell Me. People Think That I Have Traveled Too Far From the Herd. That’s Virtually a Universal Opinion." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ It’s definitely my job. It’s definitely your job too, Anonymous. And it’s definitely everyone else’s job.” No, it is only your job as we choose our jobs.  You chose your pathway, now it is your job to set people straight. My conscience is clear, Anonymous. I feel that I have done my part and then some more on top of that and then some more on top…

  • Ken Evoy, Owner of SiteSell Web Hosting Company, to Rob: "I Think You'd Be Perfect for This! You E-Mailed 30,000 People at SSRN?! Individually? Wow!" 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of an e-mail sent to me by Ken Evoy, owner of the SiteSell web hosting company, on April 16, 2014: Hi Rob, I think you'd be perfect for this! How much time could you spend on it? If this happens, we can talk more about it at the time. You emailed 30,000 people on SSRN?! Individually? Wow! Re the academic, Wade sounds like he'd fill the bill. It's Momentum-based, pushed in interesting directions. If he's interested in getting involved, please let me know.…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "It Is Not What YOU Think You Have Done. Instead, It Is What Others Say You Have Done." 14 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: It is not what YOU think you have done. Instead, it is what others say you have done. Otherwise, your words are meaningless. A) Academic Researcher Wade Pfau’s Statements Showing Interest In and Confidence in Rob Bennett’s Work 1) “I do cite you and John Walter Russell in my paper as the earliest and strongest advocates of this approach [New School…

  • "When Two Sides in a Dispute Are Both 100 Percent Inflexible re the Key Point of Contention, the Only Thing to Do Is to Take a Step Back and See If Time Causes Circumstances to Change in Some Way. I Wish You All the Best That This Life Has to Offer a Person. I Believe That We Will Be Working Together Following the Crash." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: If you are waiting for a 65% crash, followed by your $500 million windfall and goons going to prison, then you will probably need to come visit me at the local cemetery as I will be long gone by that time. I am not planning on passing away anytime soon, but old age will eventually catch up to me in another 50 years or so. Fair enough? I guess. I don’t like this way of playing…

  • "I Am Not Ashamed of My Behavior From May 13, 2002, Forward. I Am Proud of It. It Would Be Fair to Say That I Am Somewhat Ashamed of My Behavior Prior to May 13, 2002." 16 Comments

    Set forth below is a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Unbelievable. This is it? You have been lying about death threats all this time. You should be ashamed of your behavior. I am not ashamed of my behavior from May 13, 2002, forward, Anonymous. I am proud of it. It would be fair to say that I am somewhat ashamed of my behavior prior to May 13, 2002. Not entirely so. Given what we have seen from May 13, 2002, forward, most…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: " I Am Willing to Give Anything a Shot for a Period of Time (1-3 Years). But Spending 16 Years of My Time With $0 Earnings Is Beyond Any Level of Reason." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: I am willing to give anything a shot for a period of time (1-3 years). But spending 16 years of my time with $0 earnings is beyond any level of reason. I was rereading yesterday’s posts this morning and I saw this one and I thought that I should make a point that I did not bring out in my original response. In an objective sense I agree with this point. If you…

  • "I Have Paid a Financial Price for My Honesty. But Now I Feel Good About Myself As a Person. And I Believe That I Will See Big Financial Rewards Too Down the Road a Piece." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: I would hate to not have much left of a nest egg, versus having a large nest egg that might have to weather a short term loss. Speaking just of the nest egg, I would agree with you. The issue here has been whether I am willing to tell my friends things about stock investing that I do not believe in order to appease you Goons or whether I am willing to pay the…

  • "I Believe That What I Have Done in the Investing Field Can Be Done in Lots of Fields By People Possessing a Reasonable Amount of Intelligence (All That I Possess) Who Take Advantage of Opportunities Created by the Creation of the Internet" 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the Suckers Buy It! forum: The purpose of this thread-starter is to offer some ideas on how blog and site owners can obtain big-name endorsements for their work. The obvious benefit of doing so is that big-name endorsements give you the credibility you need to persuade customers to buy your products and services. They can also help you obtain citations in big-name media outlets, which can generate traffic gains. I have a…

  • "I Am the Most Knowledgeable Person Today on the Subject of How Average Middle-Class People Should Invest in Stocks Not Because I Spent 20 Years in School or Possess a Genius Level I.Q. It Is Because I am Honest. That Gives Me a Huge Edge in a Field that Is 100 Percent Corrupt." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently put to the blog at this site: I think millions would disagree with your level of knowledge versus those you have listed. Millions would disagree with what I say about my level of knowledge TODAY, Pink. We agree re that one. How about tomorrow? What happens tomorrow matters. Bogle does not believe that he can respond effectively to my questions about Buy-and-Hold, Pink. We know that beyond any reasonable doubt. I announced…

  • "I Only Feel Competent to Address One Question. Are Stock Prices Determined By Rational Assessments or By Emotional Inclinations? There Are Lots of Smart People Around Who Address Themselves to All of the Hundreds of Other Important Issues That Arise in Discussions of Stock Investing. That Said, I Believe That the Valuations/Emotions Question Is BY FAR the Most Important Investing Question. And I Not So Humbly Submit That I Am the World’s Leading Expert on That One Important Question." 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: If someone came to you today and said they wanted to invest their life savings of $5 million by following the VII strategy, what specific investments and percentage allocations would you give them as a recommendation? I like that question. It seems down-to-earth and real. I only feel competent to address one question, Anonymous. Are stock prices determined by…

  • "On the Content Side, I Have Achieved a Level of Success 500 Times Greater Than the Highest Level That I Ever Thought That I Could Achieve If Everything in My Life Worked Out in the Best Way Possible. On the Process Side, It Has Been the Biggest and Most Catastrophic Failure That I Have Ever Encountered or Even Imagined." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “To continue my efforts to open every discussion board and blog on the internet to honest posting re safe withdrawal rates and scores of other critically important investment-related topics.” And how is that working out for you? Time for plan C? On the content side, I have achieved a level of success 500 times greater than the highest level that I ever…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "What You Call Research Is Your Opinion of What One Guy Said. You Even Stated That Shiller Doesn’t Say What You Say. 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: What you call research is your opinion of what one guy said.  You even stated that Shiller doesn’t say what you say. I am not aware of Shiller ever having put forward the words "The safe withdrawal rate is not the same number at all times." So he doesn't say precisely what I say. That's true of anyone who has ever said anything. The standard Buy-and-Hold…

  • "We Have Fallen Into an All-Or-Nothing Battle Here. Either I Am Totally Crushed and End Up With Nothing and You Goons Get Off With No Prison Sentences or I Become One of the Richest Men in the United States and It Is You Goons Who End Up Ruined. That Reality Makes It Pretty Darn Hard to Work Out a Compromise." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: What has enabled you to remain impervious to the all powerful Buy and Hold Mafia something not a single other person on this planet has been capable of? This is a super question. First of all, it is of course not the case that I am the only one who has not been influenced by the intimidation tactics of the Buy-and-Holders. There are lots of people who have made brave statements. I think…

  • "I View It As a National Tragedy That As an Entire Society Advances in Our Understanding of the Realities of Stock Investing Have Been Delayed for 35 Years Now. I Have Taken on as My Life's Work the Project of Doing All That I Can to Create Safe Places for People of All Investing Persuasions (Buy-and-Holders and Valuation-Informed Indexers Alike) to Express Their Sincere Views on the Many Far-Reaching Implications of Shiller's Powerful Research-Based Insights." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Buy and hold what, Rob? You just use it as a label. If you go to the Boglehead forum (which is your stated nemesis, the portfolios vary greatly and there is the common practice of rebalancing. Meanwhile, your plan crashed and burned a long time ago. Your emotions (most notably, your envy) comes through loud and clear. When I say "Buy-and-Hold," I am…

  • "If Bogle Could Get Market Timing Wrong, As I Believe Is the Case, Then Surely Rob Bennett Could Get Marker Timing Wrong. " 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You are just like that Kim Blandino guy on YouTube.  You are so sure you are right, but only making a fool of yourself. I believe that I am right on the substantive issues. There's the 40 years of peer-reviewed research. There's Shiller's Nobel prize. There are the thousands of our fellow community members who have expressed a desire that honest posting be…

  • "This Stuff Is HARD. Not Intellectually. It's Hard EMOTIONALLY Saying Things That Millions of People Very, Very, Very Much Do Not want to Hear." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Are you referring to the book that you said would be out 12 years ago? That's the one! It will be a humdinger when it is ready for public consumption, I promise you that muvh. Whenever I feel a little discouraged, I read the first three Parts (the first 27 chapters) and that gives me a confidence rush. Those first three Parts are perfectly polished today. Part…

  • "Do You Think It Would Have Been Better If I Had Kept It Zipped re the Error in the Greaney Retirement Study?" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: <i>When is the last time you actually spoke to these “friends”?</i> There were not personal friends. They were internet friends. I haven't spoken to them since I left the board. Do you think it would have been better if i had kept it zipped re the error in the Greaney retirement study? Do you think it would be a good idea to say that I now…

  • "I Am Not the One Who Is Alone. If I Were Alone, I Would Pose No Threat to You Goons. It Is Precisely Because There Are So Many Millions Seeking to Understand for the First Time How Stock Investing Really Works That You Hate Me With Such a Burning and All-Consuming Hate." 21 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Rob, you seem to be alone in this VII crusade. Haven’t you ever considered that you might be wrong about this?I have considered whether I might be wrong and looked for evidence to support that view every day of the past 12 years of my life, Sensible.I am not alone. My work is rooted in the research of Yale Economics Professor Robert Shiller. Shiller was awarded the Nobel prize in…

  • "You Are Broke. You Are Divorced. You Got Everything Wrong. Take Responsibility and Stop Blaming Everyone Else." 18 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You are broke.  You are divorced.  You got everything wrong.  Take responsibility and stop blaming everyone else. And I was right about the Greaney retirement study lacking a valuation…

  • "I Wrote Draft Seven, Which Is Largely Organized But Still Somewhat Scattered Thoughts Placed in Chapters (the Chapter Titles Are a Lock at This Point — Just Making Final Decisions on Chapter Titles Is a Big Organizational Advance) but Without Good Enough Narrative Flow, Earlier This Year. I Am Now Working on Draft Eight, Which Will Have the Proper Narrative Flow. I Am Getting Through Roughly a Chapter per Week." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Have you started your job search? I have not. I am working on what I consider the eighth draft of the book. I count the collection of the material that I put in the 30 binders that used to be in my basement as Draft One. I count the exploration of the ideas on internet discussion boards that I participated in after I put forward my famous post of May 13, 2002,…

  • Fear Strikes Out 0 Comments

    I once was afraid that I was losing my hair. I once was afraid that I would not be able to find another job that I liked as much as the one that I lost in the recession of the early 1990s. I once was afraid that my grades wouldn't be good enough to get me into law school. I once was afraid to call up a girl and ask for a date. I once was afraid to hand in my resignation from a high-paying job to become a freelance writer. I once was afraid that disco was never going to fade in…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "Any Wife Would Be Saddened by a Husband Who Is Capable of Working But Hasn't 'Made a Dime in 13 Years.' Since You Acknowledge That Fact, To What Extent (If Any) Does It Bother You?" 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Any wife would be saddened by a husband who is capable of working but hasn’t “made a dime in 13 years”. Since you acknowledge that fact, to what extent (if any) does it bother you? It bothers me. But it doesn’t bother me enough to persuade me to betray my fellow community members and to betray my profession and to betray my country and, yes, to betray my family. Timothy is 15…

  • "Your Loyalty Should Be to Your Readers, Not to People Who Have the Power to Advance Your Career" 0 Comments

    Here's a link to an interesting thread at the FinCon Facebook page: http://www.facebook.com/groups/362252247186456/permalink/367187723359575/ Michael Germanovsky asked: "Is it okay for a finance blogger that caught a news reporter on a wrong factual statement to call out the mistake?" He noted that one reported warned him of a risk of being blacklisted for doing such a thing. Here's my comment: I think it is fine to try to correct the error in private, so long as that gets the error…

  • "I Take All of the Stuff that Bogle Got Right and Incorporate it Into My Analysis. Then I Add the Stuff that Shiller Got Right So That the Stuff That Bogle Did Actually Helps People Instead of Destroying Their Lives. And Then I Add the Part that Shiller Failed to Put Into the Mix, the Exploration of the Far-Reaching How-To Implications of Shiller’s 'Revolutionary' (His Word) Research Findings. Without That Critical Part, the Entire Thing Just Does Not Work." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You think way too much of yourself. You’ve said that in a direct way hundreds of times, Anonymous. If we count indirect ways, you’ve said in thousands of times. So the thought behind the statement is obviously of great import to you. I am extremely proud of the work that I have done over the past 17 years. If that’s what you are accusing me of, then you…

  • "I've Got the Most Important Job in the United States Today. My Job Is to Open Every Site to Honest Posting re the Last 42 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research, Without a Single Exception. Executing That Job Successfully Will Permit Everyone to Live a Fuller and Richer and More Fulfilled Life Than He or She Imagined Possible Back in the Buy-and-Hold/Get Rich Quick Days." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: No one agrees with you, but it really has nothing to do with you not getting a job.  Why is it that everyone else is responsible for bringing in an income to support before and after retirement, but you don’t think that it applies to you?  Why should you not have to get a job? I've got the most important job in the United States today, Anonymous. My job is to…

  • "The Proper Way to Describe Me Would Be to Say That I Am Non-Stubborn in General But Very Stubborn When Conditions Apply That Make the Issue at Hand Appear in My Mind to Be One of Great Consequence. I Have Reasons Why I Feel a Need to Stand Firm re the Investing Matter. My Experience Is That Matters of This Nature Are Sometimes Resolved as the Result of Unexpected Developments. The Buy-and-Holders Made a Mistake in Taking Such a Hard Line and Regret That Mistake Today. I Believe That Someday There Will Be Circumstances That Will Cause Them to Ease Up Just a Notch." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: "But she doesn’t agree with my strategy for dealing with the problem." Your wife is a wise woman. I just hope she doesn’t expect you to change. I half agree with what you are saying here and I half do not, Evidence. I am not generally a non-yielding person AT ALL. When it comes to things like what movie to go see or what restaurant to eat at, I ALWAYS am the one who defers to the…

  • Question Asked at the Quora Forum: "Why Is Rob Bennett Opposed to the Buy-and-Hold Strategy for Investing in Equities?" 11 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of the response that I offered at the Quora forum to the question "Why Is Rob Bennett Opposed to the Buy-and-Hold Strategy for Investing in Equities?": Finally a question re which I can feel confident that I possess the expertise needed to rise to the task of venturing forward with a response! The backstory here is that I was a Buy-and-Holder myself until the evening of August 27, 2002. The Buy-and-Holders did something very important that had never been done…

  • "I Developed the Ideas Tested in the Study That I Co-Authored with Wade Pfau. Wade Did Great Work Testing Them and Proving Their Legitimacy. He Never Tried to Hog Full Credit for the Study. He Said Many Times That He Considered Me the Lead Person Behind the Development of the Valuation-Informed Indexing Concept and That He Believed That the Shift from Buy-and-Hold to Valuation-Informed Indexing Is the Biggest Advance That We Have Seen in the Investing Field in Many, Many Years." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted in the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Tempted to lie???? You lie constantly. Look at your latest post. You repeat the lie that you authored a study with Wade Pfau. That is a lie. You are merely mentioned in the credits along with other people and you are not listed as an author. Your retirement plan was a well documented failure. You now try to cover that up by blaming other people and also…

  • "I Had a Discussion About This With My Mother Shortly Before She Died. She Said That Maybe All That I Am Trying to Teach People Is Going To Become Widely Accepted After My Death. Oh, Great!....I Pray That I Have the Courage to Accept God's Plan Here Without Too Much Whining." 54 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to a discussion of a blog entry at this site: hopefully for your sake you have more of a plan than praying. God helps those who help themselves, What. So I certainly need to work it myself in addition to saying my prayers. But it is in God’s hands, not mine. If God doesn’t mean for this to happen, it’s not going to happen, no matter how hard I work it. I had a discussion about this with my mother shortly before…

  • "My Aim Is to Set Up a New Version of Every Investing Discussion Board and Blog on the Internet. A New, HONEST Version, One That Permits Discussion of the Last 39 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research in This Field." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Why don’t you start up your own version of the Bogleheads forum for your own followers instead of expecting other people to change for you? My aim is to set up a new version of every investing discussion board and blog on the internet, Anonymous. A new, HONEST version, one that permits discussion of the last 39 years of peer-reviewed research in this field. Why…

  • "As Of Today, I Honestly Do Not Feel That I Have Ever Been Unfairly Harsh in My Dealings With You Goons. But I Also Think That It Is Possible That There Are Things That I Just Cannot See Because of My Human Limitations. I May Look Through Some Earlier Discussions and See If I Can Identify Places Where I Have Been Unfair or Unkind. If I Can, I Hope That I Will Have the Courage to Own Up to Them Publicly." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Hey Rob. When can we expect to hear all the stories of your great successes at FinCon? I’m at the conference now, Question. I brought my computer this year. I have indeed had some great successes. I have had some great frustrations too. I always do. That’s been the story for 13 years now — great successes combined with great frustrations. I organized a community event that was a…

  • "I Like Rob’s Fresh Views and Tips on the Subject of Saving" 3 Comments

    The Digerati Life blog recently ran a blog entry examining the unconventional money saving tips explored in my recent interview with ABC News Now. It's called Money Saving Advice from an Expert Money Saver. Juicy Excerpt: I like Rob's fresh views and tips on the subject of saving money.... The “magic” here is that by using this rule, you’ll figure out what it takes to fund something for life. Once you’ve saved up for something in this manner, it can be quite liberating to realize…

  • "I Expect to Set Up a System Whereby Internet Communities Concerned With Personal Finance Issues Help the Public to Identify the Good Guys, a Good Housekeeping Seal of Approval Sort of Thing. Lots of People in This Field Want to Do Good Work But Feel Pressured to Engage in Unethical Activities. They Need a Respected Authority Site to Identify Them as Honest and Holistic in Their Approach." 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Rob, The crisis has come. The Wall Street Con Men ™ have of course, rumaged their lapels, and pooled together to provide 1 BILLION untraceable, untaxable U.S. dollars to you, to ensure a quick settlement. It is already in your bank account. The sun rises over 160 N Hatcher. You roll over, wipe the sleep from your eyes, and the day begins. Rob, please describe for us the typical day of a…

  • "I Look at the Same 14 Years of Abuse and Observe That That Abuse Is What Has Kept Lots of Other Smart and Good People From Walking the Path That I Have Walked and Thereby Has Left a Mountain of High-Dollar Opportunities Open to Me" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You don't like anything that doesn't fit with your fantasy. When you go 14 years without making a dime and the people get fed up enough that they have to ban you from almost every board, you would think that reality would step in. It seems you have gone to extreme lengths to avoid having to back to work, instead of spending your day playing out a fantasy on your…

  • "There’s an Emotional Toll That Has to Be Paid for Telling People What the Last 36 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research Tells Us About How Stock Investing Works in the Real World. Do You See Anybody Else Doing It? Can You Point to Anyone Else Who Has Done As Much Of It As I Did in Earlier Years? There’s a Reason Why No One Else Goes There. It’s Hard Work. Taking Constant Emotional Hits Is the Hardest Kind of Work There Is." 30 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Yes, you’re great at imagining. Not so great at actually doing. When is the last time you posted at any other blog? I don’t recall. It’s been a long time. But I certainly expect to be doing so in future days. After the next crash, I am certain that I will be posting at lots of places. It will be a lot easier then. Emotions will have turned. I will not…

  • "Working Through the Abusive Stuff Is the Price That Anyone Who Cares About Getting Stock Investing Right Has to Pay in the Year 2023 to Get to the Learning Stuff." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You said the same thing 5 years ago and 10 years ago and 15 years ago and 20 years ago. Look at how all that worked out for you. Your interpretation of Shiller’s work led to an “amazing” broke retirement and an “amazing” divorce. I think it worked out extremely well, Anonymous. I of course hate all the abusive stuff. I've said that thousands and…

  • "The Crime Is Ongoing. Greaney’s Study Has Not Been Corrected to This Day. The Bans Remain in Place. The Abusive Posting Continues. Wade Pfau Remains Afraid to Work with Me to Promote Our Research Because of the Threats You Made." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: "The entire purpose of my plan was to shift to a form of work that I would find more fulfilling and that would in the long run produce more income than the corporate employment that I left behind.” No, your historical posts show you had only counted on a small amount of side income. You never had a substantial business income. To win anything, you would need to…

  • Rob on Day Four of The Great Debate: "I Finally, Finally Get It. I Am Deeply Sorry for Falsely Criticizing the Study and for Wasting So Much of the Board's Time. Understanding for the First Time That There Really Is a Known Safe Withdrawal Rate That Applies in All Circumstances Makes Me Feel a Little More Comfortable With the Idea of Investing in Stocks at Today's Prices." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Here is your parting post on that old thread. Remember this? "John I finally finally get it. I am deeply sorry for falsely criticizing the study and for wasting so much of the board's time on this issue. The only possible saving grace here is that perhaps my public display of deep ignorance will cause a few others to realize that they do not…

  • "I AM Intense. There Is No Question But That That Is a Reality. I Am Friendly and Polite and Warm. But I Am Intense and Determined. And There Is No Question Whatsoever But That That Turns a Good Number of People Off in My Discussions With Them. My Challenge Is to Retain the Good that Comes from Caring Deeply without Scaring People or Turning Them Off." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of an e-mail from Jackie (owner of the The Debt Stuff blog) to me dated October 14, 2014, followed by my response: Some of my (unasked for) thoughts: - I think you could really benefit from an editor to make sure you aren't focusing on the past but instead are getting your actual message across - I think a simpler tone (like what I posted from your emails vs. the tone of what you originally sent me) is more readable - Shorter paragraphs are more scanable. -…

  • "I Do Not Think That I Am Wrong to Talk About Financial Fraud and Prison Sentences. But, If I Am Handling Things Improperly Even in Some Small Way, I Want to Know About It. Reflecting on the Words “Criticize Not One Bit” May or May Not Help Me Go About the Job That I Have Been Elected by Circumstances to Perform." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: I am not following. Do you go to AA meetings to talk about the addictions of millions of people other than yourself? This seems very absurd and you should stop Wasting their valuable time. They have far more important topics to cover and real people to help. What a disgrace. It is my job to heal the wounds that you Goons have ripped open in our…

  • "I Have Asked Myself From Time to Time Whether I Would Put Up That Fateful Post of the Morning of May 13, 2002, All Over Again If I Had a Chance To Go Back and Do It Over. The Pain on the Process Side Makes Me Think That It Would Be Crazy to Choose That Path Again. But the Amazing Stuff on the Substance Side Makes Me Think That There Is No Way on God’s Green Earth That I Could Ever Elect to Choose a Different Path." 26 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Don’t you wish you could say the same thing. Yes and no, Anonymous. There have been two sides to these discussions, a substance side and a process side. The process side has been the most horrible nightmare that I have ever encountered. The substance side has been the most wonderful dream that I have ever experienced. I wouldn’t have enjoyed the hundreds of…

  • "I Have Attended Numerous Financial Blogger Conferences and At Each One That I Have Attended I Have Spoken to Financially Successful Bloggers Who Have Told Me That They Regretted the Abusiveness That Has Held Me Back and That They Hoped That Things Would Soon Change." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: My plan has been a huge success, presuming that Shiller's Nobel-prize-winning research is legitimate research, Sammy. I definitely have spent down my nest egg. That part of your comment is accurate. But that of course has nothing to do with the merit of the Valuation-Informed Indexing strategy. Had it not been for your abusiveness and the abusiveness of…

  • "In Terms of Dollar Bills, the Return Has Indeed Been Zero. In Terms of Building a Model for Understanding How Stock Investing Works That Will Be Improving the Lives of Millions for Many Years to Come, the Return Has Been Off the Charts. I Have Lost Every Process Battle. And I Have Won Every Content Battle." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: With a zero return, I think “wasted” is closer to the mark instead of “invested”. In terms of dollar bills, the return has indeed been zero. In terms of building a model for understanding how stock investing works that will be improving the lives of millions for many years to come, the return has been off the charts. I have lost every process battle.…

  • "I Have Had Several College Professors Include Links to Material Posted at My Web Site as Part of the Required Reading for Their Courses Because They Felt That the Material Was So Important and Could Not Be Found Elsewhere. That Tells Me Something." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I earned the $500 million, Anonymous.” Who says you earned this? I think I have earned $2 Billion for my work. Does that mean I will see it? I have the laws of the United States on my side. That tells me something. I have seen thousands of my fellow community members say that the debate that I launched was the most important debate that we ever saw on…

  • "I Believe That the Buy-and-Holders Are Great People. I Like Them as Individuals. I Want To Be Friends With Them." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: If you were confident in your market timing scheme, you wouldn’t keep attacking the buy and holders.  If you were confident in your market timing scheme, you would keep making up death threat accusations.  If you were confident in your market timing scheme, you would keep banning posts at your website.  If you were confident in your market timing scheme, you…

  • "My Agenda Is To Open Every Investing Site on the Internet to Honest Posting re the Last 36 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research in This Field." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Rob, Here is the difference between you and everyone else. The investment community reads the words Shiller says and believe that those are his opinions. You read what he says and then interpret it to fit your agenda. My agenda is to open every investing site on the internet to honest posting re the last 36 years of peer-reviewed research in this field,…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "The Market Has Concluded That You Are Irrelevant." Rob's Response: "You Nailed It." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: The folks who set prices have massive amounts of information including Shillers work. They can also read or have their computers ingest your awful website. The market concludes you are irrelevant. The market has concluded that I am irrelevant. As of today, it would be fair to say that the market has indeed concluded that. All that you have to do to understand…

  • "I'm the Only Person Who Advanced a Post on the Morning of May 13, 2002, That Pointed Out the Error in the Greaney Retirement Study and Then Saw the Cover-Up That Followed for the Next 21 Years. Any Decent Person Who Saw What I Saw Would Be Doing the Same Thing That I Am Doing." 28 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You have certain beliefs and others have their beliefs.  So what.  It has nothing to do with getting a job.  Why should things be any different for you versus every other American. I'm the only person who advanced a post on the morning of May 13, 2002, that pointed out the error in the Greaney retirement study (it lacks an adjustment for the valuation level that…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "Here You Are, Over the Age of 60, Living in the Land of Make Believe With the Silly Stories on Death Threat, etc. Meanwhile, You Are Run Through Savings and Have Destroyed Your Social Security Benefits By Avoiding Work. You Have No Relevant Work Experience As You Haven't Had a Job in About 2 Decades, So Any Job Your Could Possibly Land Would Pay a Very Minimum Income. To Provide for Retirement, Your Plan Revolves Around Some Fantasy of a $500 Million Windfall. Yet Here You Are Preaching to Everyone About Investing for Retirement. Really????" 26 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Here you are, over the age of 60, living in the land of make believe with the silly stories on death threat, etc. Meanwhile, you are run through savings and have destroyed your social security benefits by avoiding work. You have no relevant work experience as you haven't had a job in about 2 decades, so any job your could possibly land would pay a very minimum income.…

  • "I Would Put Myself in the Same Class as Bogle and Shiller." 12 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: "I wouldn’t put yo Goons in the same class as Bogle or Shiller” Would you put yourself in the same category as Bogle and Shiller? Perhaps you would put yourself at a level above them? I would put myself in the same class as Bogle and Shiller. Bogle laid the foundation. Bogle got everything but valuations right (according to the peer-reviewed research…

  • "Everyone Has Access to All the Information. You Just Don’t Like the Opinions of Others." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Everyone has access to all the information.  You just don’t like the opinions of others.  Learn to deal with it and fix your own problems. I wish you all the best, in any event,…

  • "Buy-and-Hold Is Not Just a Bad Investing Strategy. It Is a Threat to the Survival of Our Free-Market Economic System. I Love My Country. I Want My Two Boys to Be Able to Grow Up in the Same Sort of Country That I Grew Up In." 12 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Rob, serious question here: do you think you’re obsessing about this topic? I agree with the idea that you believe in: buy and hold isn’t the best way to invest. Seriously, though, you must’ve thought to yourself, at least a few times…..that “perhaps I could broaden the range of topics beyond the one idea I talk about daily….that buy and hold is not the best way to…

  • "Do You Think It Would Have Been Better If I Had Just Kept It Zipped re the Error in the Study?" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You have no businesses making the comma you do when you lack any education in this area and have a failed retirement. Do you think it would have been better if I had just kept it zipped re the error in the…

  • "I Reported on the Errors in the Buy-and-Hold Retirement Studies on the Morning of May 13, 2002. Neither Shiller Nor Bogle Has Reported on the Errors in Those Studies TO THIS DAY. So There Obviously Are Some Things That I Am Seeing That Those Two (and Lots and Lots of Other Good and Smart People) Are Not Yet Seeing." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Are you saying: A) You know more than Shiller B) Shiller is just wrong in his analysis C) Shiller is purposely giving the wrong answer to appease the goons D) All of the above I’m saying that I know more than Shiller re some aspects of the question. Shiller also knows more than me re some aspects of the question. Bogle knows more than me re some aspects of…

  • "If You Asked My Father Whether Buy-and-Hold Worked for Him, He Would Answer "Yes!" I See That As a Misperception on His Part." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: It worked for me. It worked for my father, who has since passed on. If I am correct in what I have read from you (and I literally BEG you to correct me if I am in error) it worked for YOUR father, too Rob! So that’s three independent proofs that your nutty claim is wrong, from right off the top of my head, and of course I only needed one to do the job, anyway. End of argument. If you…

  • "I Have Done a Lot to Make Sure That I Am Not Being Influenced By Delusions. I Write This Column, for One Thing. If I Get Something Wrong Here, Some Smart Buy-and-Holder Is Going to See It and Let Me Know. I Wrote to 30,000 Academic Researchers to Elicit Their Feedback. Nearly All of Those Who Responded Had Only Positive Things to Say. My Work Has Been Endorsed by Some of the Biggest Names in the Field, People Like Rob Arnott and Wade Pfau." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Delusions don't pay the bills. You might want to start that job search earlier, rather than later. I believe that the transition from Buy-and-Hold to Valuation-Informed Indexing will prove to be the biggest advance in the history of personal finance, Sammy. And I believe that those who put their necks on the line and serve as the pioneers will be compensated…

  • Site Visitor to Rob: "Discovering Your Work Has Been Enlightening for Me; It's Given Clarity to My Own Ideas. Your Theory Is Just As Valid, If Not More So, Than What's Popular Right Now. It Definitely Furthers the Scope of Investment Knowledge." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Rob, For what it’s worth, and obviously not on the scale of what you have accomplished and achieved, but on the all-things-money blog I have frequented for the last couple of years, and debated against common stock market mantras, there have been several calls for me to be banned or my comments ‘moderated’ simply because I rally against what’s popular and the feel-good…

  • "My Parents Gave Me My Inheritance With Certain Unspoken Expectations. They Had Values They Instilled In Me As a Boy That They Hoped I Would Follow As An Adult: Honesty, Caring About Others, and Doing Solid Work. If I Were to Post Dishonesty on Safe Withdrawal Rates, I Would Be Dishonoring My Parents." 6 Comments

    Set forth below are the texts of three comments that I recently posted to the Goon Central board: Not true, since most of what you have you inherited. > My father and mother worked very hard for a long number of years for the money I inherited from them, GW. My mother had to leave school after eighth grade to work in a factory so that her family had enough to eat in the Depression. They lived in the row-house they bought (mostly with checks he sent back to her while he was in…

  • "Robert Shiller Has Been Awarded a Freakin' Nobel Prize for His Work. And Yet Thousands of Investing Analysts and Academic Researchers Remain to This Day Too Afraid of What the Buy-and-Holders Will Do to Them to Be Willing to Direct Their Energies to Exploring the Implications of the Peer-Reviewed Research That Shiller Published 34 YEARS AGO. And I Am Supposed to Consider Moving On? Really? That's a Question You Feel a Need to Ask?" 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Wade told you to move on three years ago. You simply can’t. Ever. That’s messed up. Why the heck would I ever want to move on, Stag? Are you joking? I write about personal finance. The shift from Buy-and-Hold to Valuation-Informed Indexing is the biggest advance ever achieved in the history of personal finance. It is bigger than all earlier advances all added together. And I am going…

  • "What Are My Responsibilities When I See a Super Weird Situation Like This? I Sure Don't Want to See the People of This Country Having to Endure Yet Another Buy-and-Hold Crisis. Do You?" 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: No.  “Not working out” means that your retirement plan did not go as you said it would.  Do you think it is a good thing to have a depleted retirement account when you are 60’s?  Are you not responsible for that, just like everyone else is responsible for their own situations? I'm responsible for it. But no reasonable person could have anticipated that I…

  • "The Only Ones Who Have Ever Offered Any Criticism of Me Are You Goons. I Have Had Normals Who Have Said That They Do Not Agree With Everything That I Have Said About Stock Investing But Who Have Also Said That They Appreciated My Stuff Because It Helped Them to Think Things Through More Carefully and Generated Lots of Great Discussion. I Can Live With That." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: "No one but you Goons posts here. That’s a fact." That should tell you something. In the last two decades you have probably posted more than anyone I know. Despite the volume of your messages, there is no signs of support. Instead, you have had your considerable share of critics and skeptics. Rather than try to learn from others, you have chosen just to call them…

  • A Five-Part Series on Passion Saving:
    "It Is a Great Book"
    0 Comments

    The author of the No Limits Ladies blog recently ran a five-part series on my book Passion Saving: The Path to Plentiful Free Time and Soul-Satisfying Work. She says: "Unfortunately, most people will not pick up this book based on the title alone. The S word no one likes. The people who truly value the innovative financial thinking it holds will walk on by. It is a shame because it is a great book, a great return on the cover price." She's probably already married or else would object to the…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "Everyone Else Is Lying and Only You Are Telling the Truth?" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Everyone else is lying and only you are telling the truth? I am the only one telling the truth re the financial fraud aspect of this, Anonymous. You yourself have acknowledged this on many occasions. Fama had good faith when he published his wonderful research in 1965. Fama didn’t distinguish between short-term timing and long-term timing because long-term timing was at the time not…

  • "You Say That I Stalk Women. You Say That I Use Drugs. You Say That I Am Stupid. You Say That I Manage My Money Poorly. You Say That My Wife Has Left Me. You Say That My Parents Were Alcoholics. You Say That I Am a Bad Father. You Say That I Am a Liar. You Say That I Am Jealous of Lindauer and Greaney and Bogle. If You Didn't See the Importance of People Liking Someone Who Is Trying to Convince Them of Something, You Wouldn't Focus All of Your Efforts on Personal Destruction." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: “It is important because friendship is the prerequisite to learning.” No. It’s not. People learn all the time from sources that are not their ‘friends’, or even friendly! Your entire premise is ridiculous. I don’t think it is ridiculous, Anonymous. I am a conservative. At earlier times in my life, I was very much a liberal. I still have sympathies for a good number of…

  • "A Little Over a Year Ago I Began Attending Meetings of the Al Anon 12-Step Program. You May Recall That I Used to Have a Section of the Site Called “Stock Drunk.” Get Rich Quick Investing Is an Addiction. The Real Problem That We Are Facing Is That Millions of Middle-Class Americans Are Today Addicted to Buy-and-Hold." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Rob, can you give us a sense of how many hours per week you work on investing matters? Any new books in the works? I’ve talked about the book before. I have a draft of a book about investing (“Investing for Humans: How to Get What Works on Paper to Work in Real Life”) completed. I will finish the book when the story it tells is complete. That is when the Ban…

  • "If I Had a Cure for Cancer That Had Passed Peer Review, Would It Be Irresponsible for Me to Tell People About It? I Say 'No.' I Think That It Is 100 Percent Imperative That We Get the Word Out to Everyone on the Planet." 10 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Don’t you think it is irresponsible for you to try and trick people into your market timing scheme, when it has never worked for even one single person, including you? If I had a cure for cancer that had passed peer review, would it be irresponsible for me to tell people about it? I say “no.” If there were some people who elected not to make use of the cure,…

  • "My New Target Date for Completion of the Investing for Humans Book Is June 2022" 58 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Since that deranged non-response ignored my question about your book, we can assume it won't be finished by the end of this year.  Or any year. It won't be finished by the end of this year, as I had hoped. I can now see light at the end of the tunnel. Before, when I would rework a section, it would often cause changes in a number of places throughout the book. I…

  • "If I Were Willing to Sell Out My Friends in the Way That I Would Need to be Willing to Sell Out My Friends to Do What You Suggest I Do, I Wouldn’t Have the Power to Produce the Kind of Work I Need to Produce to Get Featured in the New Yorker in the First Place. You Are Asking Me to Destroy What’s Good About Me to Get the Good in Me Widely Recognized. No. If I Destroy It, it Doesn’t Merit Recognition." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Don’t know if you saw this profile of Mr Money Moustache in The New Yorker, Rob. As I read it I couldn’t help thinking about your own near-two-decade pilgrimage. “Of all sad words of tongue and pen the saddest are these, it might have been.” When you hit rock bottom, quit…

  • " I Am a Whistleblower. I Have Been Made to Pay the Price That Whistleblowers Are Made to Pay. I Blew the Whistle on Buy-and-Hold." 12 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: You were the one to quit your job, right? Have you actively searched for a job since that time? It appears that you have not really taken steps to get a new job. Thus, we can conclude that you only have yourself to blame. Expecting someone to pay you for your internet rantings is laughable. It's not laughable if it turns out that I was right about what…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "Respectful Behavior Is What Is Required, Rob." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Respectful behavior is what is required, Rob. I have the greatest respect possible for the PEOPLE who advocate Buy-and-Hold, Sammy. I sing their praises all the time. Every Buy-and-Holder whom I have ever met is smart and it appears to me that just about all of them are top-notch people in a more general sense too. The Buy-and-Holders have made huge…

  • "The Valuation-Informed Indexers Have Been Placed in a Ghetto. It's a Ghetto in Which They Do Not Possess the Same Rights as the Buy-and-Holders. It's a Ghetto in Which They Keep Their Most Powerful Insights to Themselves. It's a Ghetto in Which They Do Not Say "Buy-and-Hold Is Dangerous" or "That Claim Is Wrong" or "Bogle Is Contradicting Himself." It Is a Gheto in Which They Watch Their Step and Are Careful Not to Offend Their Betters. Not This Boy." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Let’s play Jeopardy. Answer: the peer-reviewed research of the past 33 years needs to be discussed in every THREAD in which Buy-and-Hold “ideas” are advanced. Question: Why has Rob Bennett been banned from every major finance board? That's a super comment, X. You cut through a lot of b.s. and got straight to the heart of things with that comment. Good for you. I understand…

  • Frugal Dad Blog] Can Make a Difference for Millions of Middle-Class Investors"" target="_blank">"You [the Owner of the Frugal Dad Blog] Can Make a Difference for Millions of Middle-Class Investors" 0 Comments

    I posted a plea yesterday at the Frugal Dad blog asking that he permit me to write a series of guest blogs explaining the Valuation-Informed Indexing strategy to his readers. Juicy Excerpt: Please (I am begging) give the idea a little bit of thought. You are positioned to make an awful big difference in the lives of millions of middle-class investors. I sincerely believe that, if we could get the word out on these findings (which have been endorsed by a good number of big-name experts as…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "When You Are Commonly Banned on the Boards, It Should Be a Wake-Up Call That You Are Doing Something Wrong." 5 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: When you are commonly banned on the boards, it should be a wake up call that you are doing something wrong. Well, I've been banned at many places, Sammy. That one is beyond dispute. And this reality signifies something. We are in complete agreement re that one too. We differ on what it means. You say that it signifies that I am doing something…

  • "A Very Solid Approach to Investing" 1 Comment

    Michael Harr, founder of Walden Advisors, endorsed the Valuation-Informed Indexing strategy in recent comments at the Wealth Uncomplicated blog. Juicy Excerpt: I'd like to introduce you to a very solid approach to investing from Rob Bennett.... The principles are sound, and, over the long run, it will serve to reduce overall risk in your portfolio while providing more than adequate returns. The comments came as preface to a Guest Blog Entry that I wrote for the blog entitled A Better…

  • "What Will Happen Once We Have Opened Every Discussion Board and Blog on the Internet to Honest Posting re the Last 42 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research, Without a Single Exception? Will There Be Even One Person in This Field NOT Talking to Me Then?" 25 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Does Scott Burns talk to you now? Nope. Does Wade Pfau talk to you now? Nope. Does anyone else from the investment community talk to you now? Nope. No, we are not in this together. No, there is no one that supports you. What will happen once we have opened every discussion board and blog on the internet to honest posting re the last 42 years of peer-reviewed…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "This Absurd Claim (That Lots of People Agree That the 15-Year Cover-Up of the Errors in the Buy-and-Hold Retirement Studies Is the Biggest Case of Financial Fraud in U.S. History But Are Afraid to Say So Publicly) Lets You Say Any Crazy Old Thing You Want, on Any Topic, With No Evidence At All." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “Lots of people agree and are afraid to say so publicly” An earlier comment mentioned bottom lines. This is your bottom line. This absurd claim lets you say any crazy old thing you want, on any topic, with no evidence at all. And keep saying it forever. It’s how you justify 15 years of sitting on your butt, instead of working. There really are people who…

  • "If This Situation Had Been Normal All Along, the Opportunity Wouldn’t Have Been Available to Me." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site:  Then why haven’t you had the same level of success and acclaim as well as wealth, in comparison to Bogle and Shiller? I am on my way, Anonymous. It’s a process that is playing out before our eyes. It’s a drama that can only end one way. The trick is not to get scared when it looks like the bad guys are close to shutting it down. If it had been up to me,…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "Your Assumption Is That, If You Could Post Whatever You Wanted at Any Board, the Stock Market Would Behave Much Differently." 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “Your abusive and even criminal posting behavior has blocked access to the information that those of us who want to buy stocks to support our old-age retirements need to perform the job that we need to perform for the market to do its job of setting prices properly. ” You are referring to your banning at the various financial boards, correct? Therefore, your…

  • We Need a Tim Russert in InvestoWorld 1 Comment

    When Tim Russert died recently, lots of people came forward to tell us what made him so special. He asked tough questions in a polite way. That's pretty much it. But that's a lot. When someone asks tough questions in a polite way, we learn stuff. That makes us a better people. Tim Russert made us a better people. You cannot ask much more of a guy than that, can you? We need a Tim Russert in Investoworld. We need that really, really, really, really badly. My background is in…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "We Don’t Need to Seek Revenge and Call People Names Like You Do. We Decided Long Ago to Keep Working and Saving So That We Don’t Have to Struggle in Retirement. I Can’t Imagine Having to Go Back to Work at Your Age After Being Out of the Market for So Long." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I am still going to be doing the honest-posting thing. So how are you Goons better off?” We are already just fine. We post honestly instead of trying to convince people about being perceived as honest (when you are not). We don’t need to seek revenge and call people names like you do. We decided long ago to keep working and saving so that we don’t have to…

  • "Would I Not Be an Awful Person If I Believed These Things and Just Kept Them to Myself? I Would Be Letting You Ruin Yourself and Not Even Trying to Warn You Beforehand. Wouldn't That Be Pretty Darn Low Behavior? I Care." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently put to another blog entry at this site: That sounds reasonable. Did the same person also write: Yes, the same person wrote both things. I have spent a lot of time thinking about these things and I have strongly held views. But I am a flawed human. I get things wrong from time to time. There are millions of good and smart people who do not agree with me. Everyone who hears my words needs to know that. I DO believe what I say. I AM…

  • "My Mother Grew Up in the Great Depression, Brought on By an Earlier Try at Seeing Whether Doing the Opposite of What the Peer-Reviewed Research (Which Wasn't Available at the Time) Teaches Us We Should Do. She Had to Leave School When She Was in Eighth Grade So That She Could Work in a Factory to Put Food on the Family Table. My Mother Loved School. That Hurt Her a Great Deal. She Talked About That Pain Until the Day She Died. Does That Matter?" 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Clearly your responsibility to the world (as you see it) is equal or higher priority than your family responsibility. This is a point of view that we ordinary family guys just cannot grasp. If people in Syria are suffering, that’s a shame. But I can’t help them and it doesn’t directly affect me. If my wife is suffering (for an hour, let alone 15 years) that is…

  • "I Have Caused My Wife Pain. I Have Caused My Boys Pain. I Hate the Idea. I Hate It, Hate It, Hate It. Just As Much As Abraham Hated Driving a Stake Through His Boy’s Heart. But Abraham Did What He Felt He Was Required To Do and I Am in the Process of Doing What I Believe That I Am Required To Do and That’s That. Right or Wrong (One Never Knows for Absolute Certain), I Am Just Going to Have to Watch the Thing Play Out to the End. I Do Not Have It in Me to Play it Any Other Way." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: “If you don’t get the $500 million, what will your family do to get by?” Live in a tiny house and forego vacations and the other stuff normal kids get. “You’re on your own for college son, but Dad’s got big dreams for the future! BIG DREAMS!” I wouldn’t include the sarcastic tone if I were the one saying it, Anonymous. But the THRUST of what you are communicating here…

  • "I Don’t Think That I Suffer From a Delusion. I Think That I Suffer From Holding a Minority View on an Issue That Is a Highly Sensitive One for the People Holding the Other Point of View." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “So you say, Anonymous. But I am not convinced.” That’s the issue. Other people have to see value in what you say or do. Otherwise, it is a waste of time. You don’t have that support, but delusionally think you do. I don’t think that I suffer from a delusion. I think that I suffer from holding a minority view on an issue that is a highly sensitive…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "Only a Complete Troll Sits Around Trying to Point Out Other People's Mistakes All Day." 10 Comments

    Set forth below are the texts of several comments that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Only a complete troll sits around trying to point out other people’s mistakes all day. We couldn’t possibly disagree more, Anonymous. Getting the mistakes of the Buy-and-Holders fixed is huge. There’s a lot of good stuff in the Buy-and-Hold Model. When we get the mistakes fixed, it works in the real world. I love working to get those mistakes fixed. I only wish we could…

  • "My Profession Is One in Which You Are Taught to Expose Cover-Ups. So I React Very Differently to Death Threats and Threats of Career Destruction Than Either Bogle or Shiller Do. They Worry That It Would Not Be “Professional” to Point Out That Financial Fraud is a Crime. I Put My Readers First. I Tell the Story." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “He is also a great man, one who has done more to advance our understanding of how stock investing works than any other human alive on the planet today. ” You mean he has done more than you???? Are you sure??? I’ve also done something of huge importance, Anonymous. It drives you out of your mind to contemplate that reality. But it is a reality all the…

  • "Investing Matters. Saving Matters Too, Maybe More. But in the Final Analysis, Investing Matters as Well." 14 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Did you know that only 4.7% of American’s have saved at least $1 million and only 1.8% have $2 million?  The REAL crisis is that people do not have enough money in their savings/investment accounts (just like you).  Let’s talk about what the REAL error is. From May 1999 through May 2002, I posted only about saving strategies. I was a highly popular poster.…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "No One Has to Do a Thing to Please You. We Can't Help It If You Are Too Stupid to Understand Things." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted at another blog entry at this site: No one has to do a thing to please you. We can’t help it if you are too stupid to understand things. We have significant data and facts supporting a buy, hold and rebalance strategy and don’t need some market timing scheme. We are big boys and girls and can make our own judgements and have plenty of information to make up our own minds. You need to take responsibility for ourself and…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "So An Old, Fat, White Male With an Inheritance Is Claiming Persecution" 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: So an old fat white male with an inheritance is claiming persecution. I am claiming that I have the right to post honestly re SWRs and scores of other critically important investment-related topics at any discussion board or blog on the internet at which I desire to do so. And that my good friend Jack Bogle possesses that same right. And my good friend Bill Bernstein too. And my…

  • "I Have Come to Believe That God Put Me on Earth to Do This Work" 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the response that I wrote to a question put to me at my Beyond Buy-and-Hold column by Kathryn C at the Kathryn's Conversations blog: Rob, do you mean “middle class” or just the average investor? I think you mean the average investor, not middle class. (we’re talking about how sophisticated an investor is here right, not if they are middle or upper class?) Thanks much for stopping by, Kathyrn. I understand your question. I use that “middle-class” phrase all…

  • "I Know More About What Works in Stock Investing Than Most Experts in This Field Because I Abandoned Buy-and-Hold in August 2002, When Greaney Advanced His First Death Threat and Hundreds of Buy-and-Holders Cheered Him On." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently put to a discussion thread at this blog: Did you come across as the expert you purported to be? I’ll answer this one separately. I don’t think that there can be such a thing as an investment “expert” today, Banned. We only started doing academic research on investing questions in a systematic way in the 1960s. So we are talking about a field with a history of about 50 years. We are still in the Pioneer days, when we are…

  • "That Explains Why I Am Banned at Every Large Investing Site -- I Never Had Any Success Convincing People. Makes Sense!" 34 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You have been completely unable to convince people.  That is why you have no followers posting here.  This is why you are divorced.  That is why you are broke. That explains why I am banned at every large investing site -- I never had any success convincing people. Makes…

  • "I Certainly Possess a Bias. I Hope That It Does Not Influence My Thinking re These Matters to Any Great Degree. But, If It Did, There’s a Good Chance That I Would Not Be Aware of That. This Is One of Those Darn Paradoxes of Human Existence." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I don’t deny my bias.” Yes, you do. No, I don’t. I think that I am right. If I didn’t think that I was right, I would not say what I say. But of course the funny thing about bias is that it is often the case that a person is not aware of his own bias and the effect that it has on his thinking. A bias can blind a person. And that blindness can…

  • "When Millions of People See 50 Percent of Their Retirement Savings Disappear Into Thin Air for No Good Reason, I Have a Funny Feeling That They Are Going to Know That SOMEONE Is Lying About How This Stock Investing Stuff Works. I Have a Further Funny Feeling That They Are Going To Be Able To Figure Out That It Isn’t Me." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “If I post a link to Shiller’s book, will that one count? ” Just like your website, it doesn’t provide a direct link to any death threats or job threats. It’s not hard, Rob. If the threats exist, then you just provide the links. When you don’t, people know you are lying. When millions of people see 50 percent of their retirement savings disappear…

  • "The Book Is Not an Intellectually Difficult Project. It Is an EXTREMELY Difficult Emotional Project. That's Why No One Else Has Written This Book in the 41 Years Since Shiller Published His Amazing, Revolutionary, Nobel-Prize-Winning Research Findings. It Is an Emotionally Harrowing Experience to Tell Millions of People Something That They Very, Very, Very Much Do Not Want to Hear, That Their Stock Portfolio Is Not Worth Anything Close to What They Have Been led to believe It Is Worth." 25 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I’ve answered your question.” No you haven’t. You haven’t said why you can’t do both at the same time when there are plenty of hours in the day. You seem to have time to post here, on ValueWalk, Twitter, etc. you seem to have time for watching movies, baseball, etc. Yet you have chosen to put your wife and her concerns last when there is plenty of…

  • "It's Different for Me Because I Have Seen the Entire Story Up Close and Personal for 21 Years Running Now. I Can Tell the Story Better Than Anyone Else. And It Is Very Important to Everyone Who Lives in the United States That This Story Be Told Clearly and Completely and Fairly." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: The fact that you allege there is an error and nobody else agrees has nothing to do with getting a job.  Normal and responsible American’s get a job and provide for themselves and family members so that they are not a burden.  This is even more critical when the overall topic is providing for a successful retirement as well.  Why should it be different for…

  • "I Don't Have the Same Level of Fight in Me That I Had in Me 14 Years Ago. I Have Taken a Huge Emotional Hit. In Other Circumstances, I Would Be Ashamed. In These Circumstances, I Am Going to Give Myself a Break." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I have several e-mails in my box this morning from people who came in through that link… I am going to write Barry and ask whether I can have any sort of ongoing relationship with the site. ” So how did that all work out for you? I don’t have an ongoing relationship with Barry today. But I believe that I will in days to come. So I would say that it…

  • "I Had a Big Shot Financial Advisor Call Me on the Telephone Yesterday and Talk to Me for Over an Hour About This Stuff. I Had the Same Thing Happen With a Different Big-Shot Financial Advisor Last Week. Both Are Changing Their Business Models Because of What They Learned From This Site and Because of What They Learned in Their Conversations With Me." 18 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: 1. Soon After the Next Crash, A Number of People Will Say That Their Consciences Will Just Not Permit Them to Keep Quiet Any Longer. 2. Then There Will Be a Deluge of Truth-Telling. 3. Lots of People Will Be Hoping That By Coming Forward Early, They Will Be Able to Avoid Prison. 4. We Will See a Media Frenzy. 5. That Will Lead to Congressional Hearings. 5 sentences. Each one containing…

  • "It Was About Six Days After I Advanced My Famous Post of May 13, 2002, That John Walter Russell Started a Thread About How “Rob Is Really On to Something” and Most of the Retire Early Community at Motley Fool Responded With Great Excitement About the Discussion That I Had Launched. Had the Published Rules of the Site Been Enforced, We Would Have As a Community Corrected the Error in the Buy-and-Hold Retirement Studies in Not Too Long a Time and I Would Have Been on My Way to a Hugely Successful Career in This Field. It Didn’t Happen Then for the Same Reason That Wade Pfau and Robert Shiller Are Not Going to Recommend My Book Today and Make It Happen Now." 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You don’t really need a crash. Just get Wade Pfau and Robert Shiller to recommend your book and then you are all set. You’re right, Anonymous. By all the rules that ordinarily apply in our society, I am all set. In fact, I was all set a long, long time ago. It was about six days after I advanced my famous post of May 13, 2002, that John Walter Russell started a…

  • "I Open the Book By Talking About the Divorce. The Price That People Pay for Telling the Truth About Stock Investing Is a Big Part of the Story." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Here is a title for your new book: “How to lose your money, wife and house by pushing timing schemes”. That's not the title that I am going to use, Anonymous. But I do open the book by talking about the divorce. The price that people pay for telling the truth about stock investing is a big part of the story. If we were all thinking clearly, we would all…

  • "Everything That Has Happened to Me Over the Past 17 Years Is Powerful Evidence That Shiller Is Right re His “Revolutionary” (His Word) Ideas About How Stock Investing Works. Shiller Presented the Theory But Held Back From Discussing the How-To Implications of the Theory. I Explored the How-To Implications of the Theory. Good for Me, You Know? The Theory Doesn’t Help Anyone Until People Come to Understand the How-To Implications." 24 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I will be joking around with Robert Shiller in those days. I will say “Robert, you were kind of a liar re that safe withdrawal rate question for all those years, were you not, my good friend?” And he will say in return “Touche’, Rob, but no more so than you were from May 1999 through May 2002, right?” And I will laugh and we will embrace and we will both…

  • Financial Odyssey Blog Posts "Interview with Rob Bennett" 0 Comments

    The Financial Odyssey blog has posted its Interview with Rob Bennett, from A Rich Life. Juicy Excerpt #1: You need to become friends with the big bloggers. Then they promote you and that’s how you move up. I feel great respect and affection for most of the big money bloggers. But I am not able to endorse Buy-and-Hold! I bill myself as the world’s leading critic of this investing strategy. That has unfortunately caused strained relations between me and a number of the big bloggers in this…

  • "Lots of People Work in Their Sixties. It's Not Exactly a Death Sentence. I Feel a Lot Better Working in My Sixties Than I Would If I Sold Out My Friends and Said That I Now Believe That Greaney Included a Valuations Adjustment in the Retirement Study Posted at His Web Site." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Wrong again. Everyone can Google your retirement plan, investments and stock crash predictions. The history on each shows massive failure. Of course, like always, you run away from it with your answer by failing to talk about your history. I was actually surprised to see you admit on your own website that you have to go back to work in your 60’s. How about…

  • I Gave Investing Advice When
    I Didn't Know What I Was Talking About
    8 Comments

    I take dips into the Post Archives of The Great Safe Withdrawal Rate Debate from time to time, just to see. It can be a weird experience. I’ve learned a lot during the past six years. Going through the archives often puts me face to face with an earlier version of me. Sometimes I am impressed. Sometimes not so much. One time I came across a thread in which people were hitting me with a stick, demanding that I tell them what stock allocation I recommended given that I didn’t think that…

  • "There Are Lots of People Who Try to Be Kinda Sorta Honest to a Limited Extent and Get Away With It. I Want More. I Want to Provide Millions of People Access to Honest and Accurate Safe Withdrawal Rate Studies. I Want to Bring the Economic Crisis to a Full and Complete Stop. I Want People to be Able to Retire Many Years Sooner While Taking on Only a Fraction of the Risk That They Were Taking on in the Days Before We Opened the Entire Internet to Honest Posting." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “My guess is that Shiller’s rationalization is that he can do more good saying things the way he does because at least he gets the message out” What good is getting a message out if it’s the wrong message? MY guess is that your guess is pure speculation based on nothing more than wishful thinking. And that Shiller is saying exactly what he means. You would…

  • Wade Pfau: "If You Read Rob Bennett’s Stuff Carefully, I Think He Did Provide an Important Contribution in Terms of Describing a Way for PE10 to Guide Asset Allocation for Long-Term Conservative Investors. I Also Think He Was Right on the Issue of Safe Withdrawal Rates." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I have made an amazing contribution to the field, there’s no question about that.“ Wrong. There not a single person alive that has said those words, other than you. Spare us the B.S. about how you think people have given you praise. A) Academic Researcher Wade Pfau’s Statements Showing Interest In and Confidence in Rob Bennett’s Work 1) “I do…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "You Constantly Present Yourself As the One Wise, Rational, Sensible Person in a World Where All the Rest of Us Are Frightened Little Rabbits." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “We want to get along with others. We want to have friends. We want to be popular. We want to see people praising us and linking to us.” Among the vast number of things that aren’t helping your cause, your smug, condescending attitude ranks right up there. You constantly present yourself as the one wise, rational, sensible person in a world where all the rest…

  • "It's a Painful Experience to Tell the Truth About Stock Investing. That's Why So Few Do It." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You said you were unable to finish your book and get a job due to emotions.  I guess that means you don’t like what the research really says. What has affected me is the feeling of being an outcast. It's a very painful thing. What Shiller showed is just common sense. OF COURSE valuations affect long-term returns! How else could it be. But Shiller merited…

  • "If I Succeed in Opening Every Discussion Board and Blog on the Internet to Honest Posting re the Last 40 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research in This Field, I Will Have Accomplished 50 Times What I Thought As a a Young Man Was the Most that I Could Accomplish in a Single Lifetime." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “hundreds of thousands of businesses will go under. Millions of people will lose their jobs. Millions of retiremens will fail. Political frictions will worsen. ” We have already seen this with Covid. People that lack emergency savings will want to know how the government will bail them out (like they are doing right now) and those with resources will be picking…

  • "I Play It the Other Way. My FOCUS Is the Goon Stuff. I Focus On That Because That Is The Critical Factor That No One Else Has Explored in Depth. By Focusing on the Goon Stuff, I Am Making a Unique Contribution. That's How I Become Rich and Famous!" 30 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I posted recently to another blog entry at this site: Who are these goons that are standing in your way? How are they standing in your way? One of you Goons put up a reference to “The Law of Thermodynamics” or some such thing the other day. The idea was that this law was a core principle of physics, something that people working in the physics field don’t give up lightly. It is a foundation stone of the science. There are hundreds of…

  • " I Take Bogle’s Ideas and Update Them to Reflect Shiller’s Research. And I Take Shiller’s Theory and Give It Practical Significance By Addressing All the How-To Aspects of the Question That Shiller Ignores." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “But why do you put so much focus on where I rank? ” There are so many out there with opinions. Shouldn’t we give more credence to those that are more expert than others? Absolutely. This is why I became a Buy-and-Holder. When I was putting together my binders to plan my early retirement, I became exasperated that there seemed be as many opinions about…

  • "As the Rewards Grow Greater and Greater, My Ability to Be Honest Grows Stronger and Stronger. I Don’t Even Think About It Much Today, I Just Do It. My Decision to Write Honestly About the Last 35 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research in This Field Has Shocked a Lot of People But It Has Also Led Me to Some Amazing Places." 10 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: With all these people lying, are you the only honest person left? We have had thousands of people express a desire that honest posting be permitted at every investing discussion board and blog on the internet, Anonymous. I am confident that, following the next price crash, the thousands will become millions. Then we are off to the races. We all have a potential…

  • "There Are No Other Learning and Teaching Opportunities with 1/500th of the Potential of This One Available Today in This World." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Other than a few critics, everyone avoids and / or ignores you, yet you don’t want to accept the realities of why this is the case. Instead, you try and cope with a fake story line. I don’t want to be ignored and I don’t want any of the others (about 10 percent of the population) who believe that the last 38 years of peer-reviewed research in the investment…

  • "Showing That Stock Prices Are Set By Emotion Rather Than By Reason Is a Breathtaking Change (an Advance If This Is the Reality). It Changes Absolutely Everything. Shiller’s Research Is Like a Hurricane (a Benevolent One, To Be Sure) Passing Through Our Country. Everyone But Me (Including Shiller!) Has Had the Sense to Run to Get Out of the Way of It Rather Than to Run Towards It and Ultimately Into It."" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Since Shiller did not respond, he clearly did not see any value in what you had to say. I certainly do not agree. All of my work follows from Shiller’s research findings. For Shiller not to find value in my work is for Shiller not to find value in his own work. And, if Shiller stopped finding value in his own work, he would stop doing it. So I feel certain…

  • "The Research That I Did With Wade Pfau Shows Millions How to Retire Five to Ten Years Sooner Than Is Possible With Buy-and-Hold Strategies. If Each of 100 Million People Has Been Willing to Spend Just $1 for Each Year of Financial Freedom Provided to Them By That Research, That Would Have Been $500 Million in My Pocket." 19 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently put to a blog entry at this site: You haven’t suffered $500 million worth of damages. I’ve suffered far more than $500 million in losses as a result of the Campaign of Terror, Evidence. The research that I did with Wade is Nobel Prize-level work. It shows millions of middle-class investors how to reduce the risk of stock investing by 70 percent and how to retire five to ten years sooner than they ever imagined possible…

  • "There Is an Unspoken Code in the Finance Industry That You Don't Call Out a Fellow Investing Advisor Who Is Talking Nonsense" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of an answer that I posted to the Quora site to the question "Why do so many people trust stock analysts, investment banks or big audit firms when their conflicts of interest are obvious and they're involved in fruad scandals all the time?": Twelve reasons: 1) Even the worst of these people mix in lots of true stuff with the false stuff and people are fooled by the true stuff into thinking they are dealing straight with them; 2) The best of these people (a…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "My Posts Have Always Been Based on Truth. You Have Made Many False and Hurtful Allegations Against Very Good People. You Have Given Out Harmful Financial Advice, Despite Having No Training/Education in the Field. Most Importantly, You Have Failed to Adequately Provide for Your Family." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: It was wrong of me to make posts that appeared to make fun of you. With that said, my posts have always been based on truth. You have made many false and hurtful allegations against very good people. You have given out harmful financial advice, despite having no training/education in the field. Most importantly, you have failed to adequately provide for your…

  • Seven Things You Didn't Know About Rob Bennett 2 Comments

    The fellow who writes the My Life ROI blog "tagged" me the other day (this is my first time, so I'm a little nervous). These are the rules that I need to follow in responding to the tag: "7 Things You Didn’t Know About Me” Meme Rules 1. Link to your original tagger(s) and list these rules in your post. 2. Share seven facts about yourself in the post. 3. Tag seven people at the end of your post by leaving their names and the links to their blogs. 4. Let them know they’ve…

  • "I Became Radicalized By Seeing How Hateful & Frightened Buy-and-Hold Can Make a Person" 0 Comments

    Friday's blog entry set forth the text of an e-mail that I received from Edwin at the Finantage blog. Set forth below is the text of my reply e-mail. Edwin: Thanks for your note. Reading it cheered my morning! I am excited to hear about your plans. I think you are handling this in a positive and constructive and life-affirming way. I would like to post the words of your e-mail at my blog. I like to expose my readers to the words of smart and good people who offer a different take…

  • "That Part Is Hard to Write. It Involves Being Somewhat Critical of My Readers. Generally Not a Great Promotional Strategy." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Do you plan to use any ink to comment about Internet Goon Squads? Certainly I need to address the phenomenon. And certainly I need to take care to be fair-minded in what I say. This is the aspect of the thing that makes it difficult to write about. The Goon part of the story is the relatively unimportant part of the story. Sure, there was a lot of abusive stuff…

  • "My Behavior Is 'Anti-Social' If You Define the Word as 'Upsetting Large Numbers of People In a Serious Way.' But They Wouldn't Be Upset AT ALL If They Could Appreciate the Full Story. How Do We Get to That Place? We Don't Get There By Me Shutting Up." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: And yet you became, as you proudly proclaim, “the most hated man on the internet”. One doesn’t gain such a title without generous amounts of antisocial behavior, no? My stuff causes great pain to large numbers of people, Anonymous. That is a stone cold fact. I am a journalist. The job as a journalist is to tell the truth, not to be popular. Woodward and Bernstein are recognized…

  • "I Care About the People Who Read My Stuff. I Am Incapable of Lying to Them." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: So that list shows what SHOULD have happened. But we know what HAS happened. The scoreboard is showing a massive, epic blowout. If you took the field today against the Patriots, all by yourself, the final score would be closer than your competition with the Goons. And yet, you see nothing wrong with your game plan. I am not happy with the results that we have seen…

  • "One of the Most Ridiculous Is That Buy-and-Hold Led to the Depression and to the Current Crisis" 5 Comments

    Edwin Ivanauskas, owner of the Finantage blog, wrote me an e-mail on May 11 detailing his plans for writing a series of articles re my criticisms of the Buy-and-Hold investing strategy and his reactions (both positive and negative) to those criticisms. Set forth below are his words. I will post the text of my response in Monday's blog. Last week we had a brief back and forth on your guest post at popeconomics.com.  I promised to write a lengthy response in my own site.   I wanted to…

  • "I Don't Seek to Take Over Any Discussions. It Just Happens. The Reason Why It Happens Is That the Things I Say Make So Much Sense to Most People and Most People Have Never Before Heard Anyone Say These Things. So They Naturally Are Interested and Want to Learn More. So They Naturally Ask Lots of Questions. And the Next Thing You Know One of the Buy-and-Holders Feels Bad That I Have Yet Again 'Taken Over' a Discussion." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: What they take issue with is the way you seek to take over every discussion and make it about yourself and your views. I don’t seek to take over any discussions, Sensible. It just happens. The reason why it happens is that the things I say make so much sense to most people and most people have never before heard anybody say these things. So they naturally are interested and want to…

  • "My Father Loved His Country. He Knew That Those Who Resort to Those Sorts of Tactics Thereby Tear the Social Fabric of His Country Apart. He Understood That Those Sorts of Tactics Are Not Within the Scope of the Tactics by Which Disputes Are Resolved When His Country Is Working in Tune With Its Foundational Beliefs." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Rob, you have only to look at your father and to me for two immediate counterexamples that totally disprove your claim. My father experienced the Great Depression (caused by a widespread belief in the core Buy-and-Hold “idea” that consideration of price is not necessary when buying stocks that developed during the 1920) not as an investor but as a child. It left a mark. He…

  • "It Was My Love for My Fellow Community Members That Drove Me to It." 26 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Stop evading the question, Rob.  What made you go off the deep end? It was my love for my fellow community members that drove me to it. The humans will do it to you every…

  • "Everyone Alive Will Offer Better Investment Advice Once We Have Opened Every Discussion Board and Blog to Honest Posting re the Last 41 Years of Peer-Reviewed Research in This Field. My Contribution Is to Get Every Site Opened to Honest Posting. Then All of the Others Will Be Able to Do Much. Much Better Work." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Do you feel that you can offer the same or superior investing advice versus  people like Wade Pfau, Michael Kitces and/ or Bill Bernstein? I think that everyone alive will offer better investment advice once we have opened every discussion board and blog to honest posting re the last 41 years of peer-reviewed research in this field. My contribution is to get every…

  • "I Only Post About One Subject. But It Is a Very Important Subject and There Are Hundreds of Angles To It. So Posting About That One Subject Keeps Me Busy. The One Subject Is Long-Term Market Timing." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: How about posting something of value. You have repeated this same stuff over and over again. Try posting something new. While you are at it, why don’t you explain to readers as to why you won’t provide and proof (links) to your claims of job threats and death threats. I only post about one subject. But it is a very important subject and there are…

  • "It's the Cover-Up That Is Outrageous, Not My Reporting On It. The Only Way to Bring the Cover-Up to an End Is for People to Report on It. It Is Because Too Many Have Been Afraid to Report on It For So Long That We Are All In the Fix We Are in Today. I View My Reporting On the Cover-Up As a Beautiful and Brave Thing, Journalism At Its Best. I Am Honored and Humbled To Do This Important and Very Difficult Work and Very Proud of the Efforts That I Have Directed to Bringing This Cover-Up To an End." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Actually, you only give one side of your deluded story in Valuewalk, yet make those outrageous statents on your own website on an almost daily basis. By the way, Jack is NOT your good friend. It is just another spin you give to your stories. When you were asked about this a look time ago, you stated you became his friend by reading his books. The "honest"…

  • "The Delay Is Because of the Social Isolation. It Is an Extremely Painful Experience. No One Else Has Written This Book. Why Do You Think That Is? Shiller's Nobel Prize-Winning Research Has Been Publicly Available for 41 Years and No One (Including Shiller Himself) Has Written a Full Exploration of the Far-Reaching Implications of His Nobel-Prize-Winning Work." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Since you ignored the question, obviously your book is nowhere near completion, and you will miss yet another self-imposed deadline. That book would be done by now if you had put in just five minutes of serious work every day. Clearly any amount of serious work on anything is too much to expect from you. I'll probably miss the June 30 self-imposed deadline. But…

  • "I Will Acknowledge That These Views Are Extreme If You Go By the Continuum of Viewpoints Held Today. But It Is Not Right for Me Not to Express My Sincere Views. If Everyone Who Holds This View Says to Himself 'I'll Keep It Zipped Until Lots of Others Are Saying This.' The View Will Never Be Publicly Expressed. Someone Has to Be the First to Say These Things." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted at another blog entry at this site: From today’s post by you on this exact topic, which you agree can’t be proven one way or the other: I am telling you what I believe, Anonymous. I stand by those words. If I said anything different, I would be telling you a lie. I am not able to imagine any circumstance in which the promotion of Buy-and-Hold strategies would not cause an economic crisis. Once you tell people that…

  • "I Didn't Know About the Cover-Up of the Error in the Buy-and-Hold Strategy That Shiller Revealed in His Research from 1981 (the Error Is the Idea that Long-Term Timing [Price Discipline] Is Not Required). The Cover-Up Had Already Been Going On for 22 Years at that Time. I Didn't Know, Just As Most People Today Don't Know. I Had No Idea What I Was Getting Into. I Was Just Trying to Help Out My Board Community. Then the Roof Fell In on Me." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: In reading your own words, you have stated that you have banked your future on getting a settlement statement. Do you need to be reminded again of your own words? You have stated that you do not have a back up plan and you do not have enough money to fund your remaining years in retirement. As to the thousands of people you speak of, they are all part of…

  • "One Time I Asked If I Could Stay at His =House for a Few Days and His Response Was That He Would Impose Only One Condition, That I Promise Not to Talk About Stock Investing." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You made some money from a report on soapbox.com about 25 years ago You made a few posts on Motley Fool that got 100+ likes You self published a book a short time later which does not seem to have sold well You have spent about the last 20 years trying to write your second book and seem no closer to finishing it now than you were when you started You let…

  • "My Primary Project Today Is Writing the Book 'Investing for Humans: How to Get What Works on Paper to Work in Real Life.' I Expect to Finish That By the End of the Year. At That Time, My Intent Is to Seek Employment in the Corporate World. I Will Continue to Write My Weekly Column and to Respond to Blog Comments and to Contact Other Sites at Nights and on Weekends. I Can Continue Doing That Indefinitely Even If There Is Not Money Coming in From the Investing Work." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of several comments that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: If another 20 years passes and you don’t get your story in The New York Times and you don’t see a dime of the $500 million payout, will you come to the conclusion that you wasted your time? I think that another 20 years would just about do it, Anonymous. I am a stubborn cuss. But a person struggling to make his way through this mixed-up world of ours has…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "I Don’t Think You Have Ever 'Conformed' to Anything. If You Did, You Would Not Be Broadly Banned From the Investment Community, Nor Would You Be Broke or Divorced." 30 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I felt intense social prssure to conform” I don’t think you have ever “conformed” to anything. If you did, you would not be broadly banned from the investment community, nor would you be broke or divorced. I've conformed to U.S. law, Anonymous. I've conformed to what the last 41 years of peer-reviewed research teaches us all about how stock investing…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "Which Means That You Are the Most Important Person in the History of Personal Finance. What Else Could Justify the Many Years of Pain, Abuse and Deprivation?" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Which means that you are the most important person in the history of personal finance. Of course, you’re too modest to say so yourself. But what else could justify your many years of pain, abuse and deprivation? Can’t decide though which of these is correct: a) Rob Bennett is as important as Bill Gates and Steve Jobs. b) Rob Bennett is MORE important than…

  • "I Told My Boys That This Was the Bible and That It Was the Word of God and That They Needed to Learn its Lessons to Live Their Lives Properly. And I Added: “But Your Dad Would Never Do That!” I Sometimes Wonder If God Was Playing a Little Joke on Me (If So, It’s Not Funny, God!) By Placing Me in Circumstances in Which I Would Be Asked to Place Stakes in Both of My Boys’ Hearts SLOWLY AND GRADUALLY Over the Course of the Following 14 Years Since I Was Such a Smarty Pants As To Question the Way Abraham Was Asked to Show His Obedience." 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Some dads work to support their families. Others wait around for something to happen. Others still accept the call to serve their country when their country is in greater immediate need of their services. This country provides great opportunities for families that work hard, as does mine. But if this country collapses, my family will be hurt in a very serious…

  • "For So Long As I Believe Those Two Things, I Would Be Committing a Felony (Financial Fraud) By Leading People to Believe That It Is My View That They Don’t Matter." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: How long should we wait for things to play out? You can wait as long as you please, Anonymous. Or you can not wait at all if that’s your preference. You decide for you. No? I am going to wait for so long as I believe that the Greaney retirement study (and other Buy-and-Hold retirement studies) lacks an adjustment for the valuation level that applies on the day…

  • "You Are Our New Leader" (But Please Note Correction!) 0 Comments

    The author of the Pop Economics blog let me have a sneak preview of the Guest Blog Entry that he posted yesterday a few hours before he put it up. Set forth below is the text of the e-mail I sent to him to let him know my take. Pop: I love it! It's 100 percent perfect. I've been waiting for someone to do something like this for eight years now. You are our new leader! My only question is -- Is there any chance that you could give me the JPEG file for that image? I have no particular…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "The Difference Is That Todd Tresidder States His Opinions and They Are Just That. The Rest of Us Have Opinions As Well. With You, There Is a Strong Agenda and You Want to Be the Center of Attention, Have Everyone Agree With You and Then Be Considered Some Kind of Financial Expert to the Level of Someone Like Bill, Jack, Etc." 46 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that one of the Goons recently posted to another blog entry at this site: The difference is that Todd states his opinions and they are just that. The rest of us have opinions as well. With you, there is a strong agenda and you want to be the center of attention, have everyone agree with you and then to be considered some kind of financial expert to the level of someone like Bill, Jack, etc. the fact remains that you have been proven wrong time and…

  • "How Long Have You Been Seeing a Therapist? Has it Been Helping?" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: How long have you been seeing a therapist?  Has it been helping? It's been a bit less than two years. I've been seeing the current person (who I like a lot) since October 2023. I was seeing someone else for about three months before that. The pace of progress on the book has picked up a small bit over the past three months. But I am nowhere close to finishing…

  • "Others Saw the Campaign of Terror and Ran in Fear Because of the Money and Power Possessed by the Wall Street Con Men. I Saw Opportunity." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: And, how’s that workin’ out for ya so far, slick? LOL It’s working out pretty darn well, since you asked. I don’t have a penny in my hands today. But look at what I do have — the most valuable web site on the internet. There are going to be millions of people looking for someone to sue to recover their retirement money following the next price crash. I have 13 years of Post…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "You Must Deal With the Consequences, Just Like Anyone Else That Does Not Behave in a Proper Way." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I offer zero apologies for my behavior, Anonymous. ” Then you must deal with the consequences, just like anyone else that does not behave in a proper way. If someone has a drinking problem or a drug problem, but won’t seek treatment, we don’t just give them a pass. Neither should you get a pass. We all have crosses that we have to carry in this…

  • "What Matters to Me Is the Journalism Question -- Permitting People to Have the Discussions They Want to Have -- and the Human Psychology Question -- the Incredible Ability We Humans Possess to Engage in Self-Deception, Even When It Does Us Great Financial Harm." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ The reaction we have seen from people who have been exposed to my thinking says a lot.” Yep. It is dead silence. No one is interested. Even your ex-wife didn’t agree with your thinking. That is why she is your ex. If the reaction had been dead silence, you Goons would never have advanced a single abusive post. It was the strong positive reaction to…

  • "There Are Three Things Necessary for a Message to Have Great Financial Value to the Person Delivering the Message: (1) It Must Be Powerfully Important Content; (2) There Must Be Strong Interest in Hearing the Message; and (3) the Message Must Be in Short Supply." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion  thread for another blog entry at this site: Are you saying that if you were not banned at the various financial boards, you would be making millions by now? Obviously. Now, there’s another way of looking at it. What if Bogle had given his “I Was Wrong” speech on the day after he learned about Shiller’s “revolutionary” (Shiller’s word) research findings? Then would I have made millions…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "I Will Mark You Down as Someone That Won't Listen" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread at another blog entry at this site: I will mark you down as someone that won’t listen. Okay. Please take good…

  • "The Title of the Book Is 'Investing for Humans.' That's a Bold Title. Has There Never Before Been a Book Showing Humans How to Invest in Stocks? The Incredible Reality Is That There Has Not Ever Been One." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Setting aside the last 20+ years, what single accomplishment have you achieved in the last 5 years? I had a huge accomplishment in early 2019, when I finished my article "Buy-and-Hold is Dangerous." Finishing that article told me that I now possessed a sure enough grasp of what happened with Buy-and-Hold to be able to write a book about it. I haven't finsihed…

  • "I Think I Should be Paid Millions for Being a Professional Actor. Unfortunately, No One Wants to Pay Me for Being an Actor. As Such, I Found Work That I Could Do That People Said They Would Be Willing to Pay Me for Doing. You Need to Do the Same." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: I think I should be paid millions for being a professional actor.  Unfortunately, no one wants to pay me for being an actor.  As such, I found work that I could do that people said they would be willing to pay me for doing.  You need to do the same. The amount of interest that I have seen in Valuation-Informed Indexing during the first 23 years of discussion…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "You Are a Quintessential Don Quixote." Rob's Response: "This Nation Is a Don Quixote Nation. People Tell Us Good Things That We Are Trying to Do Are Impossible and we Go Ahead and Do Them Anyway." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You are a quintessential Don Quixote. This nation is a Don Quixote nation, Laugh. People tell us that good things that we are trying to do are impossible and we go ahead and do them anyway. Call us all…

  • "The Scary Thing Is That Rob Is An Optimist" 2 Comments

    Jennifer at the Live Richly blog offered some fine comments re The Troubles in a recent post of hers titled Will You Retire on Your Stocks? Juicy Excerpt #1: I started reading some guest posts by Rob Bennett of Passion Saving, and found out that his stance on buying when stocks are cheap and not when they are expensive is a controversial one. To me, this just seems like common sense, but apparently many advocates of buy-and-hold won’t even let Rob give his point of view. Juicy Excerpt…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "The Real Return Between July 1996 and July 2014, Counting Dividends, Is 5.9 Percent. You Claim to Have Everything in 3.5 Percent Real TIPS. Please Explain How 3.5 Percent Is Greater Than 5.9 Percent, and Show Your Work." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently added to another blog entry at this site: “If you do the math, you will see that you are wrong. There have been six different people who have done the numbers on my personal situation. I have been following VII strategies for 18 years and I have been ahead of where I would have been had I followed BH strategies for a long, long time.” That comment was posted July 2014. Took me just seconds to find an S&P 500 historical…

  • Rob Bennett 99 Comments

    Rob Bennett's A Rich Life blog aims to put the "personal" back into "personal finance" -- he focuses on the role played by emotion in saving and investing decisions. Rob developed the Passion Saving approach to money management; Passion Savers save not to finance their old-age retirements but to enjoy more freedom and opportunity in their 20s, 30s, 40s, and 50s -- because they pursue saving goals over which they feel a more intense personal concern, they are more motivated to save effectively.…

  • Google Knol #3 -- Rob Bennett 1 Comment

    I've posted my third Google Knol. This one is entitled Rob Bennett. Juicy Excerpt: Rob Bennett graduated from Temple University, in Philadelphia. He majored in Political Science. He holds a law degree from the Columbus School of Law at Catholic University of America, and a Masters in the Law of Taxation from George Washington University School of Law.  Rob covered the IRS and Capitol Hill beats for The Daily Tax Report, a newsletter published by The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc.,…

  • "The Old School Safe-Withdrawal-Rate Studies Did Not Contain Valuation Adjustments. Lots of People Either Did Notice It or Could Have Noticed It Had They Been Paying Attention. But I Am the One Who Noticed It and Went Public With What I Noticed and Then Didn’t Back Down. That's How Great Discoveries Are Made." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: Do you think you should be awarded a Nobel prize? Should you be Time Magazines man of the year? Should you be on the front page of The New York Times? I think the work that I have done over the past 13 years is of huge importance, Anonymous. The work that I have done is built on the work of many others. As I have noted many times, there would be no Valuation-Informed Indexing today had…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "What Circumstance Would Finally Lead You to Conclude That You in Fact Are Wrong?" 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Then under what circumstance would finally lead you to conclude that you, in fact, are wrong? If (as I suspect) you can't answer that, then saying "it's possible that I am wrong" is nothing but false humility. I would need to see peer-reviewed research supporting the idea that there is no need for investors to practice price discipline when buying stocks.…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "Write Your Own Book and Say What You Want to Say, But Leave Everyone Else Alone." 23 Comments

    Set forth below is a comment that I posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “But he never actually says those words.” And there you have it. Shiller says what HE is thinking, not what Rob Bennett wants him to say. You do this with almost everything. You twist around what people say, or don’t say, in order to make it seem like everything aligns to what you want. You somehow feel as if everyone needs to say what you want and that people need to let you say…

  • "My Wife Is 100 Percent Confident That I Have Achieved Huge Advances in This Field. She Needs to Tell Herself That I Had Something to Do With the Bad Stuff or She Would Lose Her Faith in Humanity. I Think That She Is Pretty Darn Representative of How Other People Think About These Matters. We Have Never Seen This Level of Corruption in Any Field of Human Endeavor in the United States." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: To you this is an open-and-shut case. To everyone else, it’s madness. Yes, literally everyone else, including Mrs. Bennett. Does it ever occur to you that you might (gasp!) be wrong? In the early days, I thought it was possible that I was wrong. On the morning of May 13, 2002, my confidence level was 90 percent. That’s a high confidence level. But it…

  • "I Had Posted With a Good Number of People at the Motley Fool Board for Three Years and Had Gotten to Know Them and to Care About What Happened to Them." 20 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I’ll do what I can to get along.” Not really a plan when you are in your 60’s. It’s now to late to say you will wait to see how it will all turn out. We see how it played out. It failed. It's about 500 times better than betraying my friends and then not knowing how I am going to be able to sleep at night, Anonymous. I had posted with a good number of…

  • "Once We Got the Greaney Study Corrected, It Was My Intention to Take the Discussion to Every Site on the Internet and Determine What It Is Within Us That Makes Us Want to Deceive Ourselves as to How Stock Investing Works." 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: And you have been told 10’s of thousands of times that there no error as the study did not require that. It is a retrospective study. It is surprising that any board owner would let you post the same thing hundreds of times. Thousands of times is abusive. 10’s of thousands is a whole new level of horrible behavior and there was obviously no choice but to…

  • "I Live in a Nation of People. Many of Those People Have Helped Me Live a Better Life. Doctors. Scientists. Teachers. Policemen. On and On and On and On. I Would Not Be Able to Sleep at Night If I Sold Those People Out." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Do you regret it enough to say that you made the wrong decision? No. I live in a nation of people. Many of those people have helped me live a better life. Doctors. Scientists. Teachers. Policemen. On and on and on and on. I would not be able to sleep at night if I sold those people out. I sincerely believe that the Greaney retirement study lacks an adjustment…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "I Am Guessing Your Own Wife Agrees More With Me Versus You." 6 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: I am guessing your own wife agrees more with me versus you. I don't agree with that. She hates the Goon stuff. She has total contempt for it. The sense in which she agrees with you is that she believes that a husband and father needs to be bringing in money, that there's just no getting around that core reality. She doesn't understand the investing stuff well…

  • "If I Had Showed Investors How to Reduce Investing Risk by 10 Percent, I Would Be on the Cover of Time Magazine. The Problem With Showing Them How to Reduce Risk by 70 Percent Is That It Makes the Buy-and-Holders Look Bad. That's the Only "Problem" With What I Have Done, I showed the Way to Too Big an Advance in Our Understanding of the Realities. What a Bad, Bad Boy, You Know?" 8 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Seriously, Rob. It is like saying you look forward to joining Lebron James in winning an NBA championship. Your life is just an internet fantasy. You're entitled to your opinion, Sammy. But I would by lying to you if I told you that I share it. I have had many big names tell me how important my work has been to them. Wade told me that he learned many…

  • Jaime Tardy to Rob: "I Saw Your Speech at Ignite. I Was Sitting With a Few Millionaires, and Their Reaction Was That You Were Very Bitter About This. They Didn't Understand Why You Were Talking About the Haters So Much." 31 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of an e-mail sent to me by Jaime Tardy, owner of the EventualMillionaire.com site, on November 7, 2013: Hi Rob! So I'm going to be completely honest here. If thats ok! (If not, stop reading! ;) I think you need to let go of the attacks. I think it makes the story a negative one instead of a positive one. Yes- there are haters, but we can't let the haters get into the story. I saw your speech at ignite. I was sitting with a few millionaires, and their…

  • Financial Samurai "Can't Understand the Rift" Behind Lindauer/Greaney Smear Campaign 6 Comments

    The Lindauer/Greaney Goons took their Smear Campaign to a thread put up last week at the Financial Samurai blog entitled "The Dark Side of Early Retirement." I objected with these words (Post #47): "Of course I have never spammed your site or any other site one time in my entire life, Sam. "My “reputation” is the result of the fact that I am the person who discovered the analytical errors in the Old School safe withdrawal rate studies back in May 2002. The former owner of the Early…

  • "I Am Just Waiting for the First Person to Come Up to Me and Exclaim “You Are So Lucky to Have Been the Person to Discover This!” I Am Going to Punch That Person in the Nose, You Know?" 16 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: If what you are doing is not working, perhaps you should try a different path. I am not capable of posting dishonestly re the numbers that my friends are using to plan their retirements, Anonymous. It’s just not in me. For good or for ill, I think it would be fair to say that I am stuck for life on the path that I walked onto on the morning of May 13,…

  • Goon Poster to Rob: "You Have Your Agenda and Want To Spread It On Every Thread, Even When It Is Not the Subject Being Discussed. You Think That Your Points Are More Important Than What Anyone Else Has to Say, Yet Give No Consideration to the Opinion of Others. If It Doesn't Mesh With Your Line of Thinking, You Say That People Are Lying or Afraid and That Is Just a Bunch of Bull." 21 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: A contributing factor of you getting kicked off all those sites is the factbthat also don’t listen. You have your agenda and want to spread it on every thread, even when it is not the subject being discussed. You think that your points are more important than what anyone else has to say, yet give no consideration to the opinion of others. If it doesn’t mesh with your line of thinking, you…

  • "I Couldn't Be Happier. I Am Humbled to Have Played an Important Role in the Process by Which We All Are Discovering How Stock Investing Works in the Real World." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: Almost any investing strategy has given better results than what you have had, Rob. To use your words, has it been a "purely rational experience" to stop woking a job at the age of 43 and then to put all of your financial hopes on some fantasy that you will get an imaginary $500 million windfall. Yes, it has been a 100 percent rational experience and a 100…

  • "I Have Come to Have Doubts As To How Much a Technical Background Counts for in This Field Today" 2 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently put to the Value Walk site: I think your comment is super, Buzz. I am grateful to you for taking the time out of your day to share your thoughts with us.  Also, I just want to note that I do not possess any particular "technical experience" in this field. My training and experience is as a journalist. I learned in the late 1990s (from reading a book by John Bogle -- "Common Sense on Mutual Funds") that Reversion to the Mean…

  • Goon Poster at Value Walk Site: "All One Needs to Do Is Read Your Posts and See That the Vast Majority of Your Posts Include Complaints About What You Think of Shiller, Bogle, Pfau and Others. You Want to Talk About Taking People Down, Down, Down. Just Read Your Own Posts." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I posted in the discussion thread for a recent entry at my weekly column at the Value Walk site: Rob, My comments are based on the truth and supported by facts. All one needs to do is read your posts and see that the vast majority of your posts include complaints about what you think Shiller, Bogle, Pfau and others. You want to talk about taking people Down, Down, Down? Just read your own posts. Tell us again about people going to prison, or…

  • "The Moment in Which I Pushed the “Send” Button on That Famous Post of the Morning of May 13, 2002, Was My Finest Moment in the 62 Years in Which I Have Been Walking Planet Earth. All of the Learning Experiences That We Have Enjoyed Together Over the Past 17 Years Had Their Origins in That Single Moment of Personal Courage and Honesty and Good Will Toward My Fellow Community Members." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted in response to another blog entry at this site: I guess Shiller is going to prison as well, right? We will decide as a society who goes to prison and who does not. I doubt very much that Shiller will be in the group that will be going to prison. But I am highly confident that Shiller will be expressing regret that he did not speak up re lots of critically important investment-related topics in a clear and firm and simple…

  • "Michael Kitces and I Are Friends. You Are Right, Though, That He Keeps His Distance From Me. I Am 'Controversial.' I Shouldn't Be. Everything That I Say Just Follows Naturally From Shiller's 1981 Finding That Valuations Affect Long-Term Returns. If Shiller Is Right, 90 Percent of the Investing Advice That People Have Heard in Recent Years Is Wrong." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I put to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: I am sure you will write more articles from this in which you explain how this expert, like all other experts are wrong and how you are right. It goes along with how you say Michael, like the other experts, "pull their punches" as you have this unique ability to read their minds. Just to note, it is interest how Michael, like many other experts, no longer speak with…

  • "I Have Made Contributions That Neither Bogle Nor Shiller Have Made. I Give My Best Shot to Answering Every Question Put to Me. I Struggle Mightily to be Honest in the Face of Enormous Pressures to be Otherwise. But the Idea That I 'See All the Issues' Is Flat-Out Nuts." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: So Bogle, Shiller, the goons, etc., are either lying, misunderstood, don’t care, ignore and/or suffer from cognitive dissonance and only Rob Bennett has been able to clearly see all of the issues and has the only clear understanding as to how the market dies or should act. Have I got that right? Bogle has brought scores of critically important investing insights…

  • Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: "Are You the Only One Posting Honestly?" 5 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Are you the only one posting honestly? I’m certainly not the only one who includes ANY honesty in his posts. But I think it would be fair to say that I have shown more of an unwillingness to post DIShonestly than anyone else working in this field. Take Bill Bernstein. He said back in May of 2002 that you need to subtract two points from the safe withdrawal…

  • "Have You Ever Had an Academic Researcher Who Was So Impressed By Your Stuff That He Elected to Devote 16 Months of His Life to Researching It in Depth and Then Concluded That It All Checked Out? On the Morning of May 13, 2002, I Would Have Told You That Such a Thing Was Impossible. But Here We Are." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ 10 percent of the American public loves my stuff. I have had more effusive praise directed at me over the past 22 years than any other poster in any of our communities that I can think of.” None of that is real. You live in an imaginary world. Yeah, yeah. Have you ever had an academic researcher who was so impressed by your stuff that he elected to…

  • "There are Five Factors That Explain Why I Am Perceived Differently: (1) I Focus on the Findings of Peer-Reviewed Research Rather Than Express a Personal Opinion; (2) I Attack Buy-and-Hold As Well As Advocate Valuation-Informed Indexing; (3) I Make Expansive Claims That Strike Most People As Grandiose; (4) I Do Not Possess the Credentials That Would Make People Respect the Claims; and (5) I Seem to Be Questioning the Personal Integrity of People With Stellar Reputations." 9 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: There IS no such such Ban, as you well know. The only applicable ban is the one regarding a single mentally ill persistent troll, for his rotten BEHAVIOR, not for his bizarre beliefs. Shiller can post, Easterling can post, etc. Any of a host of perma-bears, timers, wave-speculators, kooks, cranks, swindlers, and nuts can post on pretty much any board out there. In fact, right up until his…

  • "There Were Numerous References in the Movie to How He Was an Idiot Who Was Going to Lose His Job. It Was an Important Theme. The Guys Who Believed in the Pre-Research Stuff Hated Him as Much as You Goons Hate Me. Research Was as Much of a Threat to Them as It is to You." 10 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: The Brad Pitt character had a job.  Even he lost his job, he would then go get another job.  His character was successful, you are not.  You are nothing like his character.  You don’t have one single thing in common with that character. There were numerous references in the movie to how he was an idiot who was going to lose his job. It was an important theme.…

  • "The Job of a Journalist Is to Help People By Explaining Things to Them That They Do Not Yet Fully Understand. It Wouldn't Be Possible to Imagine a Story That Helps More People Than This One That Is As Poorly Understood As This One. The Potential to Help People Live Better Lives That Exists Here Is Just Off the Charts." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for one of my columns at the Value Walk site: I look at results, Rob. It has been a disaster for you. Despite your attempts, there is no way to spin it any other way. I did not study investing in school. I have never managed a big mutual fund. I should not know more about this subject that any ordinary investor. Wade Pfau holds a Ph.D. in Economics from Princeton. I should not be able to teach Wade…

  • "It's About 500 Times Better Than Betraying My Friends and Then Not Knowing How I Am Going to Be Able to Sleep at Night. I Had Posted With a Good Number of People at the Motley Fool Board for Three Years and Had Gotten to Know Them and to Care About What Happened to Them." 10 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “I’ll do what I can to get along.” Not really a plan when you are in your 60’s. It’s now to late to say you will wait to see how it will all turn out. We see how it played out. It failed. It's about 500 times better than betraying my friends and then not knowing how I am going to be able to sleep at night, Anonymous. I had posted with a good number of…

  • The Pop Economics Guest Blog Is Not Merely Live -- It's Positively Psychedelic! 0 Comments

    My long-delayed Guest Blog Entry at Pop Economics has finally gone live. No -- wait. "Live" doesn't say it. It's positively -- Psychedelic! Take a look and tell me that's not a fair thing to say! Juicy Excerpt: For those of you unfamiliar with Rob, he’s a regular on pretty much every personal finance blog that mentions investing and hasn’t banned him....Iit’s been done in such an odd way (blog comments that are longer than articles, a conspiratorial tone, oddly capitalized words as…

  • Goon Poster: "I've Dealt With the Mentally Ill Before and I've Found That They Can Sometimes Be Reasonable If Gently Redirected. Rob, Take This as Friendly Advice -- Your Condition Can Be Managed with Meds. You're a Smart and Articulate Guy and You Could Be Making Valuable Contributions to This Discussion." 4 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that a poster named "Wab" (he used to post with me at the Early Retirement Forum and is now one of the Greaney Goons) recently put to another blog entry at this site: Why haven’t you responded to the many questions that I have put forward that are each at least 500 times more important than the matter you keep bringing up? Because I’ve dealt with the mentally ill before, and I’ve found that they can sometimes be reasonable if gently…

  • "The Doctor Said That, If I Sincerely Believe That the Greaney Retirement Study Lacks a Valuation Adjustment, I Need To Be Locked Away for the Safety of Society." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Have you ever had a mental health evaluation? Yes. The doctor said that, if I sincerely believe that the Greaney retirement study lacks a valuation adjustment, I need to be locked away for the safety of…

  • "My Own Wife Faults Me for Using the Term “Goons.” I Dedicated My Life to This Woman and She Has Dedicated Her Life to Me. But Every Now and Again She Feels the Need to Get in a Little Dig at Me for My Use of the Word “Goons” in My Writings. I Stand Pretty Much Alone in My View That the Goon Issue Is of Supreme Importance, That It Is Perhaps the Most Important Public Policy Issue of Our Day." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to another blog entry at this site: “I would be if it were not for you Goons” Your answer to so many questions. It’s not just you Goons who don’t like me using the word “Goons” or talking about the Goon phenomenon. John Walter Russell spent eight years of his life researching my ideas. He was the biggest supporter that I ever had. But there were several occasions when he chastised me for talking about…

  • "I Have a Chapter in My Book Called 'My Mother Speaks From the Grave Against Buy-and-Hold.' My Mother Was Born in 1917. So She Was 12 Years Old When the Crash of 1929 Hit. She Had to Leave School in Eighth Grade to Work in a Factory to Put Food on the Table for Her Family. My Mother Loved School and Was Denied an Education Because of the Buy-and-Hold 'Idea' of Not Practicing Price Discipline When Buying Stocks. So This Is Personal for Me." 0 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You already said you depleted your assets. Why would you even wait to get even near that point. Why are you selling out your family? My family has to live in this country, Anonymous. I obviously want to take care of my family. But part of taking care of my family is taking care of my country. I need to do both. I cannot throw either one overboard and still live…

  • "Let’s Say That Shiller Changes His Mind and Tells People That We Should Time the Market with CAPE and Then He Gets Rich from People Buying His Books With This New Message………..but Then You Are Still Ignored and You Don’t Earn a Single Dime From All This. Are You Okay With That Outcome?" 30 Comments

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Let’s say that Shiller changes his mind and tells people that we should time the market with CAPE and then he gets rich from people buying his books with this new message………..but then you are still ignored and you don’t earn a single dime from all this.  Are you okay with that outcome? I wouldn't be happy about it. But I could live with it. I see it as a…

Featuring Top 200/304 of Rob Bennett

Subscribe

Read more

Browse Rob Bennett

  • “We All Possess a Sincere Desire to Invest Effectively for the Long Run. But the Get Rich Quick/Buy-and-Hold Impulse That Resides Within All of Us Compromises Our Efforts. We Need Open Discussion of the Peer-Reviewed Research to Strengthen Our Resolve.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Buy and Holders, by definition, continue to buy regardless of the daily swings of the stock market.  The failures you describe are clearly market timers.  These are the people that make emotional responses to the daily fluctuations and THEIR perception of the stock market valuation.  This is why the top 10% continue to consolidate ownership of stock.  You are a market timer, Rob.  You are broke. Do Buy-and-Holders adjust their stock allocation in response to changes in valuations? That’s the question on the table, Anonymous. Do Buy-and-Holders Stay the Course in a meaningful way? Valuation-Informed Indexers do that. We engage in valuation-based market timing. That’s the only difference between Buy-and-Hold and Valuation-Informed Indexing. VII is Buy-and-Hold updated to reflect the last 44 years of peer-reviewed research in this field. It’s a big difference. As long as most investors are Staying the Course in a meaningful way, irrational exuberance, the cancer of the personal finance world, cannot get out of control. Stock prices are self-regulating so long as honest posting re the peer-reviewed research is permitted at every internet site. We all possess a sincere desire to invest effectively for the long run. But the Get Rich Quick/Buy-and-Hold impulse that resides within all of us, compromises our efforts. We need open discussion of the peer-reviewed research to strengthen our resolve. My sincere take. Rob Related Posts“At the Very Bare Minimum, We Need to Make It a Practice to Tell Both Sides of the Story. Reasonable People Need to Absolutely Insist on That Much.”“Is There Any CAPE Level at Which Stocks No Longer Represent a Bargain According to Your Perspective on Things?”“You’re Not Adjusting for Irrational Exuberance. If You Adjust for Irrational Exuberance, You Get Very Different Numbers.”“You’re a Liar. I Might Just As Well Say That You Are a Human. It Comes With the Territory. The Question Is Whether You Want To Make Use of the Tools Now Available to All of Us Who Want to Be More Honest and Thus More Successful Stock Investors.”“The Idea Behind Valuation-Informed Indexing Is to Take the Emotion Out of the Stock Investing Project. All That We Need To Do To Stop the Horrible Losses Is To Stop the Insane Highs.”“Buy-and-Hold Is a Marketing Gimmick. People Would Be Better Off Being […]

    (No Comments)

  • “It Is the Roller Coaster Ride Created By the Buy-and-Hold Mindset (No Price Discipline When Buying Stocks Now!) That Causes All the Crazy Ups and Downs. All of That Is Optional Today and Has Been for 44 Years Now, All We Need To Do At This Point Is To Get the Word Out.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: The sellers are market timers because they don’t have enough dry powder. Someone sitting there with only a few hundred thousands has no ability to hang on for the long term. They will always bail during any perceived time of risk. I have already shared some of my details. You probably remember that my portfolio generates $300K plus a year in interest and dividends. I also have other sources of income. I don’t need to sell and I just keep doing just like the rest of the top 10% in that I keep accumulating assets. It is fine if you don’t want to hold stock. People like me will continue to buy. Remember the old saying: “The are two types of people with McDonald’s. One type is the customer that buys the burgers. The other type is the guy that owns McDonald’s (stock). Pick which one you want to be. Valuation-Informed Indexers don’t count phony gains as real. So they don’t perceive risk in the disappearance of the phony gains. They are looking at the realities and the realities of stock investing are very reassuring — gains of 6.5 percent real annually. It is the roller coaster ride created by the Buy-and-Hold mindset (no price discipline when buying stocks now!) that causes all the crazy ups and downs. All of that is optional today and has been for 44 years now, All we need to do at this point is to get the word out. Irrational exuberance is the cancer of the personal finance world. Shiller’s Nobel-prize-winning research is the cure for cancer. We should permit people to partake in the cure. Rob Related PostsValuation-Informed Indexing #264: Shiller’s Findings Revolutionize Our Understanding of How the Economy Works Too“Some People Have Been Waiting Since the Mid 90s for Stocks to Be Cheap Enough (in Their Opinion) to Buy.”“Those 29 Years Were Not Good Years for Stock Owners.”Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: “If Buy and Holders Did Not Have Confidence, They Would Have Done Something Different.”Valuation-Informed Indexing #596: Stock Prices Drift Upward Unless Most Investors Practice Market Timing“Shiller Showed Us That It Is Primarily INVESTOR EMOTION That Determines Stock Prices, Not Economic Developments. So We All Need to Make a Switch to Talking Primarily About Investor Emotion. We Should […]

    (36 Comments)

  • “The Idea Behind Valuation-Informed Indexing Is to Take the Emotion Out of the Stock Investing Project. All That We Need To Do To Stop the Horrible Losses Is To Stop the Insane Highs.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Yep. Market timers are selling there stock and just look at how everything has been consolidated at the top. Not surprising and it is not just stock. Take a look at real estate holdings and how that has changed over the years. You can decide if you want to follow those that have been successful or you can go with the 90% that struggle. The people who you are calling “market timers” are just Buy-and-Holders who have lost confidence in their strategy. Buy-and-Hold is a confidence game. Excessive confidence causes prices to go to crazy high levels and excessive pessimism causes prices to go to crazy low levels. The idea behind Valuation-Informed Indexing is to take the emotion out of the stock investing project. Those times of low prices are horror stories. We should all want to bring an end to them. To do that, we need to focus on what causes them. It’s high prices that cause the insane price drops. All that we need to do to stop the horrible losses is to stop the insane highs. That’s done with valuation-based market timing. Valuation-based market timing is the key to long-term investing success. Irrational exuberance is a snare and a delusion, Anonymous. It is not real. It hurt us. We should all work together to to keep it from getting out of control. We should all work to keep the CAPE level at a reasonable levels. My sincere take. Rob Related Posts“We Don’t Accept the Phony Numbers. We Fear the Emotional Pain We Experience When Our Longstanding Game of Let’s Pretend Is Exposed to Daylight. We Are ASHAMED.”“The Losses That We Need to Cover as a Result of the Continued Promotion of Buy-and-Hold ‘Strategies’ are $24 Trillion, $6 Trillion More Than the Entire Federal Debt of $18 Trillion, Constituting All the Annual Budget Deficits Going Back to the Days of George Washington Added Together. Buy-and-Hold Is Truly Bad Stuff.”“Market Timing Is the Thing That Permits the Market to Do its Core Job — Get Prices Right. It Is Market Timing That Keeps the Market Functional.”“Is There Any CAPE Level at Which Stocks No Longer Represent a Bargain According to Your Perspective on Things?”“Child Porn and Slave Trading and Murder for Hire Are Far, Far, […]

    (6 Comments)

  • “Say That the Alcoholic Beverage Industry Con Men Didn’t Want to Acknowledge Their Mistake. They Might Say That the Explanation for the Millions of Deaths That They Caused Is That Six Beers Isn’t Really Enough, That People Need to Drink a Minimum of Eight Beers Before They Can Drive a Car Safely.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I do not intend to write fresh material.” When did you ever write fresh material? I have never seen anything new. Valuations affect long-term returns. That’s the story. It’s a pretty darn simple message. But it’s important. Say that that the alcoholic beverage industry got control of all the driving schools and put out a message that the key to safe driving is always to drink six beers before getting behind the wheel. That would be a catastrophe equal to the catastrophe that we have seen in the investment advice field with this garbage about how there might be some alternate universe in which valuation-based market timing might not be 100 percent required for every investor. Say that that the alcoholic beverage industry con men didn’t want to acknowledge their mistake. They might say that the explanation for the millions of deaths that they caused is that six beers isn’t really enough, that people need to drink a minimum of eight beers before they can drive a car safely. And on and on like that. When you make a mistake this big, the best thing to do is to acknowledge it and move on. Covering it up just makes things worse. My sincere take. Rob Related Posts“I Used to Believe in the Buy-and-Hold Garbage. I Know How It Feels to Be Tricked Re This Stuff. Legitimate Strategies Can Be Defended Without Death Threats. I Earned My Retirement Money. I Expect to Be Able to Find Accurate and Honest Reports re What the Peer-Reviewed Research Says About How to Invest It. I Deserve That. We All Do. We All Should Demand It.”“The Fact That Wade Pfau Won’t Speak to Me Today Definitely Tells a Tale That Needs to Be Widely Told.”“The Wall Street Con Men Are Not Convinced That Buy-and-Hold Cannot Work. They See the Holes in the Concept. They Become Insanely Defensive When Challenged. But They Tell Themselves That Buy-and-Hold May Work Well Enough. They Tell Themselves That There Is Nothing Better.”“There Are Cases in Which Someone Drinks Six Cans of Beer and Does Not Get in an Accident. So Those Who Follow the Buy-and-Hold Approach to Data Analysis Say: ‘You Cannot Look at the Number of Cans of Beer Consumed to Know If There […]

    (12 Comments)

  • “Maybe It’s Okay to Believe It So Long As You Don’t Give Voice to What You Believe in a Public Place.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: No, we are all not victims.  Reasonable people know that they are responsible for their own well being.  Making up these silly posts are not helping anyone.  It seems your therapist has his work cut out for him. Anyone who believes that the Greaney retirement study lacks a valuation adjustment must be nutso. Or maybe it’s okay to believe it so long as you don’t give voice to what you believe in a public place. Rob Related Posts“It Means It [the Greaney Retirement Study] Never Needed Correction and That It Has Been Explained to You Well Over a Thousand Times.”“Is It My Failure If Many Buy-and-Holders Did Not Call for the Greaney Retirement Study to be Corrected Even Though It Is Obvious to Anyone Who Checks That It Lacks a Valuation Adjustment?”“I’m Not the One Who Permitted the CAPE Value to Rise to 37. That Was the Buy-and-Holders. That Number Suggests That It Is Today’s Stock Market That Needs a Therapist.”“Do You Think That I Should Lie About My Belief? Should I Say That It Appears to Me That the Greaney Retirement Study Contains a Valuation Adjustment Even Though My Sincere Belief Is That It Lacks One?”“You Need Either to Point to the Page in the Greaney Retirement Study Containing a Valuation Adjustment or Join Me in Insisting That He Correct the Error Immediately.”“At the Very Bare Minimum, We Need to Make It a Practice to Tell Both Sides of the Story. Reasonable People Need to Absolutely Insist on That Much.”

    (No Comments)

  • “Unfortunately, There Is a Feeling Among Some Buy-and-Holders That They Will Not Be Perceived as Super Duper Experts If People Come to Learn That They Didn’t Always Know It All. “

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You are always the victim, aren’t you Rob.  The whole world has orchestrated a mass conspiracy against you and even your ex-wife is in on this scheme.  Poor Rob. We are all victims of this massive act of financial fraud, Anonymous. We all would be living richer and freer and happier and better lives if every site on the internet had been opened to honest posting re the peer-reviewed research in this field on May 13, 2002, as I proposed at the time. I is not possible for the Rational human mind to imagine any possible downside, I mean, come on. Learning is this world one true free lunch. There was a time when we didn’t know all that we needed to know to invest in stocks successfully for the long run. Now we do. Shiller was awarded a Nobel prize for his research because it represented such a huge advance over what came before. Unfortunately, there is a feeling among some Buy-and-Holders that they will not be perceived as super duper experts if people come to learn that they didn’t always know it all. Well, they didn’t. I don’t think that the mistake they made was that big a deal. But the cover-up of the mistake has hurt millions of people and hurts more each day that it continues. We all need to pull together and insist that every site be opened to honest posting re the peer-reviewed research so that we can all move forward together into a better tomorrow. Where I’m coming from. Rob Related Posts“The Bennett/Pfau Research Shows That Market Timing Is 70 Percent of What It Takes to Achieve Long-Term Stock Investing Success. So 70 Percent of What We Hear From Investment Experts Should Be Telling Us Ways to Avoid Getting Sucked in By the Get Rich Quick/Buy-and-Hold Garbage.”“I Certainly Am Not Going to Demand Prison Sentences If Most Others Do Not See a Need for Them.”“My Buy-and-Hold Friends Are Good and Smart and Hard-Working People. They are Trapped in Unfortunate Circumstances. But They Want To Be Giving Sound Investing Advice. I Know Because I Have Talked To a Good Number of Them re How They Feel About All This.”“This Is a Field Where People Don’t Admit Their Mistakes. The ‘Experts’ […]

    (No Comments)

  • “Say That There’s a 1 in 100 Chance That What I’ve Been Saying for 23 Years Now — That the Greaney Retirement Study Lacks a Valuation Adjustment — Is Accurate. After 23 Years of This Stuff, I Personally Would Put the Odds at 99.9999 Percent. But Let’s Say for Purposes of Discussion That There’s Only a 1 Percent Chance That Greaney Got the Numbers Wrong in His Study. If There’s a 1 Percent Chance, Then We Should Be Talking About It at Every Site on the Internet.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: “ I did many things to help her. She owns her own home today. That came from money that I provided” From what money? You haven’t worked in 25 years. Meanwhile, your ex-wife has been working multiple jobs the whole time. Notice you even admit in your last post, like you have done before that she needed you to bring in an income. There is zero excuse for ANYONE to not support his family if you are physically able. I don’t think that there’s any excuse for anyone who knows about the 44-years cover-up not to do everything in his or her power to bring it to an end. It affects the retirement accounts of millions of people. I couldn’t sleep at night knowing that I was aware of the problem and just let another Buy-and-Hold Crisis take place. Say that there’s a 1 in 100 chance that what I’ve been saying for 23 years now — that the Greaney retirement study lacks a valuation adjustment — is accurate. After 23 years of this stuff, I personally would put the odds at 99,9999 percent. But let’s say for purposes of discussion that there’s only a 1 percent chance that Greaney got the numbers wrong in his study. If there’s a 1 percent chance, then we should be talking about it at every site on the internet. Greaney isn’t the only person who advanced that loony-tunes 4 percent rule. There are millions of people who put together their retirement plans thinking that that was something real and who need to be advised that it was all just a scam. How do you think that word is going to get out if no one works up the courage to stand up to you Goons. There’s no other way that it could happen. And look at today’s CAPE level. It’s pretty darn scary. If we had opened every site to honest posting re the research on the afternoon of May 13, 2002, as I proposed at the time, we would obviously never again have to endure such an insanely dangerous CAPE level. We would have people explaining why valuation-based market timing is the key to long-term stock investing success at every site. How do you think we are going […]

    (2 Comments)

  • “The Thing That Is Really Off in the Investment Advice Field Is That the Non-Experts — the People Who Will Be Suffering Huge Losses in the Event That the Stock Market Continues to Perform in the Future Somewhat As It Always Has in the Past — Tolerate the Cover-Up. That’s Nuts. But They’ve Got That Get Rich Quick Impulse Residing Within Them That Makes Them Like Buy-and-Hold, that Makes Them Think That This Might Be the First Time in History When It Doesn’t End in Tears for Everyone.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Did you care about what happened to your ex-wife’s retirement account? Very much so. If we experience another Buy-and-Hold Crisis, she is one of the millions and millions of people who will get hurt by it. I obviously don’t want to see that happen. The question is — Why do we not apply the same rules that apply in every field other than the investment advice field in the investment advice field as well. That’s what makes sense. In every other field, we apply laws that show that we understand that experts can make mistakes and that those mistakes need to be corrected over time. So we permit honest posting re new research and thereby provide a means for the experts to come to terms with the mistakes that they have made and to develop stronger ideas. The thing that is really off in the investment advice field is that the non-experts — the people who will be suffering huge losses in the event that the stock market continues to perform in the future somewhat as it always has in the past — tolerate the cover=up. That’s nuts. But they’ve got that Get Rich Quick impulse residing within them that makes them like Buy-and-Hold, that makes them think that this might be the first time in history when it doesn’t end in tears for everyone. Can we overcome it? I believe that we are working up to that magic moment. I believe that the arc of history in the personal finance field bends toward rationality. I believe that opening up one large site to honest posting re the peer-reviewed research will get us over the line will get us there. At that point, my ex-wife and millions and millions of others will be able to have some confidence that the numbers on their portfolio statements are accurate. I see that as being a huge step forward. We’ll see. Rob Related Posts“We Don’t Accept the Phony Numbers. We Fear the Emotional Pain We Experience When Our Longstanding Game of Let’s Pretend Is Exposed to Daylight. We Are ASHAMED.”“Peer Pressure Is a Huge Influence on the Human Mind. Bull Markets Are the Product of Peer Pressure. Buy-and-Hold Is the Product of Peer Pressure.”“Jeff at the Sustainable Life Blog […]

    (No Comments)

  • “You Are Broke. You Are Divorced. You Got Everything Wrong. Take Responsibility and Stop Blaming Everyone Else.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: You are broke.  You are divorced.  You got everything wrong.  Take responsibility and stop blaming everyone else. And I was right about the Greaney retirement study lacking a valuation adjustment. Rob Related Posts“I Developed the Ideas Tested in the Study That I Co-Authored with Wade Pfau. Wade Did Great Work Testing Them and Proving Their Legitimacy. He Never Tried to Hog Full Credit for the Study. He Said Many Times That He Considered Me the Lead Person Behind the Development of the Valuation-Informed Indexing Concept and That He Believed That the Shift from Buy-and-Hold to Valuation-Informed Indexing Is the Biggest Advance That We Have Seen in the Investing Field in Many, Many Years.”Goon Poster to Rob: “Why Do You Continue to Do What You Do? Clearly You Are Not Making Any Money.”“You Are Broke. Who Got the Numbers Wrong?”Buy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: “You Are a Quintessential Don Quixote.” Rob’s Response: “This Nation Is a Don Quixote Nation. People Tell Us Good Things That We Are Trying to Do Are Impossible and we Go Ahead and Do Them Anyway.”Goon Poster to Rob: “Any Wife Would Be Saddened by a Husband Who Is Capable of Working But Hasn’t ‘Made a Dime in 13 Years.’ Since You Acknowledge That Fact, To What Extent (If Any) Does It Bother You?”“That Explains Why I Am Banned at Every Large Investing Site — I Never Had Any Success Convincing People. Makes Sense!”

    (18 Comments)

  • “Buy-and-Hold Fails Every Time There Is a Change in Valuations and There Is an Investor Who Fails to Change His Stock Allocation”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site; Just because you say something, it doesn’t make it true. Buy and hold has never failed and you cannot point to one single person with a buy and hold failure. To the opposite, you can’t point to even one single successful outcome with market timing. You are broke, Rob. You lost the game. You got everything wrong. Everyone abandoned you. You fail to acknowledge your long list of mistakes. Buy-and-Hold fails every time there is a change in valuations and there is an investor who fails to change his stock allocation. I mean, come on. Even the Buy-and-Holders say that investors should seek to “Stay the Course.” Well, an investor who stays at the same stock allocation when the CAPE value has changed is not exactly staying the course, is he? The Buy-and-Holders got it right about staying the course and about following the peer-reviewed research. They got it wrong about there not being a need to practice valuation-based market timing. Price discipline is critical in all markets. We now have 44 years of peer-reviewed research showing that the stock market is not the sole exception to the common-sense rule. Buy-and-Hold is a marketing gimmick. It’s what sells. Valuation-Informed Indexing (Buy-and-Hold updated to reflect what we’ve learned from the last 44 years of peer-reviewed research) is what works. I would permit honest posting re the peer-reviewed research at every site and see what happens. Rob   Related Posts“Shiller Has Never Put Forward a Single Word Suggesting That Investors Should Not Be Using CAPE to Practice Effective Long-Term Timing. If It Is True That Valuations Affect Long-Term Returns, As Shiller Showed, Then Long-Term Timing MUST Work.”“There’s Risk in Long-Term Market Timing? Huh? Long-Term Market Timing Is Price Discipline. The Risky Thing Is to Exercise Price Discipline? I See It Just the Other Way Around. I Exercise Price Discipline With Every Single Good and Service I Buy. The Risk Is in FAILING to Exercise Price Discipline.”“The Peer-Reviewed Research Looks at the Entire History of the Stock Market While Your Scoreboard Is How Things Feel at a Moment in Time When Irrational Exuberance Is Out of Control and the CAPE Value Is Scary High.”“The Buy-and-Holders Don’t Subtract for Irrational Exuberance When They Determine Whether Their Retirement Is Fully Funded […]

    (No Comments)

  • “The Buy-and-Hold Team Has Failed for 23 Years to Insist That the Greaney Retirement Study Be Corrected. The Object of the Game Is Not to Avoid Admitting That You Ever Got Anything Wrong. The Object of the Game Is to Help the People Who Listen to Your Investment Advice. Acknowledging Mistakes Is a Key Part of What It Takes to Win the Game.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: When two sports teams compete, one side wins and the other side loses. The losing team accepts the fact that they were wrong (did not do the right things to win the game). The losing team doesn’t blame the winning team for their own failures. Get the picture? You are broke. You are on the losing team. You made the wrong choices. The buy and hold crowd one the game with consistent retirement successes. Stop blaming those that made the successful people for making the right choices. Accept the fact that you were wrong and are broke as a result of your decisions. The Buy-and-Hold team has failed for 23 years to insist that the Greaney retirement study be corrected. The Buy-and-Hold team lost the game. The object of the game is not to avoid admitting that you ever got anything wrong. The object of the game is to help the people who listen to your investment advice. Acknowledging mistakes is a key part of what it takes to win the game. That’s where I’m coming from re this terribly important matter, in any event. Rob Related Posts“We Don’t Accept the Phony Numbers. We Fear the Emotional Pain We Experience When Our Longstanding Game of Let’s Pretend Is Exposed to Daylight. We Are ASHAMED.”“At the Very Bare Minimum, We Need to Make It a Practice to Tell Both Sides of the Story. Reasonable People Need to Absolutely Insist on That Much.”“Do You Think That the Buy-and-Holders Support This Cover-Up? I Surely Do Not Think That.”“The Side Pushing the Death Threats (the Buy-and-Holders) Are Also the Side Pushing the Pure Get Rich Quick (No Market Timing!) Approach to Stock Investing.”“If Shiller Put Forward a Statement That ‘The Buy-and-Hold Retirement Studies Are in Error and Should Be Corrected Within 24 Hours Because of the Harm That They Will Otherwise Do to Lots of People,’ He Would Get the Same Reaction That I Have Gotten. It Is Not That It Is Rob Bennett Saying the Things That I Say That Causes Buy-and-Holders to Lose Their Freakin’ Minds, It Is the Content of the Message.”“The Primary Effect of Buy-and-Hold Is to Take People’s Attention Away From the Most Important Factor Affecting Long-Term Stock Investing Success — Valuations.”

    (2 Comments)

  • “Buy-and-Hold Is Not Based on Research. Wade Pfau Devoted 16 Months of His Life to the Project of Trying to Find One Iota of Research Showing That Valuation-Based Market Timing (Price Discipline!) Is Not Always 100 Percent Required for Every Investor. He of Course Came Up Empty-Handed. There of Course Is No Such Research. It Is a Logical Impossibility That There Could Ever Be Any. It’s Like Looking for a Perpetual Motion Machine.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Buy and hold is based on research.  Market timing is all speculation as there has never been one successful outcome.  Why go on speculation when we all know what works and what has failed. Buy-and-Hold is not based on research. Wade Pfau devoted 16 months of his life to the project of trying to find one iota of research showing that valuation-based market timing (price discipline!) is not always 100 percent required for every investor. He of course came up empty-handed. There of course is no such research. It is a logical impossibility that there could ever be any. It’s like looking for a perpetual motion machine. Rob Related PostsBuy-and-Hold Goon to Rob: “Valuation-Informed Indexing Failed. You Have Been Wrong. You Just Can’t Bring Yourself to Ever Admit It Because Then You Would Have to Admit That the Last Two Decades of Your Life Have Been Wasted.”“The Thing That They Call a Price Crash Is Really an Emotions Crash.”“Looking for Data to Support the Idea That Market Timing Is Not Required Is Like Looking for Data to Support a Perpetual Motion Machine.”“The Price That Is Set at a Time When Honest Posting re the Research Is Banned Is Obviously Not the Price That Would Apply If Honest Posting re the Research Were Permitted.”“If Buy-and-Hold Were a Real Thing, Those Who Advocate for it Would Welcome Questioning of Their Strategy.”“For Investors to Set Prices Properly, They Need Access to the Information Needed to Make Good Choices. The Peer-Reviewed Research Is Obviously Critically Important Information.”

    (No Comments)

  • “I’m Not the One Who Permitted the CAPE Value to Rise to 37. That Was the Buy-and-Holders. That Number Suggests That It Is Today’s Stock Market That Needs a Therapist.”

    Set forth below is the text of a comment that I recently posted to the discussion thread for another blog entry at this site: Perhaps this is a topic best discussed with your therapist. I’m not the one who permitted the CAPE value to rise to 37, Anonymous. That was the Buy-and-Holders. That number suggests that it is today’s stock market that needs a therapist. I believe that the best possible therapy for a stock market that has produced a CAPE value of 37 is open discussion of the last 44 years of peer-reviewed research in this field. Rob Related Posts“After the Crash, the Floodgates Open. People Will Give Up Their Feelings of Embarrassment and Shame and Become Determined to Get Things Back on the Right Track. At That Point the Owners of the Bogleheads Forum Are Not Going to Be Resisting My Efforts to Take Over. They Are Gong to Be Asking Me to Take Over. We Are Going to Be Friends.”“The Fact That Wade Pfau Won’t Speak to Me Today Definitely Tells a Tale That Needs to Be Widely Told.”“I Used to Believe in the Buy-and-Hold Garbage. I Know How It Feels to Be Tricked Re This Stuff. Legitimate Strategies Can Be Defended Without Death Threats. I Earned My Retirement Money. I Expect to Be Able to Find Accurate and Honest Reports re What the Peer-Reviewed Research Says About How to Invest It. I Deserve That. We All Do. We All Should Demand It.”“The Primary Effect of Buy-and-Hold Is to Take People’s Attention Away From the Most Important Factor Affecting Long-Term Stock Investing Success — Valuations.”Goon Poster to Rob: “Any Wife Would Be Saddened by a Husband Who Is Capable of Working But Hasn’t ‘Made a Dime in 13 Years.’ Since You Acknowledge That Fact, To What Extent (If Any) Does It Bother You?”“The Greaney Study Hasn’t Been Corrected to This Day. What Does That Tell You?”

    (25 Comments)

What’s Here

  • Bennett/Pfau Research (62)
  • Beyond Buy-and-Hold (117)
  • Bill Bengen & VII (8)
  • Bill Bernstein & VII (4)
  • Bill Schultheis & VII (2)
  • Brett Arends and VII (1)
  • Carl Richards & VII (8)
  • Daily Caller Articles (10)
  • Economics — New and Improved! (102)
  • Financial Highway Column (11)
  • From Buy/Hold to VII (381)
  • Guest Blog Entries (96)
  • Index Universe & VII (11)
  • Intimidation of VII Advocates (66)
  • Investing Basics (519)
  • Investing Experts (91)
  • Investing Strategy (55)
  • investing theory (23)
  • Investing: The New Rules (120)
  • Investor Psychology (94)
  • J.D. Roth & VII (17)
  • Joe Taxpayer & VII (14)
  • John Bogle & VII (97)
  • Larry Evans and VII (12)
  • Lindauer/Greaney Goons (471)
  • Michael Kitces & VII (43)
  • Mike Piper & VII (31)
  • Podcasts (200)
  • Reactions to Pfau Silencing (71)
  • Reality Checker (4)
  • Return Predictor (11)
  • Risk Evaluator (11)
  • Rob Arnott & VII (4)
  • Rob Bennett (304)
  • Rob E-Mails Seeking Help (67)
  • Rob's E-Mails to Researchers (1)
  • Robert Shiller & VII (103)
  • Roger Wohlner and VII (5)
  • Saving Strategies (23)
  • Scenario Surfer (3)
  • Scott Burns & VII (8)
  • Silencing of Wade Pfau (96)
  • Strategy Tester (5)
  • SWRs (87)
  • Todd Tresidder & VII (3)
  • Uncategorized (23)
  • Various Experts & VII (33)
  • VII Column (720)
  • Wall Street Corruption (353)
  • Warren Buffett & VII (5)

Rob on the Internet

  • Rob's Weekly Valuation-Informed Indexing Column at the Value Walk Site.

  • Rob's Weekly Beyond Buy-and-Hold Column at the Out of Your Rut Site

  • Rob's Articles at the Financial Highway Site

  • Rob's Articles at the Balance Junkie Site

  • Rob's Daily Caller Articles: (1) Can We Handle the Truth About Stock Investing?; (2) How We Invest Is a Political Question; (3) The Economic Crisis Is Trying to Tell Us Something (and We're Not Listening); (4) Facts Don't Matter; (5) Going Google Stupid; (6) How Much Transparency Can We Handle?; (7) Confessions of an Internet Troll; (8) Conservatives Fall Into a Trap by Blaming Obama for the Bad Economy; (9) Meet the New Media, Same as the Old Media; and (10) How Restoring Honor Will End the Economic Crisis

  • Humble Money Experts Are the Best Money Experts, (Rob's Article in the Integrative Advisor, the Journal of the Association for Integrative Financial and Life Planning)

  • Articles on the Return Predictor, the RIsk Evaluator, the Scenario Surfer and the Strategy Tester

  • The Myth of Buy-and-Hold and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • The Good Side of Stocks' Lost Decade and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • A Better and Safer Way to Invest in Stocks and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • The Economic Crisis Is the Best Thing That Ever Happened to Us and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • The Bankers Did Not Do This to Us! and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • Stock Volatility Kills! and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • The Risks of Buy-and-Hold and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • The Future of Investing and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • What the Stock Investing Experts Don't Want You to Know and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • What's the Best Age at Which to Experience a Stock Crash? and Seven Other Guest Blog Entries

  • Guest Blog Entry Compares Our Effort to Open the Internet to Honest Posting on Stock Investing with the Civil Rights Struggle of the Early 1960s

  • Our Monster Thread (153 Comments!) on Whether Bill Bengen Should Correct His Retirement Study Now That He Acknowledges the Errors He Made In It

  • Google Search Results for the Term "Valuation-Informed Indexing"
  • Favorite RobCasts

    • Bogle and Valuations

    • When Stock Losses Are True Losses and When They Are Not

    • There Is No Free Lunch! Or Is There?

    • Risk Tolerance in the Real World

    • Cash Is a Strategic Asset Class

    • Nine Valuation-Informed-Indexing Portfolio Allocation Strategies

    • Why the Stock Market Does Not Set Prices Properly (Even Though Other Markets Do)

    • Only Valuations Matter -- Everything Else Is Priced In

    • Low Stock Prices Are Better Than High Stock Prices

    • 30 Investment Myths in 60 Minutes

    Links That Matter

    • Ten Bogus Investing Truths

    • Study by Associate Professor Wade Pfau Showing That Long-Term Timing Provides Higher Returns at Reduced Risk

    • Study by Associate Professor Wade Pfau Showing That Valuation-Informed Indexing Beat Buy-and-Hold in 102 of 110 Rolling 30-Year Time-Periods in the Historical Record

    • Wall Street Journal Article Pointing Out That the Idea That Long-Term Market Timing Does Not Work Is a "Myth" of Stock Investing "That Will Not Die" Because "This Hoary Old Chestnut Keeps Clients Fully Invested" Even When It Is Contrary to Their Best Interests

    • Wall Street Journal Article Pointing Out That" "This Ratio (P/E10) Has Been a Powerful Predictor of Long-Term Returns" and That "Valuation Is By Far the Most Important Issue for Investors"

    • The Internet Blowhard's Favorite Phrase: Why Do People Love to Say That Correlation Does Not Imply Causation?

    • Michael Kitces (One of the Bravest of the Good Guys in This Field) Asks: "Who's Really at Risk When Avoiding Overvalued Stocks?"

    • Financial Mentor Article Reporting on How Our Knowledge of How to Calculate Safe Withdrawal Rates Has Grown During the First Nine Years of The Great Safe Withdrawal Rate Debate

    • Does the Trend Matter?

    • Improving RIsk-Adjusted Returns Using Market-Valuation-Based Tactical Asset Allocation Strategies

    • A Value Restoration Project Blog Post That Sums Up in Three Paragraphs All You Need to Know to Become a Highly Effective Investor

    • Year 20 Annualized, Real, Total Return v. P/E10

    • Year 10 Annualized, Real, Total Return v. P/E10

    • Valuation-Informed Indexing Always Superior to Buy-and-Hold Over 10-Year Periods

    • The Valuation-Informed Indexing Advantage

    • What P/E10 Predicted vs. What Actually Happened

    • Normal and Valuation-Adjusted Wealth Accumulation

    • Valuation-Informed Indexers Can Retire Five Years Sooner

    • Following Valuation-Informed Indexing Strategies Reduces Stock Investing Risk by 80 Percent

    • S&P 500 Tracked by P/E10 Level

    • Treasury Inflation-Protected Income Securities (TIPS) Table

    • Best, Average and Worst Returns Since 1871

    • Compound Annual Growth Rate Calculator

    • Investing Through Time

    • Mapping S&P 500 Performance

    • S&P 500 at Your Fingertips

    • S&P 500 Return Calculator

    • Russell's Research

    • Shiller's Data

    • Safe Withdrawal Rate Research Group